In short, Undertale is one of the most fantastic and engaging games I've played in quite some time.
In long-form:
The whole top-down shooter style defense system is super interesting. It actually reminded me of the Mario & Luigi series, where enemy attacks act like minigames in which, if you're good at observing enemy movement patterns and have quick reaction time, you can avoid or deflect damage. In Undertale, every enemy has their own recognizable attack patterns, and though they can be tough to master, with enough skill you're always capable of avoiding damage completely.
On top of that, the game never lets the battle system become stagnant. It's always expanding upon the system by regularly adding in new mechanics, and changes them drastically during boss fights for some really enjoyable and memorable battles.
The world of the game is incredibly creative too. The characters are colorful and quirky, the environments somehow always look remarkable, and scenery tends to alternate between minimalistic and intricate pixel art. You get the impression that the entire Underground is a connected, thriving, living world through consistent character interactions and repeated environmental throwbacks to earlier points in the game, such as...
Mild Spoilers
the reappearance of the Spider Bakesale in Hotland after seeing it in the Ruins, or the copy of Toriel's house once you reach New Home.
Plus, going the extra mile to explore everything in the world will always lead to interesting discoveries, including funny bits of dialogue and narration, notable side characters, and in some cases, you'll find some seemingly innocuous little details that hint at larger revelations that occur later in the game's story, such as...
Bigger Spoilers
the circled skeleton joke written in Toriel's diary, the television in Napstablook's house (as well as his comment about having a show he watches on it sometimes), or the unopened letters found in Alphys' lab.
Additionally, when you play through the game multiple times, you get a renewed respect for the characters because you are given the chance to see every side of their personality. In pacifist or some neutral runs, you'll see how comedic and caring and relatable they are. But once you start killing, you'll discover how they react to crisis, what they do when their lives and the lives of those they love are at risk. You get to see these characters at their most kind and their most desperate. I haven't had a game make me enjoy its characters quite as much as Undertale did in a long time.
Now, in response to
brightobject 's post:
Spoilerinos
I understand that Sans is designed to be unfair and force the player to struggle tremendously, but
good lord, I don't think players were supposed to struggle quite as much as I did. Fighting Sans took somewhere around a combined 10 hours for me, over the course of three days of attempting and giving up after constantly dying. I must have gone through at least 100-some iterations of this fight, inching the tiniest bit farther every few attempts.
I had already used the Pie during Undyne's fight, so all I had were seven Legendary Heroes and the Steak. After I had sunk so many unsuccessful hours into the battle, I looked up some advice and found out that heading back to Waterfall to get a Sea Tea would help. And it actually does help; tremendously at that. I used it after entering the "Real Battle" portion and had a
much easier time dodging his lasers and blue attacks, and especially his final attack, during which I could more reliably navigate through the bones during that long sideways free-fall.
That said, what truly kept me determined to keep fighting this guy well past the point at which I lost my sanity was his
KICKASS FUCKING THEME SONG