Gonna be a lot busier than I had hoped for the next 2 months so I'm not sure how much more gaming I'll get done now that I've beaten Expedition 33. I saw people on twitter do this so I decided to make a tierlist of all the games I played from the start of the year til now, hopefully I'll come back at the end of the year and finish it with what I play in the latter half of 2025.
tierlist (poor formatting sorry)
S Ranks: Nier Replicant & Expedition 33
Nier Replicant cemented itself as my new favorite game after I beat it this past March. "The Worldender", as he's called in official media, colloquially Brother Nier, stands out to me as a better character than any of Automata's cast. The game really is an odyssey of seeing just how far you're willing to go for one person... or is it? Along the way you meet found family, each with their own baggage, and unfold their stories even more in the later playthroughs for alternate endings. I like how the world map is designed - you can tell they really knew how to make a lot happen with a little back when the original Nier released in 2010. The music does hit a little less hard for me than Automata, but I still found myself humming quite a few tracks from the game, especially the many renditions of Devola & Popola's song.
Big fan of the combat in this game as well. Weiss and his customization makes for something a little more engaging than Automata's unlimited Pod rapid fire, and the Sword/Spear/Heavy Sword combat options all feel great, though I settled on the Phoenix Spear and stuck with it for the remainder of the game as soon as I got it in my first part 2 playthrough. Words are a cool way to spec out your gear even further and I switched them up pretty often depending on whether I felt like I needed more damage or exp gain or whether I was hunting drops for a sidequest.
Speaking of sidequests, I did quite literally every sidequest in the game even though there's no achievement for doing so. Some of them unlock very tangible rewards like lower prices from merchants, or some offer rewards that make them outright required if you want to get all the endings, but you don't need to do all of them for anything. And I think that's partially why I felt so good about doing them. I was having so much fun playing the game I just wanted to take my time and talk to every NPC, fish for sea monsters in the desert, and do every fetchquest I was asked of.
The first time I saw Expedition 33 was a trailer shown off at The Game Awards last year, and I wasn't too sure what to make of it. "Oh that looks cool, but maybe a little industry planty". Then the game launched to roaring acclaim and picked up a lot of people playing a turn based RPG who were suddenly bashing other turn based RPGs to build up this game, and I won't lie it left a bit of a sour taste in my mouth. But by the end of May when I had finished the Digital Devil Saga duology, I felt it was time to hop on.
By this point all of the trailers were pretty far out of my mind which meant I was going in effectively blind. The way the game's Prologue tears at your emotions no less than 30 minutes into the game is incredible. It really feels like everything in Act I is about constantly feeling hope and getting that hope destroyed as soon as it comes, iykyk.
The story following Act I is nothing short of incredible as well in my opinion. There were a few things I picked up on before they were explicitly communicated to the audience, but other reveals that had my jaw dropping. The game's conclusion to Act III will go down as one of my favorite endings in gaming.
Gameplay wise, this game also knocks it out of the park. I love the combat so much, there's so much to spec out and build characters to do quite a few different roles. Parrying and pulling off counters feels so gratifying, I remember when I beat the first few bosses I messaged my friends that I felt like such an accomplished gamer lmao... The Parry/Dodge mechs are really where all the friction in the game lies, since your AP restores every fight, healing spots are plentiful, encounters take place on the overworld, there's plentiful autosaves, etc. It is such a smooth and rewarding experience, especially beating some of the tougher bosses. I haven't even done a lot of the Act III exclusive content yet since I didn't want to overlevel too hard for the final boss, so that'll be my excuse to revisit the game and keep getting good
A Ranks: Digital Devil Saga Duology
I played my first Megami Tensei game in 2023, and you'd never believe it but that game was Persona 5 Royal on Switch. Since then I've played a good bit more of the MegaTen games, but I had yet to touch an actual PS2 game, despite a lot of people hailing it as the best era of Atlus titles. I decided I didn't want to play P3 Fes or OG P4, I just think the upgrades Reload and Golden brought to those games streamlined the experience for me and it'd feel tough going back. I did play about 10 hours of the Nocturne Remaster sometime last fall, but ultimately I dropped the game. I just felt like it really wasn't doing anything for me in the way that both SMT V and V:Vengeance did.
Enter Digital Devil Saga. Right away I was hooked with the game's premise, a bunch of military tribes fighting tooth and nail for survival on a war-torn wasteland, suddenly stricken with a virus that causes them to turn into demons and eat people for survival? That's pretty fucking metal. Despite the gameplay being effectively an evolution of Nocturne, I enjoyed the combat and exploration in this game so much more. I think one thing I've realized as I branch out more into the SMT games is that I don't actually care that much for demon fusion and much prefer to spec out characters, exactly like you can in DDS/Metaphor's skill trees. I do love all of the other mechanics of its combat, and combat in the DDS games is super smooth from start to finish.
I got really into these games pretty quickly, by like the third dungeon of DDS1 I was pretty steadily clearing out one dungeon a day. The games weren't drowning in plot, but the plot points always gave just enough that I felt enticed by the action and motivated to pursue the next bit of the action. It really was pretty hard to put down the controller at some points. The game's dungeons were all fun to explore, I think some of my favorites are the castle and abandoned ship in DDS1 and the jail and final dungeon in DDS2. In DDS2, the narrative feels like it takes more of a front seat, especially towards the end game, as the plot wraps up. And once it does, it feels like the pacing ramps up into overdrive as each cutscene has something happen that completely alters the trajectory of the game. I loved it though. The other thing to give DDS2 props for was that I had a much tougher time with the game's bosses, and felt like I really had to do the classic SMT die -> die -> refine strategy -> still die -> ok I finally won. Would definitely recommend both of these games if you like any MegaTen game, even feel like people that have only played the Persona games could get into these pretty easily.
Rank B: DMC5, SMT Strange Journey Redux, Metal Gear Rising Revengeance
Yeah I supposed the DMC anime marketing worked on me, I picked this game up for pretty cheap on an Xbox sale after listening to the song Evanescence made for the anime about 50 times. I hadn't played a game in this style up until this point and I think I was expecting something fluid like Nier Automata's combat but I wasn't really let down with how the combat played out in practice. I definitely sucked ass at playing Dante himself in this game but I enjoyed playing as Nero, V, and Vergil a pretty good bit. Loved the game's music and aesthetics, and the story is pretty thin but I did enjoy what was there of it.
I think Strange Journey ranks a little lower than (most) MegaTen games I've played for me primarily because I just didn't like the first-person dungeon crawling as much. I know the game came out on the DS originally so I'm not sure it would've been really possible to do the 3D-style dungeons that SMT IV has, but at the end of the day it's a preference I guess. Also Demon Co-Op feels like a pretty mid system for combat compared to press turn, again it feels like it comes down to what specific demons you're recruiting and fusing more than speccing out builds to optimize for hitting weaknesses and getting critical hits. That being said it's not like I hated the game or anything, I still had a fun time, the change in setting from the average SMT game is definitely a standout feature for me.
Metal Gear Rising Revengeance is the first Metal Gear game I've played. Again I was looking for something close to Nier Automata's level of sword combat. I think this game hits the mark closer for sure. The biggest gripe I have with the game is that the camera is genuinely awful and it literally knocks it from an A tier game to a B tier in my opinion. What should be an epic and stylish combat experience is pretty frequently soured by having to adjust to the camera's horrible angles. Other than that I really enjoyed Kojima's Hype Moments and Aura: The Video Game.
Ranks C and D, currently playing
After beating DMC1 I bought DMC4 + DMC1-3 HD Collection for something like 15 dollars on some crazy sale. Well, I started with DMC1. Remember how I was talking about MGRR camera souring the experience for me? DMC1 might have the single worst camera in a video game I've ever seen. The sound design was also pretty clunky. But combat felt...uh...fine.
Devil Survivor just sucks to me I'm sorry. Pretty much any SMT fan glazes this one to hell and back but I did not like it. The writing is quirky and corny, the level design is garbage, and the only way to gain more resources is to grind on the aforementioned garbage boards. I didn't even like the music in this game except for the opening movie cutscene, genuinely didn't think there was a MegaTen game out there that would have music I didn't vibe with.
This past week I've played the first few hours of Persona 1 and Bravely Default. I think P1 is a mostly solid experience but there is definitely some clunkiness in the battle system that's hard to overlook. Bravely Default is pretty much the opposite to me, I think the combat experience is sick but I think I'm pretty meh on the game's premise and what I've seen of the writing so far. Still, I'll be playing through both of these when I have more time.