I’ve posted a rare handful of times online about the very few games I’ve played that I would consider to be worthy of a true 10/10 (ten out of ten) ranking score. And when I say very few, know that my criteria for this is ridiculously strict. How strict am I talking? Let me put it this way. Have you ever played a game that’s so unbelievably good that it actively makes you not want to play anything else because you actively know and recognize the games that come after it or are made by the same group of developers are worse by comparison? A 9/10 game might still be a generational success that’s full of effort, content, and emotion that controls extremely well and is a technical marvel for its hardware, but a true 10/10 is even better than that, at least to me.
In fact, I have to ask myself. Does such a game even actually exist at all? Is there any video game ever released that objectively has no flaws and is as physically close to perfection as you can possibly get? Such a question is heavily opinionated, of course. I’ve previously said I can only think of one, and even that was only off of a technicality that The Subspace Emissary be combined with Super Smash Bros. Brawl and not treated as two separate things like some story modes for multiplayer games have been in the past. And even then, I don’t actually agree with that take anymore; I think Brawl has enough problems to not reach that elusive ranking, specifically in regards to Brawl being one of the worst and least popular games for competitive players. By comparison, Ultimate arguably had a worse story mode but its own competitive scene is WAY bigger and more successful, and at least it HAD a story mode at all unlike Smash 4.
So, without a true answer I can think of to the question, I turn to this thread. I also encourage you to bring this up to your friends. Not only do I want to know if you think there are any true 10/10 caliber games (or whatever rating system you prefer, I just like this one), but I want to know what I think of this. My reason being, if there are any true 10/10s out there that I don’t know about and have not played, I want to be able to experience them.
I want to know what it’s like to feel genuine emotional heartbreak over video games again. I want to know what it’s like for a game to explore the fundamentals and foundations of its gameplay, writing, and mechanics and make the most of what makes similar games click. What makes a perfect game, or anything close to it, is opinionated, like I said, but I want to have a reason to be optimistic about the future of this industry and a reason to keep playing newer and older games alike, especially nowadays in an era where I’m a working young adult and have actively gone on record saying I don’t care for and openly dislike the PS5/Xbox Series generation (a sentiment I’m slowly gaining for the Switch 2, in fact).
Maybe I’m being too harsh. Maybe I need to lighten up my rankings a little bit. But I really do believe, if I can find a game or games plural that can leave that strong of an impact on me as a human being, a gamer, and someone with an interest in writing, that right there might actually just be the spark I need to not only continue this hobby, but possibly enjoy it more than ever before. My birthday’s coming up in a few days and this is the first year in AGES where I genuinely have no interest (at least right now) in getting any new games or systems. That’s not a good sign- the last time that happened was just before the death of the entire toys-to-life thing in the mid-2010s, and we all know how that turned out. This is like that but noticeably larger in scale. If I of all people think the industry is going downhill- maybe not fear mongering a market crash but still scared- then that’s a real problem.