QuickBH said:I like modern Exp Share mechanics. It forces me to actually use multiple Pokemon members in a playthrough and not have the game slow to a crawl for no reason other than I just wanted to use another Pokemon. The games aren't any easier or harder because if you're going to grind you can just grind to make one Pokemon steamroll the entire game, but it does make the games more immediately worth investing in. I wish they balanced the level curves a bit more around it, but it's still a more enjoyable experience with it than without.
The biggest benefit of the modern EXP system on paper is that it heavily deters Lowmanning strategies - ones that minimize party members to maximize EXP distribution, and thus Power, per party member - for casual players. Without a need to know how to successfully take on level mismatched foes or deal with managing the EXP Share manually, casual players are much more inclined to use a full party compared to the older system that tended to gravitate beginners towards mono-starter playthroughs. The feedback loop of trying out a newer and weaker Pokemon, it failing and fainting, it not gaining EXP or Levels, and then being more and more likely to remain benched until the next use was a negative feedback loop beginners constantly fell into with these games, and a change to the formula was a big deal for making the ideal way to experience the game into the style players would gravitate towards.
The biggest consequence of the modern EXP system in turn is that any worry about EXP distribution is gone. This, not the lack of rote level grinding, is what makes the game much easier with the modern system. There is no reason to play weaker Pokemon in training into matchups they only have a chance to win; if they have a chance to lose, they have a chance to completely lose and miss out on any EXP, while staying safe on the bench is costless and gives sufficient rewards. This dynamic obviously existed with the EXP Share Item anyway, but applied to the entire party in all directions, it inadvertently can reinforce the power of Lowmanning strategies by allowing players to solely use a single hard carry, usually their starter, in almost every situation and keep relevant counterpick Pokemon at or close enough to the level curve without actually dedicating any time or resources to using them in battles. This was also an area that limited movepools originally helped soothe - being subject to such harsh hard counters made the pokemon of the older games much more reliant on allies to complete the game. The modern games have created a system where a player could use only their starter in battle for 90% of the game and still end up with an endgame party of all fully evolved teammates with high levels.
I'm not convinced this is a solvable problem for expert players. For the older games, using a full party of 6 was the "expert" difficulty setting, for better and for worse. If the difficulty of the game is designed for casual players to have 6 Pokemon and struggle to a hard fought victory
and the incentives for playing around EXP distribution for the party are completely wiped, the handicap for expert players needs to be pretty severe to create a satisfying experience.
I've toyed around with this - I've played through XY with a revolving team of 12 thanks to the EXP Share. When I replayed Shield I ignored every optional trainer / Dynamax Raid Den and used a rotating party of 9 with 3 Slow EXP mons for good measure. SV is sort of the endgame of this concept, as in this case I kept a stable party of 6 but tried to tackle obstacles in as close of reverse order as I could manage without spoiling myself on anything in a blind playthrough. For all of these, I got something closer to what I wanted as far as battle difficulty was concerned, and I even had to sweat losing once or twice. But it still felt wrong for a lot of the obvious reasons it would. Shuffling your party around all the time is kind of annoying. Trying to figure out exactly how gimped you want your team to be is kind of an awkward exercise. The Hall of Fame still only has 6 slots.
Modern EXP Share is a net positive for the franchise, probably. Maybe. Like 8 steps forward and 5 steps back. Most of the downsides to it don't apply until a second playthrough or until you have enough knowledge on the series to be considered a casual expert. (Like someone who knows what type most pokemon are, what 60+% of the type chart interactions are without a reference, and what a large portion of common moves do but doesn't do mental math damage calculations) At that point, with the current "don't ask, don't tell" uneasy truce Pokemon seems to have with fanworks, I'd say it's up to those to really carry the torch to make games that can cater to that level of player.
I can seriously only justify the lack of a toggle for the EXP share in the modern games through the lens of not wanting genuinely illiterate players to accidentally gimp themselves. It's extremely frustrating to be a fan of games that need to be idiot proofed this badly. (and yes they do need it oh my lanta the children
need to learn to read and if Pokemon is to act as a gateway to literacy it cannot have exclusionary barriers for illiterate players this is also why alternative difficulty modes is a bad idea among other things I
promise this is a real point)
I uh had more words that feel seperate to the point above
The older system had somewhat of a reliance on the notion that a Pokemon game could be the primary time sink someone had access to for months or even years - that for those who weren't especially quick to pick up the battle system, they could find enjoyment in whittling down the Pokedex or just mashing buttons into random wild Pokemon. That was supposed to be the padding that puffed up the skeleton playthrough one tended to have easy access to of just juicing up your starter and beating foes as easily as counting tally marks. I mentioned before the games with solid ingame balance being RBY, RSE, and BW1 - I also don't think it is a coincidence that these games have some of the weakest "lifestyle game" appeal in the series, and that GSC / DPPt have extremely strong "lifestyle game" appeal with less than pristine ingame balance. The modern games are living and dying by their daily interaction elements and social co-op experiences - how on Earth do you factor the various rewards for Raid Battles into ingame playthrough balance?
Last opinion for good measure; Ironmon Randomizer SUCKS. Easily the worst spin on the battle system the community has developed. Pure streamer fodder attention retention reroll gambler slop. Literally no reason to ever play it if you aren't specifically trying to churn out low effort content.