UN: Tsykia
FC: 1205 2714 7338
Reason: Max EVs
Did 224 damage to my Infernape with his Scizor with only ONE swords dance with quick attack when my infernape is Physical defense infernape and should've easily shook off that move but instead killed him in one move when damaged from my life orb, he also survived a flametrower. He desereves to be banned, I damage calced and everything and it only shoulve done 141-162 damage to me not 224.
+2 Technician LO Quick Attack from Scizor, against a 252/252 Infernape (since I don't know the Infernape's exact spread):
182 - 215 damage; 61.1% - 70.4% after one LO recoil.
Odds are, your EV spread is different than 252/252 (seriously, who the hell runs that on
Infernape?), but seeing as how you admitted to LO recoil before, I don't see why Quick Attack shouldn't have brought a 90% 'Nape to under 40%. Also, this calc assumes perfect IVs on both ends, and Wi-Fi battlers don't necessarily have flawless Pokemon at their disposal. Perhaps a defensive IV was lower than expected?
EDIT: I didn't see the above stuff about Infernape being Lax. Here is the new calc (same scenario, with Infernape lacking HP EVs and being Lax instead of undefined nature):
166 - 196 damage; 66.7% - 76.9% after one LO recoil.
So, it seems that the second calc showed MORE damage dealt, despite being accurate in terms of EVs and natures. I remain unconvinced that Scizor should not have been able to inflict that kind of damage.