Katakiri said:Game Freak builds their games with Doubles and Singles in mind. Doubles is the "official" way to play soley because of the VGCs. (Although MLG had a Pro Curcuit for Singles for DPP iirc and has an on-going 6v6 Singles Ladder for B/W.)
Saying that Game Freak only "balances" the game for Doubles is calling them blind. Game Freak knows EXACTLY why Diamond & Pearl revitalized the series. Wifi. They know it definitely wasn't Double Battles. And, as a budding game designer myself that knows the industry, I can tell you that, just like how we do with PO, they can extract data from their servers and look at it to go "Okay, what are the most popular things we're seeing here?" When they look at the unrated friend battles being 90% 6v6 Singles, then they know what to focus on.
The VGCs are not run by Game Freak. The VGCs are vastly just a PR stunt held by the marketing division that advertises Pokemon Merchandise and is also responsible for the Pokemon TCG tourneys to....advertise Pokemon more! What a shock!
If I have one gripe with gamers, it's that you don't give game developers enough credit. Smogon is small. PO is small. BUT Game Freak knows we exist all because of one thing, there is no big, competitive Pokemon site of Japan. If you search competitive Pokemon in Japanese, the first 2 results are Smogon with the 3rd being a question asking why competitive Pokemon is so popular in North America. Does Game Freak care about our rulesets or ban-lists? Hell no. Are they aware that there is a community 116,000 strong on a site vastly dedicated to 6v6 Single play? Absolutely. It's Game Freak's job to know the community. It's bad game design to not look for easily find-able sites like Smogon the specialize in YOUR game.
Game Freak knows their fan-base. They know how much we love 6v6 battles. But they also know that 6v6 ranked matches are a terrible idea. They know that not everyone has an hour to spare for stall, but they also know that players will try to stall the timer if they have the lead if they implemented a 30-minute timer into 6v6 battles. They chose 3v3 & 4v4 because they go fast. The term "snack gaming" gets thrown around a lot, but that's what it is; most people only play Pokemon for 10, 20, 30 minutes a day. 3v3 or 4v4 battle rarely last over 5 or 10 minutes. That why Game Freak chose them. No one wants to lose points on a ladder because they can't keep playing for another 40 minutes.
Game Freak balances the game for 6v6 singles and 4v4 doubles. The game was always about 6v6 singles since Red & Green. They started "balancing" the game with Gold & Silver because then knew that they have made a competitive game series now. The series was balanced for singles every game. Up until the VGCs started in 2009, there was no question about that. You don't take a game series with 5 generations of installments, all built for singles play and then turn it into a purely doubles-balanced game. It doesn't work that way. No matter how much VGC players wish otherwise, they will always be in the back seat in Game Freak's designing process.
tl;dr: Give Game Freak the credit they deserve.
Doubles Pokemon has been more balanced than Singles Pokemon since Generation IV. TPCi runs the VGC series in North America and Europe, but Nintendo of Japan does it in Japan. I forget who runs the tournaments in Korea. The rulesets are a collaborative effort between the Tournament Planner at TPCi and Nintendo from what I remember but I do believe Japan has more weight.
Japan has a sizeable competitive community and although Game Freak is obviously aware of us (as is TPCi), I would say they pay more attention to the Japanese than us. Japan has been doing doubles and 3v3 Singles as their primary formats for quite some time now. It's just the west that plays 6v6 Singles.
You can believe they look at Singles before Doubles when thinking of competitive balance, but all evidence suggests otherwise. Elements that are considered broken or centralizing in Singles like Moody, Stealth Rock, Speed Boost, Rain, etc. are either good, average, or terrible in Doubles.
MLG never had a pro circuit for Pokemon. They approached Smogon about collaborating on a DPP ladder then did it themselves using our ruleset when we didn't really show interest. The only tournament series anyone has cared about have all been from Nintendo. JAA in 2006, VGS in 2008, and the VGCs from 2009 - 2012 have all been doubles-based. The Emerald tournament in 2005 was Singles based and I believe the last one in North America to be so.
I agree that Game Freak makes the game with both Doubles and Singles in mind. But I think Singles is something they really just care about as far as completing the single player and maybe 3-on-3 multiplayer matches.
Cobraroll said:Luckily, the Gen. V official tourneys weren't that badly affected by the monstrous move, seeing as only Gen. V Pokémon, who weren't around when Stealth Rock was a TM, were allowed to enter.
Stealth Rock isn't used because it blows. It wasn't used in the Gen IV tournaments and it's not used now either.