I am only going to respond since bb skarm tagged me about it...
My use of Sash Kartana is unique because I use it on a Sash Spam offense, where the team is played in mind of spamming the potential of Focus Sash. In most situations, Life Orb is probably preferred for damage output, or Protective Pads to ensure it isn't worn down to Helmet, Iron Barbs, Static and Flame Body.
However, Sash is not a bad item choice if you can maintain pressure on the opponent to keep rocks off your side of the field. It can force a lot of switches and bait a free Swords Dance, after it kills something and gets to +3 the lack of Life Orb becomes unnoticeable, and you can bait your opponent to revenge kill you and bop them with your Sash. Kartana's speed tier is really strong in this new meta, so usually the opponent has only one or two Pokemon that can jump Kartana, so sometimes having a Focus Sash allows it to snowball. It is really powerful with just having access to SD or grabbing an early boost with Beast Boost, so you honestly do not require LO if your team is setup right, and while Sash might not trigger every match, it does remove some of Kartana"s shortcomings and can bait a lot of things.
I think people only brought up Kartana for its VR/usage stats right? As a whole, Kartana is strong regardless of its item choice, a lot of teams are unprepared to handle it after a SD boost or its Beast Boosts get going. I think most of us could agree on that.
Sorry if my post is a little short, I am reply on mobile. I can provide 2000+ power games with Sash Kartana if needed to prove it is worth discussing, i also used a team with it to make suspect requirements. [Deleted parts of my edit because I'll just DM the person in question about it sometime.]
Can I just say...THANK YOU. I actually used to bait Swords Dances instead of having Knock Off on this set (And Giga Impact was just added bc everyone told me to add it, idk why, doesn't work for me), but I didn't know if it was the right option for overall posting. I actually have plenty of games to post too (I mean, I don't have the replays since I post them all in OU chat, where they eventually just sink into the deep abyss.) Like, frankly, I've literally used ONLY Sash Kartana on my team and have fairly consistently swept about 3/6 Pokemon on average. Honestly, LO, Band, and Scarf are good items, but I feel like people only play it with those items and don't see its potential with other items such as Sash, and they underestimate its Attack and Speed when it holds no item. But you know, what works for some people doesn't work for others. Sash Kartana definitely works for me, but if you all, aside from Shurtugal, don't believe in its competitive capabilities, that's fine by me, but please, if you haven't already, try it before you judge how it isn't strong enough or fast enough, since its a very good competitive mon, and sash is just the one thing it needs to tank that flamethrower and get an added beast boost.
Also, DutroPodoboo (or something like that) said this:
"SD would actually be decent on a sash set, probably over smart strike because of how little steel hits. Sash could potentially give you a free set up so you can do more damage before you're KO'd. +2 leaf blade does a ton to anything that doesn't resist it, and hits fairy harder than an unboosted smart strike would because of its low power. Focus sash is not a great item in this meta because of all the priority + other chip damage that can break sash, but it's certainly not bad"
Honestly, I side with this, but I would get rid of Knock Off instead of Smart Strike for two reasons.
1: Steel STAB
2: Coverage
I mean, I've seen my fair share of Pheromosa in the metagame, and I'll likely continue to. Obviously, Mosa resists Leaf Blade, Sacred Sword, and Knock Off. But it doesn't resist Smart Strike, which definitively helps, since Mosa is a clear threat to Kartana. Although, Mosa is being suspect tested rn, and Knock Off covers other points in OU such as Dragapult, Latios, Spectrier, and all those ghost types in UUBL. So I suppose this would be a better suggestion. I think I'll make an edit to my set rn.
In other news, I might try AV Kartana if that's a good idea.
Last edited: