-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
Maximum Carnage Mafia - Avengers Win! (As well as Pidge and tredge)
- Thread starter RBG
- Start date
the inspector can inspect me but i think it would be a waste.....
A more important role may come up that needs more protection than the inspector and since I'm not 100% sure there will be a body guard i kinda don't wanna leave it up to luck (but there probably will be)
you do it your way son, i do it mine.
i can help. Just pm me.
The thing is macle, no one can fully trust you unless they have viable proof. I mean, would you personally trust someone solely on what they claim? I wouldn't give my complete trust to someone unless they can prove their innocence. In mafia, everyone is guilty until proven innocent.macle said:
First of all, there will always be a bodyguard in a game, you shouldn't worry too much about that. Secondly, whenever you or the villy leader finds out the inspector and bodyguard, you can then determine who needs to be saved that night and you can just alternate between some important roles to throw off the mafia. And if another more important role comes up, then you can BG them. Don't worry about that part yet, wait until you can see what roles there are.macle said:
You just need to just get yourself cleaned to be able to lead the village properly and with the trust of the majority of us.
I want to address a few things you said, macle:
I wouldn't be too surprised if you become d1's lynch. You're certainly working to get my vote.
All Hail Kyogre!
Why exactly would it be a waste to inspect you? Don't go on saying that being Carnage makes you an automatic villager. JA mafia shown that main characters can be used as safe claims for wolves. Carnage might also be a wolf. I certainly wouldn't doubt that after doing some research on the Spider Man series.
Please listen to Mekkah, you aren't going to get any half-decent mafia player to claim to you if you keep asking for claims without getting cleaned. As I said before, the only reason that you would want to do this is to get a few gullible newbs to claim to you so you can get information for the mafia.you do it your way son, i do it mine.
I wouldn't be too surprised if you become d1's lynch. You're certainly working to get my vote.
All Hail Kyogre!
Game Freak201 said:
Macle, please, if you are who you claim, take their advice and trust Mekkah. He's an experience Mafia player and I would respect his opinion when he's offering advice towards success. I would not like for Carnage to get lynched D1. No villager would, so for the sake of the village, please gain our trust and get cleaned. You may think it's a waste, but it will be useful for everyone else.Accent said:
well considering I'm the leader of both the carnage squad and s12, it be hard for me to be wolf....
fine i will listen to mekkah even though i can't confirm I'm carnage without an inspection.
voting for me is retarded.
fine
i will take advice from mekkah.
also btw people are claiming to me from experienced players to noobs. All I really want is too see who you are and alliance. It's not like I can cause harm from that.
Inspector can inspect me, reach, or try to hit a mafia. It's up to him.
well it says it in my pm but i can post it yet so "you'll have to believe me".
also everyone get irc. >:|
what shitty way of wasting my 800 post.
edit: FROM THE OP (he refering to me)
When he broke out, he took some other criminals that he has dubbed the Carnage Squad to help him terrorize this town. To make matters worse, the first thing he had planned upon his escape was to recruit the Sinister Twelve to help him defeat Spider-Man once and for all.
also everyone get irc. >:|
what shitty way of wasting my 800 post.
edit: FROM THE OP (he refering to me)
When he broke out, he took some other criminals that he has dubbed the Carnage Squad to help him terrorize this town. To make matters worse, the first thing he had planned upon his escape was to recruit the Sinister Twelve to help him defeat Spider-Man once and for all.
same here, macle. It says nothing about my faction being led by Carnage. I gonna need proof.
Well, I'm not saying that macle is 100% trustworthy, but the OP does say that Carnage recruited both factions.
Not to sound nitpicky, but Carnage didn't recruit the Sinister 12. He wanted to recruit members from the Sinister 12 onto his own faction.MagicMaster87 said:
Edit: I misread part of that quote. Never mind this.
macle, don't expect anyone to claim unless you post your role PM tomorrow. At least then we can see what fake role pm RB Golbat has made for you...
EDIT: Hey I have an idea. Why doesn't the inspector claim to the first villager he finds and then that villager speaks for the inspector? This protects the inspector's identity.
EDIT: Hey I have an idea. Why doesn't the inspector claim to the first villager he finds and then that villager speaks for the inspector? This protects the inspector's identity.
Okay, first this is common procedure. But, on the other hand, a mafia can claim he's been cleaned by the inspector and give false information.
Next thing I want to say is, I'd say it's fine just to give Macle name and flavor, not necessarily role. As pointed out by DaLetterEl in NPC v2, the pros outweigh the cons of doing flavor exchanges. While, yes, Macle may be a wolf, I'd say that we'll be better of getting together rather than completely lost.
You have a point there Xyphang. Name and flavor is okay I guess. At least it would be difficult for someone to make a fake role and claim to him without being worried someone else claims with the same one. Anyone who doesn't claim will have suspicion cast on them too. Okay, I will give my role name and faction tomorrow.
Guys, its Night 0 and we're all wading unknown waters without a light.
I don't have much to say at the time, but just listen to this: Don't make decisions too rash at this moment. Do not rely on assumptions or instinct. Upon the arrival of Day 1 at least some light will be shed upon all of us. Suspicion is circulating within our own factions and village, so all we really can do is 1) wait and, 2) gather all we can without making too much of a disturbance.
The Day will come soon enough so don't hammer down anyone too hard yet.
I don't have much to say at the time, but just listen to this: Don't make decisions too rash at this moment. Do not rely on assumptions or instinct. Upon the arrival of Day 1 at least some light will be shed upon all of us. Suspicion is circulating within our own factions and village, so all we really can do is 1) wait and, 2) gather all we can without making too much of a disturbance.
The Day will come soon enough so don't hammer down anyone too hard yet.
itt: DCJ says the obvious.
J-man: He means inspect results and the ability to post full role PMs to everyone.