Qualified response = Evil Smogon elite whose opinion is the only one that matters.
General response = Apart from the above, opinion of the unviable plebs , illusion of democracy in Smogon.
Regarding Garg, Shed Tail and Volcarona: None of them are broken in my book with Volc being the closest one. Still I qualify it as a high risk, high reward Mon, there should be some of those in every meta and there are enough answers.
The only Mon that I would Ban right now is Greninja and that's more due to the strain it puts on building than the actual battle (it's hard to use it well and predict, that's the only thing that balances it).
For personal commodity I would also ban Gholdengo, but by itself it's not broken and never has been, you actually need to use Hazard (Spikes, rocks are not enough), Knock Off support (otherwise 6 Boots team will give you a middlefinger) and Tusk/Treads counterplay to abuse it to the fullest and even then you will occasionally be countercheesed by Maushold, Cinderace or Mold Breaker Hawlucha.
General response = Apart from the above, opinion of the unviable plebs , illusion of democracy in Smogon.
Regarding Garg, Shed Tail and Volcarona: None of them are broken in my book with Volc being the closest one. Still I qualify it as a high risk, high reward Mon, there should be some of those in every meta and there are enough answers.
The only Mon that I would Ban right now is Greninja and that's more due to the strain it puts on building than the actual battle (it's hard to use it well and predict, that's the only thing that balances it).
For personal commodity I would also ban Gholdengo, but by itself it's not broken and never has been, you actually need to use Hazard (Spikes, rocks are not enough), Knock Off support (otherwise 6 Boots team will give you a middlefinger) and Tusk/Treads counterplay to abuse it to the fullest and even then you will occasionally be countercheesed by Maushold, Cinderace or Mold Breaker Hawlucha.