Electrolyte said:It doesn't matter which is more powerful, because HP Water should not be used on Genesect in the first place. It's not that it's useless, but that Ice Beam/Flamethrower/Thunderbolt are better. Sure, a water move hits Fire and Rock types, but then you have to ditch coverage. Losing Ice Beam means no more Dragon types, which is one of Genesect's niches; losing Flamethrower means no more Steels, Bugs, and Ice; losing Tbolt means total disadvantage against bulky waters. Besides, even if you do consider using an HP, use HP Ground, which at least hits Heatran harder, while still hitting Rock types just as hard.
Um, we're talking about Rain teams here. There is absolutely no justification for using Flamethrower on Genesect if you have a Politoed as another member of your squad. That leaves your fourth moveslot with two options, Bug Buzz and Techno Blast/HP Water. If you're going to use Hidden Power, and you're running a Rain team, please use HP Water > HP Ground. Consider the following scenarios: Genesect vs. Air Balloon Heatran and Genesect vs. Terrakion. In both cases, it's far better to be packing the former. Ground doesn't do anything to BalloonTran, Heatran's most used set, but also fails to even 2HKO Terrakion at +0. That's really sad. On the other hand, HP Water at +1 OHKOs Heatran AND Terrakion. It just makes plain sense to use HP Water over HP Ground if you're running a Rain team.
By the way, Genesect often does not require what you claim is 100% necessary 4-move coverage. More than half the time it's just using U-Turn anyways. It also depends on what kind of team you're running. If you run a Sun team, sure, you'll probably want all 3 moves. A Rain team? Flamethrower is super weak in Rain so not a good idea there. Hail teams? Never weak to bulky waters, drop Thunderbolt for Bug Buzz. Sand? Depends on your lineup, really.
Genesect has the potential for versatility. It's a waste of that potential if every time you use Genesect it's the same old 4 moves. Try something new; Techno Blast, HP Water, Bug Buzz, Explosion, whatever. Surprise value really helps when you're a Genesect, because as this thread has clearly proven, everybody always expects the same old set.
tehy said:It also changes it's name, i believe. So you'd have to avoid both of those things being noticed. I guess it's good for HP ground AND techno blast, but that seems like it eats too many moveslots on such a versatile pokemon.
You're right on the changes its name thing, I think. That's a shame, names are much more obvious than a few pixels changing color. And yeah I wouldn't recommend HP Ground + Techno Blast because the former hits what the latter hits so it's essentially wasted space.