blasphemy1 said:While it's true that you'll be ahead (for a few turns), that doesn't mean you'll win. You are boosting a single stat, and any of Evasion, Speed, Defense, or Special Attack (or Attack) will let them beat you. Let's say you are using a Garchomp. Swords Dance up to +6, only 3 turns right? Well now your single stat is fighting against four other stats: Speed (they can Sub before you hit them, netting more boosts), Defense (whichever respective stat), Evasion (chance of missing is great at +2), and HP (standard non-boosted stat). On top of that, a Special Attack boost thrown in there might end you on turn 2 or whatever. The chances are very low that a stat booster will beat an Inconsistent user because you have to attack with one stat and one attack against the four aforementioned stats, three of which have a good chance of being boosted.
Good explanation, you have to think it through:
A +6 Garchomp does not have to fight against Octillery's Defense. lol (It maxes out at +6, too, y'know?)
Not even HP matters, because you either hit a Sub or OHKO them regardless of defensive boost, because you are sitting at +6 yourself. And as you have said yourself, once you start to boost, their speed is not going to matter, because they already have a Sub up (which you should consider yourself, too).
So what is left of Octillery's stats? Evasion. Once you sit at an offensive+6 you're basically fighting against Evasion. It all comes down to this.
Considering I'm against Evasion clause, too, I see nothing wrong with that. If you seriously think evasion clause is a good idea (lol), then you should consider expanding it to include Inconsistent (but Acupressure and Sand Veil, too).