Ckarasu said:A counter forces a switch out, or straight up KOs, while surviving to do so. Breloom cannot attack it or it dies, so it can come in as many times as it needs to in order to force out Breloom. There are no real beneficial exchanges in this matchup. If Breloom attacks Chesnaught after that SD, it dies. If it hits and runs, then Chesnaught can just Synthesis it away, if it needs to. Also, Breloom can only do 60-70% with a SD, as in the calcs I posted.
It's not a bad thing to have a hard counter, you know. Most good pokemon still have one or two.
I agree, and have already mentioned Gourgeist as a hard counter. I just don't agree that Chesnaught is going to be one. It could be one, but it'd have to specialise to such an extent in order to become one that it'd render itself largely useless at anything else.
Let's consider what Chesnaught needs to be able to 'switch in as many times as it needs'. First, you have to be able to OHKO Breloom. If you can't, Breloom 2HKOs you with a +2 Mach Punch. This means you need Adamant with a Life Orb, Poison Jab, and 252 attack EVs. That's not all, though. You also have to be able to heal off the damage Breloom might inflict on your switch in, since otherwise, he simply wears you down. You switch in and take 10-35% depending on what he throws your way. You retaliate as he switches out and lose a further 10% from LO recoil. The next time he switches in, you're in his KO range and you can't counter him any more. So you need Synthesis to really function as a counter, since without it you get worn down way too quickly. So Adamant, LO, Poison Jab and Synthesis.
This leaves you with 2 moveslots left, which means you're left with an unpleasant choice. Forgo one of Chesnaught's two STABs, leaving you helpless against at least one of OU's myriad of popular walls (if you forgo fighting, you can't scratch the likes of Forretress, Skarmory, Scizor, Mega Mawile, etc, and if you forgo grass you can't do jack to Hippowdon, can't even damage Aegislash, are setup bait for Reuniclus, are hopeless against bulky waters, etc), or forgo a stat booster, leaving you... also unable to take on any of the myriad of popular walls.
Sure, you can take on Breloom, but that's really about all. With Breloom taking a definite dip in popularity, are we seriously suggesting that any player worth his salt run an inferior Chesnaught set - one that is likely to provide setup bait for the 5-6 much more common defensive Pokemon that every team will run - for the sole purpose of countering it?