I've gotten quite interested in this and have checked every single Pokemon in the original list (in the OP, of course), and this is the result (Note: Pokemon I saw as utterly useless such as the four cacoons are edited out of the list. I think the four cacoons are the only ones missing, however);
MC List
- Ivysaur
60/62/63/80/80/60
- Charmeleon
58/64/58/80/65/80
- Wartortle
59/63/80/65/80/58
- Pidgeotto
63/60/55/50/50/71
- Pikachu
35/55/30/50/40/90
- Nidorina
70/62/67/55/55/56
- Nidorino
61/72/57/55/55/65
- Clefairy
70/45/48/60/65/35
- Jigglypuff
115/45/20/45/25/20
- Golbat
75/80/70/65/75/90
- Gloom
60/65/70/85/75/40
- Poliwhirl
65/65/65/50/50/90
- Kadabra
40/35/30/120/70/105
- Machoke
80/100/70/50/60/45
- Weepinbell
65/90/50/85/45/55
- Graveler
55/95/115/45/45/35
- Magneton
50/60/95/120/70/70
- Haunter
45/50/45/115/55/95
- Rhydon
105/130/120/45/45/40
- Chansey
250/5/5/35/105/50
- Seadra
55/65/95/95/45/85
- Electabuzz
65/83/57/95/85/105
- Magmar
65/95/57/100/85/93
- Porygon2
85/80/90/105/95/60
- Dragonair
61/84/65/70/70/70
- Bayleef
60/62/80/63/80/60
- Quilava
58/64/58/80/65/80
- Croconaw
65/80/80/59/63/58
- Togetic
55/40/85/80/105/40
- Flaaffy
70/55/55/80/60/45
- Marill
70/20/50/20/50/40
- Skiploom
55/45/50/45/65/80
- Piloswine
100/100/80/60/60/50
- Pupitar
70/84/70/65/70/51
- Grovyle
50/65/45/85/65/95
- Combusken
60/85/60/85/60/55
- Marshtomp
70/85/70/60/70/50
- Lombre
60/50/50/60/70/50
- Nuzleaf
70/70/40/60/40/60
- Vigoroth
80/80/80/55/55/90
- Loudred
84/71/43/71/43/48
- Lairon
60/90/140/50/50/40
- Roselia
50/60/45/100/80/65
- Vibrava
50/70/50/50/50/70
- Dusclops
40/70/130/60/130/25
- Sealeo
90/60/70/75/70/45
- Shelgon
65/95/100/60/50/50
- Metang
60/75/100/55/80/50
- Grotle
75/89/85/55/65/36
- Monferno
64/78/52/78/52/81
- Prinplup
64/66/68/81/76/50
- Staravia
55/75/50/40/40/80
- Luxio
60/85/49/60/49/60
- Gabite
68/90/65/50/55/82
Using these, I have compiled lists of "best of 10/11" Pokemon from every stat, slacking off from compiling a BST list of course. In case of a tie, I've tried organizing placement through "who's better" on first glance. I usually went up to 11 instead of 10 in case of ties when I couldn't decide which Pokemon should be omitted. And... here it is;
Top 11 Base HP List
1)
- Chansey
250/5/5/35/105/50
2)
- Jigglypuff
115/45/20/45/25/20
3)
- Rhydon
105/130/120/45/45/40
4)
- Piloswine
100/100/80/60/60/50
5)
- Sealeo
90/60/70/75/70/45
6)
- Porygon2
85/80/90/105/95/60
7)
- Loudred
84/71/43/71/43/48
8)
- Machoke
80/100/70/50/60/45
9)
- Vigoroth
80/80/80/55/55/90
10)
- Golbat
75/80/70/65/75/90
11)
- Grotle
75/89/85/55/65/36
Top 10 Base Attack List
1)
- Rhydon
105/130/120/45/45/40
2)
- Piloswine
100/100/80/60/60/50
3)
- Machoke
80/100/70/50/60/45
4)
- Magmar
65/95/57/100/85/93
5)
- Shelgon
65/95/100/60/50/50
6)
- Graveler
55/95/115/45/45/35
7)
- Gabite
68/90/65/50/55/82
8)
- Lairon
60/90/140/50/50/40
9)
- Weepinbell
65/90/50/85/45/55
10)
- Grotle
75/89/85/55/65/36
Top 11 Base Defence List
1)
- Lairon
60/90/140/50/50/40
2)
- Dusclops
40/70/130/60/130/25
3)
- Rhydon
105/130/120/45/45/40
4)
- Graveler
55/95/115/45/45/35
5)
- Shelgon
65/95/100/60/50/50
6)
- Metang
60/75/100/55/80/50
7)
- Seadra
55/65/95/95/45/85
8)
- Magneton
50/60/95/120/70/70
9)
- Porygon2
85/80/90/105/95/60
10)
- Grotle
75/89/85/55/65/36
11)
- Togetic
55/40/85/80/105/40
Top 11 Base Special Attack List
1)
- Kadabra
40/35/30/120/70/105
2)
- Magneton
50/60/95/120/70/70
3)
- Haunter
45/50/45/115/55/95
4)
- Porygon2
85/80/90/105/95/60
5)
- Magmar
65/95/57/100/85/93
6)
- Roselia
50/60/45/100/80/65
7)
- Electabuzz
65/83/57/95/85/105
8)
- Seadra
55/65/95/95/45/85
9)
- Grovyle
50/65/45/85/65/95
10)
- Weepinbell
65/90/50/85/45/55
11)
- Combusken
60/85/60/85/60/55
Top 11 Base Special Defence List
1)
- Dusclops
40/70/130/60/130/25
2)
- Chansey
250/5/5/35/105/50
3)
- Togetic
55/40/85/80/105/40
4)
- Porygon2
85/80/90/105/95/60
5)
- Magmar
65/95/57/100/85/93
6)
- Electabuzz
65/83/57/95/85/105
7)
- Metang
60/75/100/55/80/50
8)
- Bayleef
60/62/80/63/80/60
9)
- Wartortle
59/63/80/65/80/58
10)
- Ivysaur
60/62/63/80/80/60
11)
- Roselia
50/60/45/100/80/65
Top 10 Base Speed List
1)
- Kadabra
40/35/30/120/70/105
2)
- Electabuzz
65/83/57/95/85/105
3)
- Haunter
45/50/45/115/55/95
4)
- Grovyle
50/65/45/85/65/95
5)
- Magmar
65/95/57/100/85/93
6)
- Pikachu
35/55/30/50/40/90
7)
- Vigoroth
80/80/80/55/55/90
8)
- Golbat
75/80/70/65/75/90
9)
- Poliwhirl
65/65/65/50/50/90
10)
- Seadra
55/65/95/95/45/85
Enjoy~
(This may be added to the OP if needed/it has proven to be useful enough)