Throh from A- to A: Totally agree. There are a select few Pokemon who can stand a chance against Throh in the metagame, especially the RestTalk and RestoChesto set. The only things that can take it out in one hit are a Hurricane from Swanna on its standard RestTalk (252/252+ set) or a Banded Brave Bird from Dodrio on either set.
252 SpA Life Orb Swanna Hurricane vs. 192 HP / 32 SpD Throh: 393-463 (91.6 - 107.9%) -- 50% chance to OHKO
252 Atk Choice Band Dodrio Brave Bird vs. 192 HP / 32 Def Throh: 576-680 (134.2 - 158.5%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Avalugg from B to A- / B+: Try B+. With the lack of Special Attackers capable of chopping this guy down, with the exception of a +2 252 Life Orb Sneasel with Low Kick, I think it's fair.
Simipour from B to B+: Disagree. With its access to Nasty Plot, Substitute, and its high base SpA and Speed, I think it's fair that it stays where it is. Its Specs set is pretty nasty as well.
Electrode from B- to B: Agree. The fastest Pokemon in this tier with pretty nice offensive stats with mediocre but sufficient coverage as well as access to Taunt, Thunder Wave, Electro Ball, and Foul Play make this guy scary as hell to go up against if you don't have the right answer.
Simisage from D to C+: Try C. It's worthy of being C with its good typing for this metagame. Its small coverage almost requires you to be a mixed attacker, though, which means you have to decide between sacrificing Speed for one of your offensive stats or one of your offensive stats for Speed.
Solrock from C- to C+: Agree. With great Speed and Attack stats, decent bulk, and access to Stealth Rock, I think C+ is a justifiable rank for Solrock.
Wailord from C- to C+: Disagree. Its lack of coverage and Speed are the hindering factors here and its bulk is weirdly distributed. It's got an AMAZING health stat and pretty nice offensive stats with average Speed but subpar Def and SpDef. However, the prevelance of stall-walls and strong Grass-types in this tier are really what push me away from thinking he's C+ worthy in this metagame.
Dusclops from D+ to C: Agree. With access to Will-O-Wisp and Eviolite, its got even more bulk than its evolution at the cost of Attack. Need I say more?
252 Atk Life Orb Sneasel Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Dusclops: 133-159 (46.8 - 55.9%) -- 69.5% chance to 2HKO
252 Atk Life Orb burned Sneasel Knock Off vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Dusclops: 68-82 (23.9 - 28.8%) -- 96.3% chance to 4HKO
Vibrava from Unlisted to C: Try something in the D range if anything. With the quad-weakness to Ice-type moves (which are very common in this tier), slightly-above-average defenses, and weak attack, the only thing this Pokemon has over any other Defogger is that it doesn't get beaten up by Stealth Rocks.
Dusknoir from D- to D+: Agree. There's a lot of huge threats to Dusknoir out there, especially Will-O-Wisp users countering his most common set. However, there is a lack of that in this tier and its bulk and offensive stats are strong enough to justify this rank-up. It also learns Will-O-Wisp which is very nice.
Maractus from D- to D+: Disagree. The sheer lack of coverage and sub-par offensive stats makes Maractus very unappealing, perhaps less appealing than Cacnea. The only edge it has is that it is one of the few Pokemon that can take a hit from a boosted Barbaracle and counteract with a Grass-type move and a Sucker Punch for the K.O.
Regigigas from E to D: Disagree. Just as in the case of Illumise, WaveRaySub is not a reliable strategy. One burn before your Slow Start ends and your Regigigas is nothing and you've wasted 1-5 turns on nothing.
Cacnea from unlisted to D-: Testing this out, seems extremely interesting. Saving this for edit.
Corsola from D to E: Agree. With the prevelance of Grass-type coverage to stop the infamous Barbaracle from setting up, Corsola gets trashed on in this metagame before it has a chance to do much.
Dunsparce from D+ to E: Agree. I personally love Dunsparce but competitively speaking, in this metagame, there is little practical use for him on a team.
Illumise from C- to E: Agree. Pretty much has nothing to offer besides priority WaveRay and pray to the RNG gods which is not a reliable strat.
Minun from D- to E: Agree. Outclassed by Raichu completely and has limited use with any other set but not enough to be viable in the metagame.
Noctowl from D to E: Disagree. With decent bulk and utility coverage, including Dual Screens, Roost, Toxic, T-Wave, Whirlwind, Tailwind, etc., I think it's a solid D- rank Pokemon.
Phione from D to E: Agree. Outclassed entirely by just about every Water-type in the tier at every role. It's about one step above Castform.
Pidgeot from C to E: Try D-. Outclassed by almost everything in the tier. He's the fastest Defogger in the tier but otherwise, he has very limited usage besides scouting with U-Turn and hitting someone neutral for like 40% with a Brave Bird.
Plusle from D- to E: Agree. Outclassed by Raichu completely and has limited use with any other set but not enough to be viable in the metagame.
Shedinja from D+ to E: Disagree. With proper support, there's not much you can do to Shedinja at all. It's not enough to build a team around but if you can get him in a spot where the enemy can't touch him, that's a win condition right there.
Unfezant from D+ to E: Agree. Completely outclassed by even physical Emolga, even with his 100% Crit Night Slash... It doesn't even get Defog...
Clefairy from D+ to unlisted: Disagree. Clefairy, while being "outclassed" by Togetic at what Togetic does, has its own niche. It's not a Defogger, it's a bulky setup "sweeper" and counter to sub-seed stallers; very few Pokemon can answer to a Magic Guard Cosmic Power setup here being that there aren't too many phasers that can take a boosted Moonblast or Stored Power (unless you give your Grumpig Whirlwind but then you'd be sacrificing a very important move slot). It does need some support, though, that's for sure. D+ is fair.
Pikachu from D- to unlisted: Agree. Outclassed in its entirety, really, especially with Raichu being in the same tier.