Just want to quickly address some recurring arguments I saw in the first couple of pages. For those people who feel the council process was unfair and that the council members were just the 'popular moderators', have a good read of
this thread. Have a look at the effort put into the applications, and in particular take a look at the successful ones. Then ask yourself, do these users not have the credentials that entitle them to vote? These users are the among the best battlers smogon has to offer, as shown by the extensive tournament lists demanded of each. They are all respected users, and they have allowed us to have a quick and efficient suspect test that I far prefer to some of the
messes we've got ourselves into in the past.
Those people who keep on saying that 'Gen 5 will be released in just a couple of months, why ban Mence now!?' need to realise that Gen 4 needs to be balanced regardless of whether or not a new gen is coming. Gen 4 has been incredibly popular and there will always be a largish number of people who will want to continue to play it. Also, while BW are being released quite soon, we have no idea what mechanics changes there will be, and so getting an accurate simulator up will definitely take many many more months after that. Even if there are no mechanics changes, simply adding new Pokemon, moves and abilities will take time. So really, there is definitely a point to striving towards this balanced gen 4 metagame.
Personally, I'm quite glad to see Salamence go. I was on the fence for a really long time because like most people I love the feel of the thing, but I think it really will increase metagame diversity. It is Salamence's Speed that broke it. The fact that it possessed such firepower is fair enough, but when it outsped or speedtied the vast majority of the metagame, it forced the metagame to adapt through a bottleneck in order to check it. Salamence probably had this coming for a long time. I had a proper 'holy shit' feeling the first time I used DD outrage mence after platinum's release, but the fact that it coincided almost perfectly with Garchomp's ban, Scizor's Bullet Punch, and all the Shaymin-S Latias and Stage-3 stuff, it kind of fell out of the limelight for a while. For those who feel they will miss mence too much though, you need to remember that Dragonite can play very similarly, but it is a much more fair pokemon I feel since it while it does pack a ton of destructive power it still allows for a much wider range of Pokemon to act as checks for it.
And Chou, if you've not done so already, I recommend you give LO Sceptile a try :D. It really lives up to all the hype it's been getting, and it fits your playstyle pretty perfectly. One seriously cool gecko right there :D.