CaptKirby said:I just provided more facts, and you blew past them. Point differential is not utterly predictive, but it is very strong. Last season the rankings were:
Patriots #1 +205
Packers #2 +148
Steelers #3 +143
Two of those teams went to the Super Bowl because of their amazing production and a defensive emphasis. Obviously it is not a rule, since things like the Saints/Colts happens (Saints were #1 PD and won though), but in a year in which two teams seem to be on pace for ridiculous point prevention, if the Patriots face both of those teams in succession in the playoffs they are essentially guaranteed to lose to one. Elite defense makes elite offense submit more often than vice versa. Only one team had a winning record with anything like the 392 pionts given up pace the Patriots are headed for, and that was the Indianapolis Colts. Also, while you seem to believe the Patriots are the magic holy grail of offense, they are just one of five identically productive offenses at this point (T#2, but all are basically at the same place). All of those teams are very good, of course. Nothing at all differentiates the Patriots from them, however.
How is two games a small sample size when it is the only sample you have. Jesus fucking christ that is the worst fucking counterargument I have
ever seen in my entire life. The. point. I. made. was. about. the. Patriots. in. the. playoffs. I am soooooooo sorry for my factual analysis of what happened in those games being something I fixated on, instead of catering to whatever you want the argument to be.
They are the same team as the second half of last season, just playing to even more ridiculous extremes. Tom Brady can throw for 5500 yards, but just like with Marino, he will be shut down when he faces a team that only allows 220 points in the season. It does not mean that they will definitely lose the game, but it does mean that, like every single team and every single strategy, the attack is coverable. I just have to keep showing magical facts
like how the team that had a good offense and defense beat the team that just had an elite defense and very good offense easily dismantled the team that had a good defense and elite offense, but then again you do not care about reasoning, actual facts, et cetera. You already readily dismissed the exact way the exact same team was destroyed two seasons in a row with no significant changes to the team's strategy in season three as meaningless, so there is clearly nothing in the world that could get through to you.
Every team is banged up by the playoffs. If that is the only reason you think the team lost, then whatever. Why waste all this time lol, christ. The Patriots even had a bye week!
The only thing I can concede is that the Patriots might get better the rest of the season having had to play on the road 3/4 times so far. That much I do have to wait and see on. If this is who the Patriots are though, then they are doomed to playoff futility. Let me remind you that I only started making that point as a flippant comment, you are the one who has forced me to go this far and actually fucking MAKE a claim. Yet another reason your whole "let's stop!!" thing is so trite...you were the one who made this serious. I was just making a casual, innocent observation, and you chose to take everything as loaded and underrating (I rated the Patriots like #5 most likely to win the Super Bowl in several other posts, but for some reason you wanted to ignore that).
I actually saw your facts and if you notice, I responded to your assessment of what they meant. No matter how many times though, you fail to read anything I've said up to this point.
So I'm going to list everything I've said in bullet points so you can read them easier (it's clearly not your strong suit).
-The Randy Moss Patriots Offense (ala two years ago) is entirely and utterly different from the Offense now. So I would agree with you then, that the Patriots of two years ago, while dominant in the Regular Season, would struggle in the Playoffs, simply because their attack was too limited.
-My assertion has never ONCE been that the Patriots offense is better than all other Offenses. It's has ONLY been that it cannot be schemed against to great success. Yet AGAIN AND AGAIN, you bring up facts that are either irrelevant, or do not satisfy the conditional I have on my assertion. And how do you handle said caveat? "All teams are injured in the postseason." Intellectual and very factual based-response. The team RELIES on every part of the Offense meshing together perfectly, and if a cog is out, they perform at a far lower level.
-Your "factual analysis" consisted of showing me playoff games where Brady gets sacked, and your conclusion is "BRADY SUCKS AGAINST THE PASS RUSH, NEVER WIN, ALWAYS LOSE TO DEFENSE." Wait, where's the facts again? That's right, you used a stat, which only describes what happened in game, not why it happened. Your scope of view is extremely limited.
-Your understanding of Situational Football is so shockingly minimal it's almost impossible to deal with. The game is about match-ups, individual and team based. Even if the Patriots play two strong defenses in the Post-season, if they have better individual match-ups, then the Patriots will win regardless of how good the defenses were against other teams. There's no guarantee just because there's two in a row that they're going to lose.
Now to something truly important:
Not every offense is exactly the same.
This seems to be a troubling concept for you since you so blatantly fail to accept it. I say numerous times how pants-on head stupid it is to bring up the Randy Moss era offense when talking about the current offense, yet you continue to bring it up. Randy Moss era had two threats, Welker and Moss. That's it. If you covered Moss, you make the Patriots a One-Dimensional team then, and you stop their production easily. This current Offense consists of Branch Welker and the Tight Ends, and whoever they have as the fifth as a reliever. That's a far more multi-faceted and difficult to cover attack. Yet you insist they are exactly the same team with exactly the same strategy. I have to ask what you're smoking when you say something like that. How many times have you seen Brady throw the long ball up this season and last? Not even half as many times as he did with Moss. While the teams were both Offense oriented, they did not run the same schemes as they did when Moss was there. Saying that is like saying the 3-4 Defense is
exactly the same as the 4-3 because two Defenses are similar in stats, and they each run one or the other.
Another thing is production in an Offense like the Patriots, is not to be confused with similar production from teams like the Packers who don't have a nearly as diverse an Offense. Again I do NOT insist that the Patriots Offense is the best, I only insist it's impossible to cover effectively unless you run a hitherto unseen defense. I'm hard pressed to think of any Offense previous to this one has presented such a diverse attack.
It is for this reason that it was so utterly pointless to bring up the 49ers Miami game. All it did was say "Hey there's a theme to football" and then you admit immediately that there can be exceptions. I don't disagree at all that Defense is a theme for championship teams, my point is that the Patriots are one of the exceptions. I agreed with your rankings of the teams when you made them, because they were correct (I wouldn't have had the Bills above the Patriots, but that's a gripe that isn't worth arguing this much about). I say you underrate them because you write them off as an Offense that's merely productive and therefore like every other Offense ever that's been productive. That is so holistically untrue. The diversity of the attack is what makes this Offense special. I saw what Welker did to the Bills as an extremely lesser output of Offense for the Patriots. Because they made themselves one-dimensional.
As for your claim about their Playoff success this season, I would agree completely, since so far their Offense hasn't clicked and has been mostly one-dimensional. Only the first and second games showed glimpses of their diversity. The magnum opus of this offense was last year in their 45-3 win against the Jets, that was when they were at their peak. The team this year has a lot of room to improve on their potential, in my opinion. If they can get to the point where they're doing what they did to the Jets consistently (run an inordinate amount of formations, and abuse the match-up problems that are forced because of them) then I contend they will be able to get by any defense. I can't know this, but I thoroughly think they will be able to.