• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

The Dragon-type problem - Balance it or keep it overpowered?

I think we all consider the dragons being mainly designed, for ingame runs, as more of a 'Final Boss' type that is very powerful but needs lots of investment if it suppose to be used by an average player for its playthrough, often not worth the time put into them. Even something like Kingdra needs a very specific item and someone to trade with. As the generations went on, Gamefreak seems to repeatedly change the Dragon-type based on various factors.
From Gen 3 onwards, they decided to add a bunch of Dragons and their accessability and effectiveness increased. Think of Platinum Gabite, BW Gible, Emerald Rayquaza.
Gen 6 was the weirdest to me because they introduced the Fairy-type to counter balance the mistake they made for making Dragon-types too effective and it seemed to work so well, they decided to create stuff like Mega Rayquaza, (Mega) Zygarde Complete, Mega Salamence, that Godzilla Pokemon, Paradox Legendary Beasts, Koraidon, Miraidon and who knows what other needlessly overpowered Pokemon.

Gen 1 Dratini (even Pokemon Yellow Dragonair) I could never imagine using without the Missingno Glitch for infinite items. Dragonite's moveset is colorful but Legendary Birds (minus Moltres), A Water-type, Normal-type, Psychic-type or my Starter were more than enough to get through the game. I don't see Dragonite providing anything those other Pokemon don't do satisfyingly enough. It is not like I want to do Wrap spam against the AI.
But on Lance's side they were decently challenging especially if you have no moves to deal with Dragonite quickly (or a Poison-type to force it to use Super Effective Barrier).

Gen 2 I never had the pleasure to use Kingdra while Dratini seems even less appealing (because now we talk about Johto where EXP is scares).
As a boss, Clair is one of the gym leaders remembered for her difficulty especially since Kingdra is the type of Pokemon you slap on anyone's team to say "here have a challenge". Lance again is a difficult nut to crack since he has 3 Dragonites and all of them have some of the most powerful moves in the game, where getting strong moves is very difficult as well as good Ice-moves.

These were before the Dragons even had a useful STAB option.
Gen 3 you got Rayquaza in Emerald which is a huge power jump and probably the first time the game just hands you, for its time, a broken legendary that happened to be a Dragon-type at a level you would expect a post-game Pokemon to be.
Gamefreak also seemed to solve some issues with making Bagon be closer to its first evolution level and decreasing the evolution requirement for newer Dragons as well as making lesser Dragon-types like Altaria. Personally I think Altaria is pretty awful. Salamance is still too much of an investment since you need to get all Badges to get Bagon. This leaves Trapinch and Horsea as your Dragon-type option again and since the evolution requirement for Horsea didn't change, Trapinch seems to be the most popular Dragon candidate for a playthrough.
I have not tried Trapinch in RSE but I did use it in Colosseum where getting the final form might be the easiest. Getting STAB moves on it is bothersome to the point I had to use a STABless Flygon. Since most moves were Special like Crunch, Fire Blast and Gigadrain it felt like a lesser Pokemon than you would expect.
Now imagine you have to grind up not a Vibrava for 2 levels but a Trapinch from lv21 to 45. Trapinch is a slow and frail Pokemon of the slow experience group that turns into Vibrava at the point you would get Altaria by evolving Swablu. Your best move might be TM28 Dig and you lost in exchange for more speed about 30 base power worth of Attack. So your saving grace is getting STAB Earthquake TM when you get the cover legendary.
So from my viewpoint, in RSE Rayquaza is the only Dragon-type I would consider to use if I were to invest into a Dragon-type while in Colosseum Swablu can be useful to make catching certain Shadow Pokemon to get certain natures or for shiny hunting more pleasant.
As a boss, Drake shows how Dragon-types are still challenging as bosses. Mainly Salamence and Kingdra always being troublesome.

From here on the game seems to hand over easier to get strong dragons as the games are released.
- Diamond and Pearl give you lv47 Dialga or Palkia before the final gym which are strong cover legendaries.
- Platinum gives you early Gible which is a Pokemon that evolves at lv24 to a middle state Pokemon that is actually useful by Pseudo-Standards and Garchomp is at a Level obtainable where the time invested is actually worth it. You also get Giratina.
- BW give you the cover legendaries which are not that good for the point you get them but Axew and Durrudigon are fairly useful for your playthrough. Axew despite evolving pretty late is faster to train than the previous dragons and is putting work in-game before evolving
- BW2 gives you Axew again

After that the Fairy-type and the problems I mentioned earlier appeared where I feel like Gamefreak cannot decide if they want to balance dragons or make more broken dragons for marketing purposes. Both Mega Garchoms seem speficially made in a way to avoid breaking the game, but then we got Mega Salamence making me ask what the point even was.

What are your thoughts?
 
I think Dragon should be a lower-power, early-game type. It's perfect for the first gym: it resits all three starter STABs to get new players to start thinking about coverage or status, but it's not SE on any of them so they get time to figure that out within an attempt. I'd argue that the higher-power Dragons that I currently like are being carried by their other type so it's no big deal if these sort of mons stopped focusing on being Dragon: Salamence's Flying, Archaludon's Steel, Naganadel's and Eternatus' Poison. Iron Jugulis can pull this off, after all.

The mono-Dragon Goodra-Kalos is an exception as a pseudo-legend, but I also prefer it to its stronger Hisuian form despite the latter picking up a favoured type in Steel. Come to think of it, Kalos might just be an exception in general (the result of Fairy getting the biggest spotlight?). My preferred Dragons irrespective of power level are probably Noivern and Dragalge.

You mentioned a lack of a player niche in the earlier generations and I'm not sure how much that's changed. STAB with very few interactions (both weaknesses and resists) is a bit too generalist to slot into a hole the rest of the team produces. Clicking Outrage may be effective off pseudolegend stats, but it's ultimately still pretty boring. The defensive profile is more interesting, but it probably needs to stop sharing the late-game with Ice to really shine in that role. If we ever go back to Rival 2 being a massive threat, that same dynamic I mentioned for the first gym would be a good baseline option.
 
Dragon may be the most prominent example of the conflict between Pokemon as an RPG and as a competitive game. Because the competitive scene wants all types to be (very roughly) balanced, with weaknesses and strengths to exploit. The single-player RPG wants a supertype for bosses to use against the player.

Competitive, I think Dragon has been on a roller coaster, but it's ended up in a good place. It was OP but rare and limited enough for the first 4 gens to be able to be handled with key bans and smart use of a steel type. It was good, to be clear, but problems were usually a sign of greater problems with the game(Wrap Dnite in RBY, Salamence's stats hitting key thresholds with no team preview) than issues with the type. Drag-Mag in Gen V, and the presence of a varied supply of good Dragons in general, broke the type(though everything in Gen V was broken), and Fairy in Gen VI brought it back under control. The type now has very solid offenses and defenses, with obvious weaknesses that can be worked around, and an average stupid-high stat spread to solve problems. It's not OP, but the type certainly isn't weak, and a lot of fairies still fear Iron Head or Sludge Bomb learned from TM and launched off of a comically-high stat.

This roller coaster has been specifically inverted in-game, leaving Dragon in a very awkward place IMO. In the first several gens, Dragons were rare enough, and generally cursed with late evo levels/slow growth rates, to be essentially unusable. Because it's a god-tier typing, they didn't want you using it to sweep gyms from the early game. You CAN find dragons early, sometimes, but it's generally 1 species that sucks for 90% of the game. That changes in Gen VI. With the release of the fairy type, they clearly decided that it was fine to give the player numerous dragons even early on. But now there's enough fairies, steels, and ice-type moves that by the time your dragon has reached it's final form, it's not an auto-win button. That has continued, with dragons being described as rare, powerful mons, but in practice, they're awkward to find and train, and can auto-win some battles, but not all of them, and not enough to be generally worth it. "Dragons are scary" is more of an informed attribute these days, and I think the games are worse for it. This is especially apparent with bosses and legendary mons, because now there's really not a god-tier type they can spam, which leaves the game devs in an awkward space trying to make things work.

Also, as someone who has made Trapinch work, the Flygon line is fine. RSE just hates the mon. It comes right after Wattson and Flannery, two gym leaders where you'd really want a Ground/Dragon. You could use Dig against Norman, except Dig is lvl 45 and therefore you're spending a 1-time use TM on mediocre STAB. Then you have a Flying-type leader with a Skarmory and Altaria, Levitating Psychic types, and 7/10 too much Water(with Ice Beam). In XY Trapinch is actually GOATed, Ground/Rock covers a LOT and he comes along at just the right level/location to contribute.
 
In some runs where I did trade overs from other games, the dragons with their 'peak' power and trade experience did significantly better showing that if grinding up all these Pokemon where not necessary, that would not be such an issue.
Flygon outside of Gen 3 is probably a fine Pokemon but for the amount of investment I don't know if its really worth it.

I tried Pokemon XD Gale of Darkness Dragonite in Ruby and here how it performed

I vaguely remember using Salamence and Flygon in these games too from XD and Colosseum but the Flygon probably had gained experience from the playthrough while Dragonite and Salamence were with ok Natures, no EVs and used at their respective encounter level which is still high with 55 and 50 respectively.

What generally confused me is how much Dialga underperformed every time I used it in a Diamand playthrough. Even when I used one fully EV trained and traded over from another game. Maybe I am doing something wrong, but Dialga feels incredibly underwhelming for in the Elite 4 of Gen 4.

Similar but worse I think it is with Giratina. Maybe if you use a very specific set or boost it with X-items, you can get throught the Elite 4. I don't know if you can get the Origin-form for the Pokemon league in Platinum. I could never get access to it. However, I also tried running the lv70 Giratine fully ev trained in Diamond and here is my experience with that

Modern Gens (aka Gen 6 onwards) I didn't get to use many Dragon-types. Mega Charizard X and Mega Sceptile certainly were excellent and the EXP-Share allows you to carry many Dragons through the game like Garchomp and Salamence.
But I am baffled that something like Noivern exist with such a late evolution level for the type of Pokemon it is. Isn't it basically Special Crobat?

O, before I forget, I am absolutely dumbfounded to see how bad (Mega) Latias is in AS considering I softresetted for good ivs and nature as well as Supertraining it. It was struggling against stuff you would expect it to OHKO like those annoying intimidate dogs. The lack of good moves at that point and having low base power and PP moves really doesn't help.
 
:ss/dragapult:

Dragon has one of the same problems that Ghost does in competitive play, in that being weak to your own Type indirectly incentivizes you to want to be as fast as possible to get the jump on those Pokémon. Dragapult here feels almost like the poster child of this concept, but even back in Gens 4 and 5, Pokémon like Latias, Latios, Garchomp, and Salamence for a time were seeing increased Choice Scarf usage in large part to outspeed themselves with Choice Scarf taking the top spot of Latios’s most common set in Gen 5 OU over the Choice Specs set.

In a single player environment, however, where the player’s Pokémon are much more likely to be faster than the average NPC’s Pokémon anyway due to held items, EVs, all that fun stuff, this distinction for Dragons (and Ghosts) isn’t as pronounced as it is in competitive play, particularly starting around the third generation where Hoenn was the first region to really try and emphasize the Speed stat as a part of the Type’s identity. The other major issue with Dragon that I think makes it sometime under-powered in single player if anything is the availability of these Pokémon, with one or two things usually being the case. Either your chosen Dragon-Type(s) for a team show up and/or evolve too late similar to what we all hate about Ice, or less frequently, Game Freak does include a Dragon-Type earlier on in the main story to find, but save for specific cases like Gible in Platinum, these can take a while to get going along with the rest of your team. Historically speaking, this combination of “you want to be a faster Dragon to outspeed other Dragons” and the tendency of Fire, Water, Electric and Grass to be more associated with the earlygame than the lategame means that while Dragon-Types often do have excellent stats when fully evolved, I actually find them very inconsistent and hard to use both offensively and defensively, since some of the key story matchups they’d like to use their colorful resistance palette against are going to be behind them and the combination of late availability and evolutions makes them harder to use offensively against the traditional lategame staple Types, specifically Ice and Fairy but some Steel-Type Trainers as well.

In fact, I’ll take this one step further. Here is the collective, total list of Dragon-Types, and when you can obtain them that I would recommend using for an in-game playthrough.

-Platinum Gible (Wayward Cave)
-Axew in Unova (Mistralton Cave)
-Druddigon in Dragonspiral Tower in BW1, but only if it’s a Nuzlocke ruleset as this is generally outclassed by Haxorus in the endgame and postgame
-And the famous underlevelled Salamence from Alola if you can manage to find it.

(Side note: I know Galar and Paldea both have other options too but I don’t know where most of them are, it’s been a while since I’ve examined those Dexes)

That’s it. That’s the list. I suppose Trapinch in Hoenn and on BW2 is decent too, but I didn’t include it since it doesn’t start as a Dragon-Type and Flygon loses a key matchup against Steven in Emerald, doing worse against Wallace overall alongside a surprisingly shaky Elite Four run.
 
I feel like a major aspect of Dragon types is just how tied together they are with the Pseudo-Legendaries and how they're almost balanced around one another. Excluding Legendaries (and Alternate forms) a significant chunk of Dragon types are also Pseudo-legendaries, they're so fundamentally joined at the hip with one another that, to Gamefreak, they're to be built around another another.
Which causes almost every dragon type to end up as either a Mon found in the late stage, evolves really late, or if they're available earlier then Gym 6 they're made as pretty average all things considered.
 
bdt2002 said:
In fact, I’ll take this one step further. Here is the collective, total list of Dragon-Types, and when you can obtain them that I would recommend using for an in-game playthrough.

-Platinum Gible (Wayward Cave)
-Axew in Unova (Mistralton Cave)
-Druddigon in Dragonspiral Tower in BW1, but only if it’s a Nuzlocke ruleset as this is generally outclassed by Haxorus in the endgame and postgame
-And the famous underlevelled Salamence from Alola if you can manage to find it.
Kalos exists.

No seriously, if you want to use Dragons in-game, and the idea of sneaking to them in Paldea etc doesn't appeal, Kalos.
Axew shows up in Connecting Cave(the Zubat cave well before Gym 2). Axew evolves late, but it comes with Dragon Rage and has solid level-up moves to keep up with your party.
Bagon shows up right after that. Not a good choice for early game, but it's an option and, of course, becomes a beast later.
Tyrunt is more like Axew, comes early and just has the tools it needs to succeed. Evolves late, but as the main 2-stage on this list, once you get it past the hump of the 30's(and there's a lot of easy training for it during that time), it starts crushing.
Skrelp evolves far too late, but if you're playing Y, it's an effective option once it does.
Charmander-X gets you a dragon at lvl 36 and an extremely easy to use mon for the early game.
Trapinch seems meh, but you get it right before a whole horde of Fire/Poison enemy grunts followed by the Electric gym, which is right at the level where it evolves into Vibrava. And it has the medium-slow growth rate. I cannot overstate how easy this mon is to add to your team.
Gible is the same location and typing as Vibrava, except that it evolves into Gabite earlier but has a worse growth rate. Still highly recommended.
And all of that is before the 4th gym(lvl 35). AFTER that gym you get the game's pseudo-legendary, which is admittedly meh. But still, if you ever want to use an underappreciated type(except Ice), the Kalos games have you covered.
 
Gabite might be the biggest reason why the Garchomp-line performs better in-game than the Flygon-line since it is already a good in-game Pokemon for most of the mid-games while Trapinch is too frail and slow and Vibrava is frail and is as offensively potent as non-Mega Altaria (just without the high base power coverage moves like Flamethrower to make up for the low stats). So in my mind, while it technically takes longer to grind it, you get generally more value if you insist in using it.

I don't remember using Flygon in ORAS but I think it performed better than Gen 3. You get some strong (reusable) TMs by the time you get it and Dig is 80 base power instead of 60.

Some other dragons that stick out to me are the cover legendaries of BW. You get them very late only to beat like 1 Pokemon. They have a cinematic purpose and probably were not meant to be used as an optional member to aid your team, so I think most people don't even consider them. But the interesting part is, the post game has a vast level jump and I think Zekrom (not sure about Reshiram) does kinda help out against the sudden powercreep that awaits you.

Btw, did anyone have a good experience with Turtonator? It is like pre-gen 7 Torkoal but they slapped the Dragon-type on it and expect it to do work. Often I felt it is super frail despite it being a 'defensive Pokemon' but it has been a long while I used it.
 
Castersvarog said:
I feel like a major aspect of Dragon types is just how tied together they are with the Pseudo-Legendaries and how they're almost balanced around one another. Excluding Legendaries (and Alternate forms) a significant chunk of Dragon types are also Pseudo-legendaries, they're so fundamentally joined at the hip with one another that, to Gamefreak, they're to be built around another another.
Which causes almost every dragon type to end up as either a Mon found in the late stage, evolves really late, or if they're available earlier then Gym 6 they're made as pretty average all things considered.
I think this is a good argument. Dragon is one of the rarest types, and yet it's also shoehorned into very specific roles in many of its appearances. Every new generation will only introduce a handful of new Dragon-types, and three of them will be earmarked for the pseudo-legendary archetype. And another couple for full legendaries or "sub-legendaries" (Ultra Beasts, Paradox Pokémon). "Common" Dragon-types will be whatever's left over after those obligations are taken care of, which usually isn't much.

In fact, let's quickly list all Dragon-types that aren't mythicals or legendaries with any prefix (or a temporary form like a Mega Evolution). It's a remarkably short list:
  • Exeggutor-Alola
  • Kingdra
  • Vibrava
  • Flygon
  • Altaria
  • Axew family (3 Pokémon)
  • Druddigon
  • Dragalge
  • Tyrunt family (2 Pokémon)
  • Noibat family (2 Pokémon)
  • Turtonator
  • Drampa
  • Applin family (5 Pokémon)
  • Dracozolt
  • Dracovish
  • Duraludon family (2 Pokémon)
  • Cyclizar
  • Tatsugiri
So we have only two full three-stage families (one with a couple of extra branches), three two-stage families, one three-stage family that's mostly Dragon, one three-stage family where the final evolution is Dragon, three two-stage families where the same applies, and otherwise a bunch of stand-alone Dragons usually found in some late-game area or dungeon. Four of them are fossil Pokémon, although the games are all over the place when it comes to how late those are found.

Overall, there aren't that many Dragon Pokémon whose general design lends itself well to usage for a game playthrough. Most of them are stand-alone Pokémon with too high BST for the early-game, or their families don't obtain the Dragon typing until late game (typically around level 35-40). Axew, Noibat, Applin and maybe Tyrunt are the only ones that feel remotely appropriate to place in the first third of the game, and Noibat is famously bad due to its Zubat-like stats until level 48 (a late evolution level owing to the fact it was originally designed to be encountered at level 44-46 in one of the last dungeons of its debut game).

And that's before we consider regional dexes. Because as previously mentioned, Dragon is over-represented among legendaries of all kinds, and those tend to find their ways into regional Pokédexes more easily than other Pokémon. That means that any new game is likely to fill its "Dragon quota" by featuring a bunch of old pseudo-legendary Pokémon, rather than any of the ones that are appropriate for a full game playthrough. And a new generation is likewise more likely to stack its Dragon-types toward the end of the Pokédex than making any new early-game Dragons. That we got Axew at all is a little miracle in its way (and I chalk that up to Gen V introducing so many new Pokémon that there was plenty of room left to experiment after all the obligatory archetypes were taken care of).

Overall, I consider the Dragon-type a very good argument for cross-generation pre-evolutions. Pokémon like Druddigon, Cyclizar, or Duraludon could be much more accessible to players if they had a cutesy little pre-evolution found in an early-game route. It worked wonders for 'mons like Magmar, Electabuzz, or Roselia, who used to be too late-game to bother with in their debut games, but became staples of game playthroughs when their pre-evolved forms were introduced.
 
Back
Top