Aldaron said:If you'll notice, we're tending towards a council type suspect process in 5th gen, simply for practical reasons. We don't want to spend 2+ years again determining the metagame. This council will be making all decisions on experience based theorymon. We will play, and make decisions on that theorymon. Theorymon is obviously not 100% free of an arbitrary element, regardless of experience time.
To be clear, we are implementing this Council system in the interests of increased practicality, but this doesn't have much to do with reducing the actual time spent finalizing the Gen 5 tiers. The reason it won't ever take two years again has much more to do with the fact that "we" took a full six months to arrive at a definition of uber in the three Characteristics, and bounced around many different testing methods that best allowed our users to be genuinely involved in the tiering process. Even if we were sticking with this traditional process it would take much less time (~8-9 months if I had to guess) because this Gen IV Suspect Test Process was very much a pilot we all had to trust would take us to some eighth continent none of us knew the whereabouts of, experiencing many bumps and "stoppages for fuel" along the way.
But in case anyone here has forgotten or hasn't thought about it, I'll make a few "objective" comments. The Platinum Tutors and Level Up moves have had a great impact on how long this test has ultimately taken. If it weren't for the Outrage tutor, we would be testing the Clauses right now instead of Salamence, which only started to really use the move in October 2008, a full two months after we learned of the Platinum move tutors (literally doubled in usage September to October). If it weren't for the Trick Tutor, Latias would very comfortably be in OU still, a statement that's still objective as I'm basing it on the 3-5 Suspect paragraph submissions of every single Uber voter. We wouldn't have had to use another month sorting out the curious case of Latias, even if Latios would have been more borderline.
Latios and Latias were of course branded Suspects well before Platinum came out, so ultimately tiering them accurately would have been impossible thanks to late developments. Salamence is the more drastic case, as it did not gain its "Suspect" move until October 2008, and had to gradually grow into that suspicion in much the same way Latias did for the entire calendar 2009 year. In addition, current #1 Scizor and #3 Salamence have been greatly impacted by the Platinum Tutors—roughly 70% of the latest Top-10 (Scizor, Salamence, Latias, Rotom-A, Metagross, Gengar, Jirachi) has been very positively impacted by the release of a later game, a release with ramifications not fully realized until a year later in some cases. This is going to happen in every single Generation no matter what we try to look out for because metagame adaptation takes months, not weeks.
And the Council won't be making
any decisions on theorymon, though when you say "experience based theorymon" it seems like a complete oxymoron to me so I doubt you really meant theorymon as most of us define the word.
edit: yeah, Instinctive knows what's up