Hi guys I think going through all 109 pages will be too much work and not enough reward so Imma just focus on Day 1,2,3 (mafia lynches). The method I will use here is Vote Count Analysis. Time for Wifom Galore!!! (I mean it is basically Vanilla). Will mainly focus on alive people + mafia. Also just to note so people don't bring it up, yes I have not lynched this game iirc. You might say that a VCA then is obviously bias towards other people and not myself. However, if you treat this similar to a readlist, then there is no need to include myself anyways. So here we go:
Things to note before: This post only considers the final vote counts and not the discussion. Therefore, it does not explain the whole story, but it may shade light on certain things.
Alive people:
Drookez Nuxl Pidge rssp1 vooper Whydon
Day 1 Final VC:
3p1k (6): rssp1, nuxl, asek, OM Room, Duskfall98, CaffeineBoost
CaffeineBoost (5): Energy, Texas Cloverleaf, apricity, Whydon, vooper
Former Hope (3): Oddish., Pidge, InfernoDragon,
Whydon (1): 3p1k,
Asek (1): Former Hope
Hopefully the orders here are accurate of the lynches. So let's say here. Everyone alive now, except me, voted for a mafia. rssp1 and nuxl lynched 3P1K early, which might mean that they are not mafia. On the other hand, Whydon and Vooper lynched Caff quite late. However, since they could have easily lynched 3P1K to show towniness, it does make them a bit clearer than Pidge, who lynched FormerHope with 3 votes. This may not be helpful, but note how Former did not vote for a mafia. If that was perhaps discussed in mafia chat, 3P1K lynching Whydon makes Whydon seems town because mafia might not want to add another vote to Caff or Former. Also Vooper was kinda pressured into voting Caff by hal. So from this VC, Town --> Scum
rssp1, nuxl, Whydon, Vooper, Pidge
Day 2 Final VC:
Former Hope (9): asek, duskfall98, Texas Cloverleaf, apricity, OM Room, CaffeineBoost, Pidge, InfernoDragon, Whydon
CaffeineBoost (2): Oddish., Energy
Not Voting: Drookez, nuxl, rssp1, vooper
This vote count to me is very interesting. Nuxl and rssp1, the early voters on 3P1K, did not vote on former. Pidge and Whydon did lynch Former, but it was the 7th and 9th lynch respectively, also notably it was after Caff's lynch. Can't say much about this lynch tbh
Day 3 Final VC:
CaffeineBoost (8): Oddish, Energy, rssp1, pidge, whydon, om room, InfernoDragon, CaffeineBoost
Not Voting: asek, Drookez, duskfall98, nuxl, Texas Cloverleaf, vooper
Again, not sure what to say here. rssp1 takes the lead on the mafia lynch again, while nuxl and vooper remains neutral. This vote does give a slight credit to pidge and whydon though.
Now that we see this, let's discuss how the vote counts look different when it was a townie lynch. Day 4,5,6
Day 4 Final VC:
InfernoDragon (6): Texas Cloverleaf, Whydon, vooper, InfernoDragon, OM Room, nuxl
Duskfall98 (1): rssp1
Pidge did not lynch today, whereas he was lynching every day before. Nuxl finally got back to lynches after day 1, and whydon + vooper were comparatively early to vote than on other days. Rssp1 decided to lynch Duskfall, another town, by himself.
Day 5 Final VC:
Energy (3): rssp1, Texas Cloverleaf, Nuxl
Nuxl (2): Pidge, Whydon
Dusk (1): vooper
Not voting: drookez, duskfall98, energy, om room
Day 6 Final VC:
Duskfall98 (3): Texas Cloverleaf, Vooper, rssp1
Pidge (2): Nuxl, duskfall
Nuxl (1): pidge
Not Voting: Drookez, Whydon
Grouping these together. Pidge stayed on Nuxl, while Whydon didn't vote. Nuxl went on pidge (perhaps in retaliation?), while Vooper maintained the lynch on Dusk with rssp1 joining on.
Okay so that's basically it. I am not claiming this to be perfect in any means (actually it's not, read the note) but i do think it maybe useful. If I have time I would go look at the discussion between these lynches. To sum up,
I think Nuxl is suspicious. He starts off strong with an early scum lynch, but didn't lynch the 2 scum PR and was the last lynch on the two following town lynches. Whydon and Vooper are in a very similar situation, but from these two i think Whydon is more townie for reasons given. I was suspicious of Pidge for his mafia lynches, but read him as townier during town lynches. rssp1 I think is the clear towniest here and I also think that if he is mafia I am not destined to win against him.
So Town --> Scum: rssp1, Whydon, Vooper, Pidge, Nuxl