Tangerine said:That's true, if Evil only referred to actions. And you said it yourself - "a lot" of the evil will be prevented.
Which is the point. In order to show that God may be blamed for the existence of evil, it suffices for me to show that he could have made a better world than this one.
In such a situation, people will find other ways to do evil.
Like what? What ways to do evil would they find that doesn't already exist and that they don't do already? You can't just say that without giving concrete examples.
Your "solution" doesn't actually solve anything. Your other examples fall under the same boat.
Cop out. I am satisfied with my solution. If you want to say that it doesn't solve anything then by any means support your claim. What you're doing here is hit and run, in all honesty there's hardly any substance to respond to.
Given perfect information about the world, you would not do evil
Yes you would. What the fuck.
(if you have perfect information, you do not have free will
What? Why the hell not?
- given perfect information, your values will be perfect).
What? No. Not at all. Information has nothing to do with values and values can't be "perfect" since they are inherently subjective. You're mixing so many unrelated concepts together in a giant pot that I can hardly follow your line of thought anymore.
It is because we are not perfectly rational, we can be evil.
A perfectly rational being can be evil. That's obvious. In fact, if one pursues his exact best interests, one will often do evil things. It's being moral that's irrational in that regard.
I admit that calling evil irrational is wrong.
Good. But given the sentence that preceded this, color me confused.
The possibility of evil lies within free will unsubstantiated claim (and the fact that we can't know everything and work with imperfect information to base our values this has nothing to do with anything), and free will is to be able to maximize or minimize constraints to what we consider important does not entail that some constraints cannot be forced upon us (ie, we choose the values we want to maximize/minimize/decide whatever sheer absence of an argument as to why limiting the pool to good values (which are legion) is unacceptable). You cannot have free will without the possibility of evil and that follows from... what?, you cannot have evil without free will well that's a new one. where does that come from?. It's as simple as that if you don't make any effort then perhaps it is.
Look Tangerine this is a non sequitur through and through.
None of your conclusions follow from
any of your premises in
any of your arguments. I'm disappointed because I know you can do better than that, you're a smart man. But as it stands what you are giving me is so flimsy that I can hardly do anything else than point out gaps where I expected justifications. It's not bad arguments i'm complaining of here, it's the
absence thereof.
Your definition of free will is a weaker version of mine.
So what? You give me no reasons to prefer yours. Heck, as it stands, I don't even know why my version is "weaker" because you're not bothering to tell me!
You cannot simply constrain things until no evil is possible - that is simply impossible.
Really? That's funny because if I said something like that I'd make an effort to explain why.
There will always be a way to do evil in the world.
That is an unsubstantiated assertion. I can think of innumerous ways to prevent evil and for each of these ways you can't just say it doesn't work, you have to find a counter-example. So far you have not bothered to offer any.
and that's why either evil exists and there is free will, or neither exists.
Your claim that evil requires free will stays completely unsubstantiated. In fact, all your claim are unsubstantiated. All you're doing is saying that stuff is impossible.
These are the only two options.
Look, I'm imaginative enough to present you with dozens of other options, all wildly different. Are you prepared to counter them all? Because so far I'm underwhelmed. I think the main problem with you is that you don't think outside the box. There are very few things in the world that
have to work in a certain way. When you set your mind to it, anything can be subverted, you can find thought experiments that invalidate nearly everything you took for granted. You will find that there are very, very few things that I am willing to call impossible (nonwithstanding practical considerations) and that I usually offer lengthy explanations for anything I deem impossible, typically involving conflicting semantics (such would be the case with the impossible action of "creating time" - creation implying a pair of ordered states, ordered states implying time. making time a prerequisite for the act of creation). I won't expect any less rigor from you.
About bible inerrancy: honestly, with the lengths to which one has to go in order to consider the Bible inerrant and prophecy-ridden, most works of fiction are probably inerrant and prophecy-ridden as well. There is no way you'd cut any other book than the Bible so much slack as far as interpretation goes. If any other book talked about the ends or corners of the Earth, you'd assume it's talking about a flat Earth, you wouldn't even try to play it off as anything else than that. If two books gave different genealogies for the same person, you wouldn't play it off as being genealogy from the mother's and the father's side, you'd just say "they fucked up". If some random ancient book referred to a star whose name could be translated as Chernobyl, you wouldn't say it's a prophecy, in fact, you probably wouldn't even
know about it. See a
rumor about that being true about the Bible and you get excited! If you had the slightest intellectual integrity you'd have the decency of holding the Bible to the same standards as any other book.