Aldrius said:Banning the Latis from OU (and that is the closest comparison)It's not a similar game mechanic at all anyway, when the Pokemon is sent out it starts off as the original one.
But the pokemon becomes a NEW pokemon. Not the same mechanic, but comparable.
Aldrius said:the Latis DIDN'T get banned from OU, Soul Dew got banned.
Hence I didn't say ban Mega Absol, ban Absolite
Aldrius said:What COULD happen is Absolite could get banned to BL or BL2 if Absol is in UU/RU and is deemed too strong for that tier with Absolite.
I thought I had established this as my best case scenario, but maybe I didn't make myself clear.
Aldrius said:MegaAbsol is Absol... but better in every single way.
But is the key word. How is regular evolution any different? 95% of the time, evolving improves the pokemon. SAME WITH MEGA EVOLUTION! Just another similarity between mega evolution and regular evolution and another reason why they should be treated similarly.
Aldrius said:Also how the hell would a megastone clause work? There's 30 of them and they're all totally different.
That's kinda the point. Each stone gets treated separately according to how they affect the metagame. Your Gengar example doesn't work because Gengar and Mega Gengar are both OU quality pokemon for the reasons you pointed out. A better example would be the intimidate users (like Mawile) who basically get 2 abilities (and yes, that was me admitting you have a point)
Aldrius said:OU/UU/RU/NU/PU placement is based on USAGE, not on power. And Absolite's USAGE will not be counted.
This is your only point I can't ignore. The only precedent I can really turn to is Lati@s and soul dew, because Lati@s usage in uber never affected its OU status. But I guess that example doesn't completely apply to this situation because of the weird relationship between OU and Uber. I guess it'll come down to how people start interpreting the rule, and if they want to follow a strict version of the (self installed) rule, or follow precedent of times like gen IV where they faced similar problems (forms, new evolutions, etc.) and chose right instead of like in gen III where they chose wrong (soul dew, but they fixed that).
And I'll end with a question, why do I keep getting into arguments on the Absol page? I never seem to tick this many people off on other discussions.