Suisho said:Ad hominem attacks and straw man arguments. Lovely.
You don't have to like it. The facts are the facts. I recommend you check out for yourself the archived discussions about whether or not to ban Stealth Rock back in 2007. The staff's position -- the same staff that came up with the OHKO and Evasion Clauses long before Stealth Rock was even up for debate -- was that there is a difference between things which are uncompetitive (e.g. Mega Mewtwo Y in OU) and things which are competitive but require people to change their habits (e.g. Stealth Rock). We should ban things which are uncompetitive, but we must not ban things which are competitive yet force people outside their comfort zone.
You clearly believe that Parafusion Pranksters are uncompetitive. And I have to stress that I'm not exactly a fan of them myself. But I disagree with you that they are uncompetitive. At most, they are a gimmick team: and like all gimmick teams, they are highly effective against the ill-prepared but crumple before those that have taken the necessary precautions. This site's policy has never been "BAN ALL GIMMICKS!" What it has been is to ban any gimmick which was uncompetitive. So you see Moody banned but not the combination of Truant Entrainment Durant + Shadow Tag Chandelure (early Gen 5 DW OU). You see putting more than one Pokémon at a time to sleep banned but not F.E.A.R. Pokémon. If a "gimmick" ensures its user victory even against well-prepared teams or is too centralizing to prepare for (emphasis: too), then it's hardly a gimmick and is likely to get banned. If a gimmick is worthless before well-prepared teams and if becoming well-prepared necessitates you need only drop one of your six Pokémon or drop one of your twenty-four moves for something new, then it is what it is: a gimmick. And one that's not going to be banned if past precedent is any indication.
Anyway, banning Swagger + Prankster is far too crude and far too extreme a solution. It would be better to instate a Prankster clause that limits the number of Pranksters you can have on one team. People who aren't abusing Prankster's potential are already running one or no Pranksters. It's only the problem players who are running six Pranksters that we're worried about here. With a limitation of only one or two Pranksters per team, you can allow people who like Liepard or similar Pokémon to continue to enjoy their Prankster while at the same time giving the opponent a fair chance at overcoming the Prankster and winning.
Uhh there was no ad hominem I said your arguments were shit, not you. Anyways comparing SR to prankster swagger is really stupid, I understand what you mean about adaptation, but that was not ever part of my argument, I solely argued that they were uncompetitive, which you stated you disagreed with but never gave a reason for. Although something is a gimmick, it doesn't mean it isn't uncompetitive, and as you stated yourself:
If a "gimmick" ensures its user victory even against well-prepared teams or is too centralizing to prepare for (emphasis: too), then it's hardly a gimmick and is likely to get banned.
How is using terrible pokemon with own tempo that are unviable against regular OU teams not
too centralizing, or random lum berries (sounds pretty centralizing to me if your solution is, "lets throw a lum berry on it,"), even stuff like safeguard has no real use outside of countering swag play teams (and prankster swagger still moves first, so that really has a 55% chance of working anyways, not to mention taunt Thundurus). Even moody has better counters than prankster swagger now that roar can't miss, but no one is clamoring for the unban of moody, because it is still uncompetitive and allows victory through luck alone rather than a combination of (unavoidable) luck and skill.
Anyway, banning Swagger + Prankster is far too crude and far too extreme a solution. It would be better to instate a Prankster clause that limits the number of Pranksters you can have on one team.
I have to disagree with this, as it is far more damaging to ban multiple prankster users on one team then it is to ban the combination of prankster and swagger, as there is nothing explicitly uncompetitive about a team using Sableye, Klefki, Thundurus, and Tornadus together (all prankster mons that can function outside of prankster swagger). You also pretty much undermine all of your post with this paragraph, if prankster swagger is competitive, why do you need to limit it? Shouldn't it be okay to use 6 prankster swagger mons if you can use one? I guess I really don't understand the difference.
Once again, sorry if my first post offended you or you thought I was attacking you, but you never actually argued that prankster swagger was competitive, you just started with the assumption it was and undermined your own post later. The comparison of SR to Prank Swag is also pretty terrible, because one is a move that introduces no luck to the game, and can't even be argued as uncompetitive, to one that relies solely on the introduction of luck.