Chou Toshio said:@Fluffy Otters-- overlooking all your posts: Lurk more
This is the way Smogon handles tiers, there is no discussion or room to argue, this is simply POLICY, the way things are (just like any of the rules and regulations we have in our community):
OU and UU are designed tiers. They are meant to be balanced and played as the popular tiers, with UU being a second tier for lesser used pokemon. The fact OU is currently imbalanced has no pertinence to the fact that we are currently in the process of balancing it, but first making sure whether certain bans are deserved or not.
Ubers and BL are ban lists, this is their own purpose and there is no need at all to balance them because they are not designed for play.
That said, people are free to play with whatever lists they want as long as both players agree to the rules, and Smogon is not imposing its threads on those who choose not to follow smogon. People are free to play Ubers and BL if they want to-- with the understanding that they are not designed to be tiers.
Therefore, there is no "too good for Uber" or "unbalancing in Ubers". The fact you have this misconception is what causes posters around you to roll their eyes. *lurk more*
I learned my lesson, I'm not going to argue any more, especially since this isn't the right topic for that and we both got side-tracked. But other than you and like one other person, I haven't seen people argue so vehemently over this whether ubers is a tier or not (in all practical usage it is, if not called that in name which is somewhat stupid, and it doesn't need to have been originally designed for a tier to become a tier but enough of that).
And despite differing opinions in what is and isn't a tier, doesn't mean my opinions aren't valid. I guess you could ignore my posts all you want but other than these last few about the tier, they have all been valid in application to the topic and ideas of Pokemon. I don't see why I need to lurk more on relating to topics like individual Pokemon and things since I am well aware of what the pokemon can and can't do in theory for the most part. It just seems that now you just don't like me.
Back on to the topic of Inconsistent: Smeargle pass is broken. If it gets in safely, it will make a successful pass of something (hopefully not accuracy) if not more with Spore/Sub/and evasion+Speed boosts.
Aura Sphere is limited in the OU metagame to Togekiss, Lucario, and Mew and you don't see those very often. It is more likely to see 100% accurate Thunder and Hurricane in Rain.
There is no doubt in my mind that this will be axed into a ban/clause. It is ridiculous whether or not it works, and it could make games go on for much longer than necessary.