• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Unpopular opinions

Eeveeto said:
-Glaceon gained Mud Shot. Weak as this move is, its relevant, because with 130 Special Attack, Fire and Steel types want to switch to take those Ice moves, but Mud Shot hits them hard.
I want to shout this move choice out in particular because at least on-paper, it actually makes for a very good choice on Glaceon. High SpA with mediocre Speed would be very hard to tolerate on an Ice type, but Mud Shot besides a Coverage move provides the Speed debuff to help close that gap. This makes it much more tolerable if used to snipe specifically mons WEAK to it rather than just Ice resistances (so Fire vs Water), because the Speed drop might give more wiggle room if it has to 2-Shot, and patches up a weakness of Glaceon in general if you're hitting a non-Weak target that might still fall to a follow up move like a Fighting Pokemon getting Mud Shot -> Blizzard, or a Water with Freeze Dry.

I also want to highlight that I like this design specifically because Mud Shot is a low BP move. Earth Power would be too basic, linear, and in some ways LESS effective because it gives coverage but doesn't address Glaceon's shortcoming like Speed such that it can capitalize in a meaningful way. Mud Shot patches up a particular issue without doing it so overwhelmingly as to flatten Glaceon's identity.
 
TerrickTerran said:
People are always pleading for new Eeveelutions but they're just variations of each other. The restrictions on stats and moves is crippling at this point.
I’d also make an argument for abilities as well, especially because Eevee has two different abilities and a hidden ability while its evolutions only have a single ability and hidden one. And the overall quality of those abilities are very mixed.
Like on the one hand there’s Sylveon with Pixilate, the Kanto trio with their respective type absorption abilities, Magic Bounce Espeon and Chlorophyll Leafeon.
But there’s also Hydration in a post gen 5 world, Quick feet Jolteon, and Guts Flareon, which aren’t all that great.

In a time where we have so many more abilities available the Eeveelutions could stand for a second look at.
I’m theory crafting a little, but imagine something like Fluffy Flareon, or Technician Glaceon to lean more into the use of Mud Shot, Surge surfer Jolteon would be pretty fun if Electric terrain got a chance to become bigger.
 
Last edited:
Disagree on stats being a particular limiting factor. Maybe if you tried to fill out Eeveelutions for all 17 options, but I designed a pair for a fangame to fill out the evolution stones and at least on paper they seem pretty mechanically distinct from the existing Eeveelutions. You can get a lot of mileage out of rearranging stat numbers in weird configurations.
 
I think the real problem with the Eeveeloutions is that they're all imbalanced with each other. Pixilate and Magic Bounce are OP abilities, while most of the rest of the family gets generic/forgettable ones. Water is broken defensively, and Vaporeon gets status on STAB, Ice coverage, and a stat spread perfect for CroCune strats, while Glaceon is a slow Ice-type.

And yes, that's competitive, but I've run all of them in-game, you can feel the difference between Espeon/Vaporeon/Jolteon vs Flareon/Glaceon. Whether a mon gets a STAB off it's better attack stat before level 50, whether it has Speed/Bulk/neither, you can notice, and the ones that don't feel bad.

If all 8 of them were Dodrio-level, we'd just consign them to the dustbin of Gen 1, or the devs might feel justified giving them all some sort of buff(mega? further evo? signature move?). But when Sylveon/Espeon/Vaporeon have all seen some niche competitive utility in various formats, and 4-5 of them are reasonable choices for an in-game run, the ones that don't stick out and encourage people to speculate on what would be required to make all 8 of them good.
 
Eeveeto said:
The restriction on Stats? Maybe, though if correctly distributed they are still serviceable. Clefable and Kingdra have worse Stats, but thanks to their abilities they have been viable from Gen 2 to Gen 9 (except in Gen 3, in which Clefable is almost unusable).

The restriction in movepool has been decreased in recent generation, especially 9th:

-Every Eeveelution gained Calm Mind, Weather Ball, Trailblaze, Roar and Alluring Voice. Of course, not all of them can use it equally well, but those are all good moves.

-Vaporeon didn,t gain much more than that, but retained Scald, while many Water Mons lost the move.

-Jolteon didn,t gain anything else, but CM + Alluring Voice was enough for some guy to peak the ladder with it: https://www.smogon.com/forums/threads/jolteons-rise-to-glory-peaked-1-2065-elo-and-88-5-gxe.3767669/

-Flareon lost Superpower and keeps being the worst of the bunch. There is little hope for it with that Stat distribution. However, its the only Pokemon in the whole Dex (excluding Smeargle) that learns Calm Mind, Lava Plume and Wish, so thats something.

-Espeon gained Thunder Wave and Psychic Noise. Many Mons have those, but Espeon keeps being one of the rare holders of the great Magic Bounce ability, it will always have some niche. I personally used this Mon and did pretty well in OU with it.

-Umbreon gained Thunder Wave and retained Toxic, a move almost the whole Dex lost, outside of Poison Mons. There is definetely room for improvement (Knock Off and Parting Shot could make Umbreon even better), but this is a very legit Mon and trusted it in the finals of Wcop of 2023 (it was a terrible game from both sides, but I still won).

-Nothing to be said about Leafeon. Stats and typing don,t allow it to do much, but the movepool is certainly good here.

-Glaceon gained Mud Shot. Weak as this move is, its relevant, because with 130 Special Attack, Fire and Steel types want to switch to take those Ice moves, but Mud Shot hits them hard.

-Sylveon gained Psychic, though it lost Mystical Fire. It already had Psyshock, but Psychic is stronger. It has been doing well in VGC.

I believe there is still big potential for both current and future Eeveelution. They have been improving, slowly but steadily and they still have some use after all these years. I do think that having a 3rd ability would help (especially when we consider that actual Eevee has 3). As long as movepool thing keeps getting well adressed, we can have new Eeveelution. Maybe regional variants for all 8 could introduce physical types.
1790096937428.png


At this point, they could legit get the Partner Eevee moves for their type. It would at least give them a niche.
 
Glaceon is actually pretty fun to use in an in-game playthrough of Platinum.

The main thing going against it in-game is that it ironically, despite Eevee being obtainable early, suffers from the "late-game mon" syndrome that most Ice-types have because the means to evolve it is exclusively in the snow routes which are near the seventh Gym, so you don't really get to actually use Glaceon until fairly late in the game.

I wouldn't call it the strongest Eeveelution, but it's pretty usable once you get past the hurdles required to get it.
 
ScraftyIsTheBest said:
Glaceon is actually pretty fun to use in an in-game playthrough of Platinum.

The main thing going against it in-game is that it ironically, despite Eevee being obtainable early, suffers from the "late-game mon" syndrome that most Ice-types have because the means to evolve it is exclusively in the snow routes which are near the seventh Gym, so you don't really get to actually use Glaceon until fairly late in the game.

I wouldn't call it the strongest Eeveelution, but it's pretty usable once you get past the hurdles required to get it.
Also, STAB Ice Beam for Chomp.

It is a shame how late it is tho. Water Pulse and Shadow Ball for coverage is sad too
 
QuickBH said:
You know how almost every Water type has access to Ice Beam? Yeah, get rid of that, makes no sense how Pokemon that live in marshes have access to that. You know what does make sense though? Ice Pokemon being able to control their temperature to use Water moves. Make moves like Surf generic to Ice Pokemon.
Access to Surf to non-Waters seems to boil down to "can this creature reasonably swim or float" or "is this a kaiju" and not controlling body temperature.
 
Last edited:
QuickBH said:
You know how almost every Water type has access to Ice Beam? Yeah, get rid of that, makes no sense how Pokemon that live in marshes have access to that. You know what does make sense though? Ice Pokemon being able to control their temperature to use Water moves. Make moves like Surf generic to Ice Pokemon.

For Pokemon that live in marshes specifically, most of them have access to Sludge Bomb or Sludge Wave to hit Grass-types so losing out on Ice Beam wouldn't be as big of a loss. If anything not giving them Ice Beam would give them more reason to use Poison coverage instead, which would be an interesting spin to differentiate them from lake/ocean dwelling aquamarine Water-types which mostly would have Ice Beam or Blizzard as coverage against Grass-types.
 
I frankly would prefer to buff Poison as a type to make it more desirable as coverage before gutting Ice Beam access. Make it hit Water for SE or something. I'm of the opinion that you should try to buff underpowered things first before targeting nerfs on things that aren't even overpowered.

Also as a now-VGC player, the idea of heavily restricting Mega Mence answers is just dumb to me lol.
 
Current distribution of Ice Beam on Water types is good enough. What Mons don,t get it?

-Rotom-W. Obvious, since its originally not even a Water Mon.
-Volcanion. Its a Fire Mon, hot Mons have it hard to learn Ice Beam.
-Keldeo. This one I am not sure why it doesn,t get it, but since its a legendary Mon that dominated Gen 5 and 6, I agree with the decision. It still gets Icy Wind.
-Ogerpon. Again, this is not an actual Water type, just has a mask.
-Watershifu. Physical Mon that only gets STABs as special moves. Doesn,t need it and learns Ice Punch.
-Pyukumuku. Has Counter and Mirror Coat as only offensive moves.
-Water-Dragons. The Dragon typing makes them neutral to Water instead of resistant, so it makes sense that Tatsugiri, Dracovish and especially Walking Wake (Sun Mon that uses hot water to attack) don,t learn Ice Beam. Except Wake, they still learn some weaker Ice moves. Palkia and Kingdra don,t follow this, because Palkia is an Uber that learns moves from almost every type and Kingdra has prevos that are not Dragon (and in Gen 1 they lived in the same cold cave Articuno lives in).
-Paldean Tauros. See Watershifu. Obviously this one doesn,t have punches to use Ice Punch.
-Dondozo. Not a Dragon, but feels like one. Learns Ice Fang and Avalanche anyway.
-Seismitoad. Can,t really explain this one other than Frogs hybernating. Learns weaker Ice moves anyway.
-Quaquaval. The weirdest one. Don,t see any reason for it to not get Ice Beam. Actually gets non STAB Special moves. Probably they just forgot to add it, since this is still a physical attacker.

Generally I don,t like universal moves and think Protect should have a massive cut, especially if we consider similar moves (Spiky Shield, Detect, etc.) exist. But distribution of Ice Beam seems alright, after all, Ice is a type of Water, so it makes sense all Waters except the hottest ones learn the move.
 
Eeveeto said:
Generally I don,t like universal moves and think Protect should have a massive cut, especially if we consider similar moves (Spiky Shield, Detect, etc.) exist.
This is such a singles-brained take lol because anyone who actually plays doubles understands that Protect's widespread distribution is one of the load-bearing bricks of the format. Heavily restricting access to it would do far more harm than good.
 
Karxrida said:
This is such a singles-brained take lol because anyone who actually plays doubles understands that Protect's widespread distribution is one of the load-bearing bricks of the format. Heavily restricting access to it would do far more harm than good.

I played Doubles and the less Protect is used, the more fun is the meta for me. I am not advocating for the full removal of Protect, I just want it nerfed and have a more interesting and offensive meta.
 
Eeveeto said:
I played Doubles and the less Protect is used, the more fun is the meta for me. I am not advocating for the full removal of Protect, I just want it nerfed and have a more interesting and offensive meta.
Doubles is already quite offensive and fairly interesting. You can get away with so much shit if you're good enough. Unless you really hate making reads I'm not sure what you even want here.
 
On the subject of game balance and things that are too universal in their applications to the game, lately I've been giving Life Orb more thought as something that I think was a massive contributor to the games' increased emphasis on fast-paced, offensively minded gameplay. I can understand what Game Freak was going for with the concept of an all-encompassing offensive held item especially with Leftovers being by far the most ubiquitous held item in the previous two generations- the former for a lack of held item competition and the latter for Tyranitar's Sand Stream- but I think they may have gone a little overboard with this.

Let's compare Life Orb to other offensive held items. Choice Band and Choice Specs boost increase power output by 50% but only for physical or special moves respectively and has a much worse trade-off in their usage. Gen 5's Gems are also pretty strong in their own right, providing a 50% power boost for any move so long as it's of the corresponding Type and the Gem is consumed upon usage. Gems also had hardly any downside beyond the usual opportunity cost of "what am I gaining and losing from using this instead of a different item?" that all held items have anyway. If you want a smaller power boost in exchange for multiple turns of usage and the ability to still switch moves, you can still use Muscle Band, Wise Glasses, and other various lower-mid tier held items as well as any Berries that boost stats upon consumption.

At first glance, Life Orb's 30% power boost on all attacking moves might not seem like much, and that residual passive damage is a noticeable downside, but I would argue isn't as big of a downside as what the Choice Items are known for and 30% is actually a lot for how easy it can be to either work around or passively ignore that drawback. Pokemon's damage calculation formula can roll multipliers from 85% to 100% of expected damage, and that boost means a Pokemon with Life Orb is guaranteed to deal more damage than if it didn't have a Life Orb equipped- an 85% damage roll multiplied by 1.3 still puts you at 110.5%. In fact, a 20% power boost on the lowest possible damage roll is still 102% overall. I would argue 20% is healthier for the game than 30% anyway, but it gets worse. There are two kinds of Pokemon that most frequently run this item- Pokemon with Abilities that can ignore Life Orb's passive recoil like Magic Guard or Sheer Force, and offensively minded sweepers who are, with some exceptions, either so frail already that the recoil doesn't matter in practice or have some way to try and deal with it, such as a Life Orb Rillaboom with Grassy Surge. I get that something like a Mixed Infernape in DPP OU has some repercussions to deal with if running Life Orb, but the power level of offensive threats has only grown since Gen 4 and the power of the Life Orb has stayed the same. Sometimes, in formats with open team sheets or team preview you can even know some broken win condition is coming with one equipped and you still can't do much to stop it. Uninteractive gameplay dominated by powerful sweepers and breakneck pace of play does not a fun competitive environment contain, and while Life Orb does have some skill-based interactions- I particularly like the skill check that rewards players paying attention to the damage calculator against something like a Magic Guard Clefable that can run multiple items- I think the game would be in a better position overall if Life Orb's power boost was nerfed. A nerf from 30% to 20% even feels like the kind of thing Game Freak would do and is equivalent in power reduction to the nerfs to Refrigerate and company, a set of Abilities most commonly seen on Mega Evolutions who can't hold the Life Orb anyway.
 
I think trying to pin Life Orb as the major contributor to the increase in offensive/fast games and not
  • More optimized stat spreads over time
  • More readily available weather-setting abilities starting in Gen 5
  • Various battle gimmicks that often allow for high damage in some form (also Gems in Gen 5)
  • *vaguely motions at Gen 8 with Zacian, Urshifu, and Calyrex*
is missing the big picture while putting too much emphasis on an item that isn't even always ran, even in Item Clause metas.

Also why do so many people think relatively fast Pokémon games are the devil lol. I can spend about the same about of time in a single VGC match as a good game of TF2 on a KOTH map or possibly even more, especially since the latter is 6 minutes max bar overtime shenanigans. And that's assuming both teams are evenly matched.
 
Last edited:
Karxrida said:
Also why do so many people think relatively fast Pokémon games are the devil lol. I can spend about the same about of time in a single VGC match as a good game of TF2 on a KOTH map or possibly even more, especially since the latter is 6 minutes max bar overtime shenanigans. And that's assuming both teams are evenly matched.
Because my preferred way to force progress is multiple layers of passive damage, and that being viable requires active damage to be less effective than it currently is in VGC. I think that there's a lot that can be done in the official games to reduce the amount of time each turn takes so that more turns can fit in the same amount of real time instead of needing to constantly focus on lowering the turn count.
 
Ironmage said:
Because my preferred way to force progress is multiple layers of passive damage, and that being viable requires active damage to be less effective than it currently is in VGC.
That also requires passive damage do more, and considering that several sources of it (e.g. Burn) have been nerfed over time I don't think you're winning here.

Ironmage said:
I think that there's a lot that can be done in the official games to reduce the amount of time each turn takes so that more turns can fit in the same amount of real time instead of needing to constantly focus on lowering the turn count.
While I definitely agree here (the time spent Grassy Surge notifications in particular could easily be cut in half), any gains would be negated by passive strategies becoming better at all. They inherently require you to just wait to resolve instead of making active progress. This is both boring to watch and (most importantly) frustrating to go against because half the goal is to not let the opponent play the game at all.
 
Last edited:
Karxrida said:
While I definitely agree here (the time spent Grassy Surge notifications in particular could easily be cut in half), any gains would be negated by passive strategies becoming better at all. They inherently require you to just wait to resolve instead of making active progress. This is both boring to watch and (most importantly) frustrating to go against because half the goal is to not let the opponent play the game at all.
I think that’s been one of the biggest issues with the franchise. There’s a lot of streamlining that has been done for Champions, but there’s still a lot of sore points.
 
Protect in PVP Doubles is simultaneously an omnipresent tool that makes the game a bit stale... and is the sole keystone game element that prevents a complete and utter collapse of the game into matchup roulette. It's a well and truly necessary evil the way that the game has been designed, and while an overhaul of the game to make Protect less omnipresent might be possible, it's the kind of change that the developers of a game like Champions (which is clearly aiming to create a retirement home nirvana for the established turn based battle enjoyers rather than reinvent the wheel) will never do. It's pretty much just going to be up to fan works to be the gameplay fanfiction to design a Doubles game that doesn't focus on / get broken by Protect.

I do think a Protect TM, especially an infinite use one, should probably not be in a Doubles centric RPG / strategy game.
 
They've already come up with alternatives to Protect, now they need to give broader access to those alternatives and replace Protect with them. No move should be both universally known and competitively necessary, it's a level of homogeneity that is against what the games do otherwise. And the devs agree.

Spoiler
Universal TMs.png
Notice how they've eliminated almost every good move from the list of TMs every mon can learn? Return, Frustration, Hidden Power, all Dexit'd. Toxic and Curse eliminated from most movepools. Rest, Substitute, Attract, and Swagger have survived, but are only arguably good, while the less said about Tera Blast the better.

But somehow Protect survives, and "But Protect is necessary in VGC" is taken as an argument in it's favor instead of that format being broken.
 
Hugin said:
Notice how they've eliminated almost every good move from the list of TMs every mon can learn? Return, Frustration, Hidden Power, all Dexit'd. Toxic and Curse eliminated from most movepools. Rest, Substitute, Attract, and Swagger have survived, but are only arguably good, while the less said about Tera Blast the better.
Return and Frustration were only used as STAB (either by Normal-types or -ate mons) and were incredibly powerful moves without any sort of drawback. They were gutted to force people to use Double-Edge.

Hidden Power was probably removed to prevent Dynamax Max Moves bullshit. There might have also been issues with programming it idk.

Toxic was likely culled because, as I have mentioned several times before, a Chansey stall team was marginally successful during SWSH. Also Game Freak does not like stally strats in general.

No idea what the deal is with Curse. You didn't even see it often in VGC outside of uh maybe Snorlax? And I think Snorlax liked to run Belly Drum when it was good during SuMo anyway.

Tera Blast is clearly an extension of Tera as a mechanic, hence its universal availability.
 
Karxrida said:
Return and Frustration were only used as STAB (either by Normal-types or -ate mons) and were incredibly powerful moves without any sort of drawback. They were gutted to force people to use Double-Edge.
I'm honestly not even sure that's the case.

They were taken off because they had some dumb interactions with QR codes in gen 7, where the shared team would have their friendship set at the original value of the pokemon, so they would never be able to be used correctly, and that was an actual issue as for tournaments they would have players share a QR of the team and use it on staff consoles, to avoid any kind of tampering (teams had to actually be legal to be accepted as QR codes by the system, so no cheating to be had - emphasis on "legal" and not "legit").
Even though that was no longer the case in gen 9, they probably decided it was fine as is and they did not add them back.

Karxrida said:
Hidden Power was probably removed to prevent Dynamax Max Moves bullshit. There might have also been issues with programming it idk.
Pretty sure the consensus is that it was removed because it was one of the top 2 reasons for hacking pokemon, expecially legendaries. Lord forbid you needed a legendary with more than a viable single hidden power.
 
Back
Top