Cobraroll said:I'm an atheist myself. I was brought up with a minimal amount of religion at home (it was almost never addressed at all), and actually took some Christian side-education when I was around 14 (I think it's called Confirmation in English too, right?). However, after learning (and thinking) more about religion, I decided that no, I don't believe in this. It's simply asking me to suspend my disbelief too much. Still, I stayed with the church choir as a technician for three years, learning yet more and still realizing that I didn't believe (though it's good to know what I don't believe in, at least). And, let it be said, Christianity has quite a few brilliant points about moral and ethics. It's not that I dismissed everything they stand for once I realized I didn't believe the core story.
One of the things that got me thinking was the religious view on other religions. I mean, if Christianity is true, that would mean Hinduism, Sikhism, Zoroastrianism and all the others are false, right? Logically speaking, and asking a few Christian friends, how could that be? The answers I got were eerily similar to what I had thought myself about Christianity: "They got it wrong somehow", "There's just one religion that everybody worships, a single god to answer all the prayers, but their interpretation is the false one", "Their religion is a construct by man", etc. They could easily see why other religions were false, citing a number of various reasons, but were quite adamant that the same logic could not be applied to their own religion (or the interpretation of the "one religion everybody worships"). It's like they were excempt from the criteria that falsified the other belief systems. When asked why, most said it came down to faith. Now, I don't doubt for a second that the Hindus, the Sikhs or for that matter the ancient Greeks or Vikings had any less faith in their religion that Christians have in theirs, so that argument didn't convince me. If the faith of some people is built on a "lie" and thus can be discarded, how could the faith of other people prove them right? Also considering that everything we know about the universe states it works perfectly without divine intervention, I decided to drop deities altogether and be an atheist.
How did society react? With a shrug, if anything. In Norway, about 70% of the population are members of the (former) state church, due to your automatic inclusion upon birth if both your parents were also members. Still, polls reveal that the number of people defining themself as Christians are below 35%, and falling (the exact question being "Do you believe Jesus was/is the son of God?"). Less than 2% of the population go to church more often than every other month, and even on Christmas Eve, the definite Church Day of them all, attendance is still in the vincinity of 10-15%. Most Norwegians are agnostics or atheists, and being explicitly Christian is, in most of the country, considered a lot weirder than being an atheist. The State Church was decoupled from the State a couple of years ago, now having a name nobody remembers (something to do with Lutheranism or something like that). Even my parents, when I told them, said "Atheist? OK, no big deal" and went on with whatever they were doing. I've got quite a few Christian friends, and quite a few atheist ones too, but in general, religion (or lack thereof) is regarded as "no big deal", something personal you shouldn't flaunt before others.
Cobraroll thanks for posting some of your life, and why you don't believe. (I'll tell you more about my experience of what lead me to the decision that there where no god(s) (Then I might go in on what lead me to Christ).
Chou Toshio said:I don't know... I'd say it's hard to define what a religion is. For instance, I'd like to look at Shinto as an example. Shinto is basically, to put it simply-- evolved/developed Japanese nature worship. That said, almost all Japanese go through Shinto rites throughout their lives, without them having much significant impact on faith. Many Japanese Buddhists and Christians follow Shintoism without thinking much about it.
Part of this is because most Japanese care so little about Religion.
Part of this is because Shintoism has no "higher beings"; no capital "G" God. There are millions of "kami" in Shintoism, and "kami" is often translated as "gods", but it's more like "spirits"-- in that, be they nature spirits or deceased people, kami are falible and stuck on this same earth-- we co-exist, but there's no upper-lower relationship. Praying to a shinto kami isn't like asking God for salvation-- it's more like asking a neighbor if he'll let you borrow his lawn mower. And if he doesn't, you say "fuck you" and go ask a different neighbor (or in this case, tie your bad luck fortune paper to a tree and go to a different shrine to try again, lol).
To put this in perspective, a Christian who also followed Shinto rites doesn't see Shinto kami as gods-- but just other things on the earth, like people, animals, and other parts of nature; they to are just fallible creations of God that exist on the same plane as us. Well, that's why I'm Christian and don't give a crap about praying at a shrine anyway.
There are several scholars of Japanese culture, and many Japanese, who don't consider Shintoism a religion at all-- but perhaps just another innate part of Japanese culture; like the way they take their shoes off, or the way Americans eat peanut butter sandwhiches.
Even this non-religion makes people pissed though. For instance, Yasukuni Jinja is a shrine for dead soldiers-- amongst whom enshrined include some of the war criminals of WWII. It's funny because the Chinese/Koreans are pissed at this, thinking the Japanese there are worshipping war criminals. From a Shinto stand point though, you're not worshipping them or anything else. Shintoism doesn't exist to judge the good or bad, but only to help living people co-exist with spirits (from nature or deceased people). You don't enshrine a person to worship them, you enshrine them to put their soul at rest (so it doesn't cause trouble for the living).
Is Shintoism a religion? I wonder.
Both of these post are excellent. :)
Chou I'll mainly be replying to your post (to the best of knowledge. With this in mind remember I am just a man, and I do not have all the answers.)
Part of this is because Shintoism has no "higher beings"; no capital "G" God. There are millions of "kami" in Shintoism, and "kami" is often translated as "gods", but it's more like "spirits"-- in that, be they nature spirits or deceased people, kami are falible and stuck on this same earth-- we co-exist, but there's no upper-lower relationship. Praying to a shinto kami isn't like asking God for salvation-- it's more like asking a neighbor if he'll let you borrow his lawn mower. And if he doesn't, you say "fuck you" and go ask a different neighbor (or in this case, tie your bad luck fortune paper to a tree and go to a different shrine to try again, lol).
I think I'll start here. In Christianity and Catholicism there is one higher power. His name is Jesus or Lord God. I believe Lord God created the Heaven's (in Spanish this is sort of translation of Skies) and the Earth. He also made the Angels and Humans. God made humans and angels on the same level. We aren't higher than one another. One thing my mother does is she prays to the Saints. (It's a catholic thing.) I guess a saint could be like a spirit you pray to. They make candles with the saints on it. My question is why would you pray to a saint or spirit. As a christian I believe Jesus died for me. I don't have to do any rituals (like killing doves, or slaughtering lambs, and covering an altar in blood) to talk to my Father. I can go directly to my Father and ask Him for anything. "Modern" Christianity seems to be all about friendship and love. Jesus wants to be a friend of yours. He wants you to be intimate with him.
Take a listen to Jake Luhrs testimony. (It's only going to cost you 11 minutes.)
In the Bible refers to other gods, and idols, but when He is speaking or people are speaking about him He changes to the big "G." (This logic is "fallible" because there are some languages that do not have upper, and lower case. To really understand you have 1 of two things you can do. Learn Hebrew and the Hebrew way of thinking, or pray about it, and ask for understanding.)
--
As Americans we eat Cheese Burgers, and Cheese steaks.
As a Christian you only have to partake of "two rituals". You chose to partake in communion, and you chose to get baptized baptized (If anybody has questions feel free to ask. I will do my best to answer them.)
Jesus Bless all of you :)