ianlazerbeem said:Very flawed post in many regards. As Moyashi said, every single one of those checks is an offensive check save for the ones you describe that require running niche tera types. Ogerpon matches less well into offense yes but what you're leaving out is the way Waterpon completely shreds through teams that are anything short of full offense - this is especially evident with the fact that your post mentions Knock Off a grand total of 0 times. You used the classic "well it can't run 6 moves at once" argument as if Ogerpon is a Pokémon that's remotely safe to try and scout - by the time you've figured out what safely handles the set you're facing you've already lost a Mon, let it set up, or best case scenario lost an item. This is also evidenced by you freely admitting it requires two checks. Given the 4 kingambit checks I'm already running, the 2 gouging fire checks, 2 Kyurem checks, 2 Rillaboom checks, 2 stored power checks, I'm just wondering how to fit the Ogerpon ones as well? Furthermore "sack a Mon and waste your tera" is not really acceptable reliable counterplay. Half of the so called "checks" you mentioned lose to Play Rough, which you really cannot discount as "it can't run 6 moves at once" because it is by far the best coverage move for it, Trailblaze I would honestly not even consider, I think it's awkward to make work, and knock and encore are big middle fingers to fatter teams and are both extremely disruptive, but don't really compare to the way play rough invalidates half the checks you're describing so I would consider it more than anything else, especially in HO mirrors, namely Kyurem, Bolt, Roaring Mid, Zama, booster exhausted Valiant, chipped Dnite, and the Latis (Latias not even really winning vs other variants so idk why you included it.) The only Pokémon you listed that actually reliably check it are the grasses you described, since pult, though great at revenging and one of the best answers, can't safely come into play rough or even knock. Several are also just niche shitmons like torn T Meowsc Serp and Boulder (who gets goobed by cudgel so idk why you listed it) Though this Pokémon is answerable at the cost of a sack for offense, it is singularly extremely limiting to balance teams, and an auto lose for stall if it's paired with something else stall needs to Tera to beat. There are answers that exist in the metagame but not for all team styles, and Tera Dragon as you described as a check will typically lose to Play Rough, the other common Dozo Tera being Fighting which also doesn't like play rough. "It can't run 6 moves" also doesn't really account for the fact that play rough and knock have complete opposite counterplay - knock turns any "defensive counterplay" (in quotes because this ONLY exists through Tera and even then can be overcome) into a trade (well I beat Ogerpon but it was at the cost of my Tera and now I take 3x spikes every time I come in) and play rough as previously established overcomes a good deal of offensive counterplay. If being legitimately uncounterable is the only criteria for a ban then I guess DNB waterpon because a faster Draco often wins but the overall thin amount of RELIABLE counterplay and the way Ogerpon can put the opponent in dire situations before proper counterplay can be established, as well as balance and stall teams not really having the luxury of accepting a revenge kill or being able to actually slot this counterplay, means that despite not being an unbeatable auto win button (which has never been the criteria for a ban) Ogerpon wellspring is a very broken Pokémon with a very unhealthy effect on the metagame (not only severely limiting balance and stall but encouraging more cheese team styles with Rillaboom Hawlucha etc.)
tldr at least half those checks are fake, it doesn't need 6 moves it has 2 really good options for the 4th move with opposite counterplay, essentially this is all cap and reads like a magcargo arch post
I don't want to sound rude but to me your post seems more like you just want Ogerpon gone because it is good against your favourite playstyle without actually making a valid point as to why it should be banned.
Of course passive teams filled with ground and water types are bound to have a hard time against Ogerpon-W. Pokemon that makes some playstyles miserable have existed for a long time and having blanket checks for offense and HO in the name of Zamazenta and Kingambit is apparently fine so I don't see how Ogerpon being good but not uncounterable as you said makes it broken. Ursaluna also destroys most stalls and no one would advocate for a ban for the reason that it makes an entire playstyle suffer.
Concerning Ogerpon, the classic balances nowadays often have Dragapult with wisp/t-wave to heavily cripple Ogerpon. It also has 4MSS so you won't ever find an Ogerpon that runs Trailblaze, Knock Off, Play Rough, Low Kick, Encore, Power Whip, Ivy Cudgel and Swords Dance in a single set. Yes it is strong but it struggles against a lot of things depending on the moves it chooses. The fact that it can't use any item means that it is very weak to hazards, in particular T-Spikes so you could always use them on Glowking. Also, no matter what moves it run, it will always struggle against bulky grass types so you could either use that or use Tera Grass.
I'm not saying Ogerpon isn't good because it is really good but I just don't see how it could be ban worthy with such a heavy 4MSS, no item, a locked Tera type and a speedtier that makes it very easy to revenge kill even without booster pokemon.
Also, Ogerpon-W making Alomomola players having to think instead of spamming Scald/Flip Turn is a good thing for the tier. Having a good water immunity that can be run on offense (so not Clodsire) is a huge deal for a lot of non passive teams that would otherwise have almost impossible match ups against rain or pokemon like Walking Wake. (Yes Ogerpon gets destroyed by DM but it can at least force some kind of mind game if you have a fairy on your team).
I'll just conclude by saying that not having Ferrothorn and Tangrowth sucks but there are still a lot of options to easily deal with Ogerpon for non offensive team and it's just up to players to try and think a little bit oustide of the box. Without Play Rough, Ogerpon is hard walled by Hydrapple and even with Play Rough it can't even OHKO it at +2 even after rocks so you CAN check its moveset somewhat safely despite what you said.