-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC The Mafia Invitational Redux Game Thread - GAME OVER
- Thread starter Lrr
- Start date
- Status
????? how are they good posts by me
those posts are strictly mafia theory and are not scumhunting/trying to solve
those posts are strictly mafia theory and are not scumhunting/trying to solve
okay I'm not going to be making a catchup wallpost today from the looks of it so tl;dr summary :
The only scum pings I have noticed so far are from Proph, I didn't like Asek pushing Knights either when I think its completely fine keeping him around and see if he slips later when he no longer has the excuse of not having enough things to work with.
Proph saying he has a scum lean on me but would rather keep me around and see how the read evolves is completely fine
But then in the same post he ends up voting me and looking like he's scrambling to push a counterwagon
Like let's be honest Proph has posts where he looks like legitimately annoyed townie, he put in the effort to make that ridiculously long post too, but there's Hawkie's case making a lot of sense to me, as well as Proph going for me/Leet aka easiest non afk lynches to push at that point in time. This culminates in him openly shading me in #930. His tone read a lot like he's telling us what his thoughts processes are rather than showing them if that makes sense, and I can't even say i'm confident this is a scum tell as I've never seen him being scum before.
I initially intended to sheep Hawkie's convincing wagon and see what happens, but there really isn't any other non-afk player that I'd want to lynch over Proph right now, something like Proph>>>>Dle (??)>Asek>>Hitmonleet with most of the others giving me a lot of town vibes and the rest being afk. Not going to pretend this isn't at least 50% me sheeping Hawkie with no better option in sight but Proph's push onto Leet/me seemed really half hearted and shady. If I'm given a compelling case for another lynch fine by me, atm I don't think I'll be taking my vote off Proph after all.
The only scum pings I have noticed so far are from Proph, I didn't like Asek pushing Knights either when I think its completely fine keeping him around and see if he slips later when he no longer has the excuse of not having enough things to work with.
Proph saying he has a scum lean on me but would rather keep me around and see how the read evolves is completely fine
But then in the same post he ends up voting me and looking like he's scrambling to push a counterwagon
Like let's be honest Proph has posts where he looks like legitimately annoyed townie, he put in the effort to make that ridiculously long post too, but there's Hawkie's case making a lot of sense to me, as well as Proph going for me/Leet aka easiest non afk lynches to push at that point in time. This culminates in him openly shading me in #930. His tone read a lot like he's telling us what his thoughts processes are rather than showing them if that makes sense, and I can't even say i'm confident this is a scum tell as I've never seen him being scum before.
I initially intended to sheep Hawkie's convincing wagon and see what happens, but there really isn't any other non-afk player that I'd want to lynch over Proph right now, something like Proph>>>>Dle (??)>Asek>>Hitmonleet with most of the others giving me a lot of town vibes and the rest being afk. Not going to pretend this isn't at least 50% me sheeping Hawkie with no better option in sight but Proph's push onto Leet/me seemed really half hearted and shady. If I'm given a compelling case for another lynch fine by me, atm I don't think I'll be taking my vote off Proph after all.
Proph's wallpost doesn't look as tl;dr worthy as it did at 1 AM for the record
(" so far" as in "did not read pages 31 to 38 yet)
OK I'm here for like the next hour or so, then I'll be pretty much confined to mobile for the rest of the day, so going to try and do as much as I can right now and then be intermittently checking the thread for the rest of day.
????? I was ONLY looking at your posts when I talked about that. Where in that post did I talk about Walrein?
What in those posts make it more likely that they come from town!Hawkie than scum!Hawkie? Because.. pressuring someone over lack of activity is pretty easy to do as either alignment.Hitmonleet said:
Why exactly were you finding me suspicious other than "i'm sheeping hawkie"?Hitmonleet said:
I'm just gonna tunnel the next idiot to go UR JUST OVERREACTING as if that's a reason to dismiss what I'm saying until they're dead so ppl stop saying stupid crap like that
Also the "this is the same trap as before" is like the easiest line to pull as scum to try and guilt people into not voting you. You play on paranoia of being wrong again and regret of mislynch ing before to get them to back off. Nty
Also the "this is the same trap as before" is like the easiest line to pull as scum to try and guilt people into not voting you. You play on paranoia of being wrong again and regret of mislynch ing before to get them to back off. Nty
Why are you more interested in simply stating what your read on me is, rather than actually engaging with me to make sure if it's right or not?
I'm voting you because I believe that you are scum who is trying to push a mislynch on me. I feel like you're trying to spin what I'm trying to do in as coming from a scum mindset when I'm actually just trying to analyze my wagon, determine who the scum are on it, and then try to lynch that scum. I think the scum in that case is you.
And I'm not pushing Hitmonleet; I'm trying to work out what his alignment is at this very moment. Why do you think most of the active players are town? And more importantly, why are you so focused on being "given" a compelling case to lynch? If you're town, shouldn't you figure out who the scum are yourself and push their lynch, rather than half-heartedly wait for a lynch option to "pop up" and hope they flip scum? This mindset distinction is why I think you're scum - you're moreso focused on finding a good wagon to park on rather than actually trying to solve
Yeti - since you're here, can you talk about your read on me? Because you've kind of made it clear that you don't like some of my posts, yet you're pushing the Leet wagon. Do you think me and Hitmonleet are scum/scum? town/scum? what configuration?
i agree with this every time proph goes well i dont WANT to be mislynched but i also sort of do haha! i
Confirming that you are the only wagon that seems like it might hit scum right now and that I am happy going with that with the rest of the playerlist being mostly divided between town leans and afks. You happen to be standing out to me in the middle of people with very towny tones.
I am 60% confident you will flip red and that is far more than anyone else in the game at the moment (ignoring afks who are literally coinflip lynches). I do not have the time and interest to ask you things regarding your thoughts processes and micro play when your macro screams sketchy to me and that is unfortunately about all I'll be in capacity to provide today.
I am 60% confident you will flip red and that is far more than anyone else in the game at the moment (ignoring afks who are literally coinflip lynches). I do not have the time and interest to ask you things regarding your thoughts processes and micro play when your macro screams sketchy to me and that is unfortunately about all I'll be in capacity to provide today.
ok dipping out
will be checking on mobile for rest of day most likely so get ready for more posts like this one
will be checking on mobile for rest of day most likely so get ready for more posts like this one
(am going out in a few minutes so if you have anything to ask about that now's the time)
i think i’ve asked you questions from that post that you didn’t get to
specifically on why you think most active players are tow
specifically on why you think most active players are tow
town*
my phone is not suited for posting at all
my phone is not suited for posting at all
Your passive play in this game makes me feel kinda like I'm looking at my own style from the outside. There should be a question attached to that, but I'm not sure how to phrase it aside from "thoughts/comments?"
By the by I'm at work up to deadline so I'll be semi present on mobile, in and out depending on when work deadlines hit
That was the point. It was because you were actually posting theory and stuff, which I've seen you do a lot of as town. :P
3.5 hours to deadline fyi
- Status