Just gonna casually claim this 1000 ELO player argument as another argument in favor of a separate Tera meta! New players do still hate bans by instinct, even if older, more experienced players can compellingly point out the ways they work and are reasonable, and a ban to a generation gimmick in particular results in kneejerk reactions. Giving them one less/uncompetitive space still grows Smogon overall, even if it's not contributing to the main OU metagame.Something that I also think may be worth mentioning is that a flat out ban to Tera would be far easier for newer players to understand than a restricted Tera with a bunch of clauses attached to it. What do you think is easier for the fresh 1000 ELO player to understand?
- Tera is banned
- Tera is allowed, but you can't Tera into a type you already are and you have to reveal what Tera types everything is at the start of the battle. Oh and also Tera Blast is banned.
This might seem relatively unimportant, but you have to remember that attracting new players is vital to Smogon's growth and preservation. Having incredibly complicated clauses like this is very off putting for a lot of newer players, because part of what attracted them to Pokemon in the first place is its simplicity.
Edit: Also on this note... gonna say my singular piece on Houndstone, which is that while I do understand the reasoning, I think it's a case of Smogon's bluntness and focus on precedent overriding its optics and its foresight. So far, the thread has really treated it as basic fact that Basculegion is going to get Last Respects. With Swift Swim and Basculegion's overall better stats (higher Speed and Attack with relatively equal defenses due to its HP tradeoff), as well as the blunt knowledge of what IS definitely coming in Home (cmon, this is GameFreak we're talking about, they're not ones to deviate from plans like this) not really including anything on paper that stops it... well, sorry to the council, you guys can explain it all you like, but this is a rare case where y'all could've just banned the move and not kicked up nearly as much of a fuss. Certainly could've saved us all from page after page of discourse, and yourselves from extra mod work. Besides, either way, it's gonna be retested when Basculegion comes out for real.
Last edited: