S.A.C. Martin said:Sorry I should have made my view clear:
The 180 degree is the support for Israel, which is receding at significant rates. This poll is one of several which shows that the vast majority of brits want a ceasefire, want both sides to negotiate, want an end to the fighting.
I would disagree with you that the majority of the public have been pro Palestine. I think it has accelerated publicly, which is not the same thing.
But equally, maybe mainsteam british media has skewed mine and others views, I don’t know.
Either way, there has been a notable and clear change (but not as sweeping as I was, unintentionally, saying earlier).
My apologies, I hope that makes my view clearer.
I would disagree with you that the majority of the public have been pro Palestine. I think it has accelerated publicly, which is not the same thing.
I acknowledge that my framing of the British public was incomplete. One could certainly argue a neutral/Palestine/Israel percentage split of 70/20/10 represents a neutral public, rather than a pro-Palestine public. There are various reasons I made the framing choice I did. To that end, I originally focused on how, even from the beginning, the pro-Palestine bloc was decisively larger than the pro-Israel bloc. For other reasons, I'll note the contrast between the British public and the American public on viewing the genocide–the British public being relatively pro-Palestine in this comparison–and that policy issues often depend on small passionate or invested minorities to push their stances through a largely-neutral public. Nevertheless, I again agree the framing is incomplete, and that the bloc of Palestine supporters has risen by a meaningful amount.
This poll is one of several which shows that the vast majority of brits want a ceasefire, want both sides to negotiate, want an end to the fighting.
If it was unclear, I do not (and did not) disagree with this.
The 180 degree is the support for Israel, which is receding at significant rates.
As I implied in my post, there are a couple different ways we can conceptualize "support for Israel": the percent of people who say "I support Israel", the gap between Palestine and Israel support (raw subtraction), and the gap between Palestine and Israel support (ratio). All of these measures disagree with your claim that Israel support is receding at significant rates. Two are pointing the opposite direction, and one is static. You may believe I misinterpreted the data or may believe the data are incomplete for some reason, but neither is clear to me.
| "I support Israel" | Pro-Palestine Margin (Subtraction) | Pro-Palestine Margin (Ratio) |
| Israel Support (1Y) | 10% -> 17% (+7) | 14% -> 14% (=0) | 2.4x -> 1.8x (-0.6x) |