jg1198 said:I understand and have stated several times that yes, Kabutops does need support in the form of rain, but the amount of OHKO's and 2HKO's it gets while being extremely hard to revenge thanks to his speed boost, priority that outspeeds almost all other priority, and resistance to extremespeed, makes it an extremely viable sweeper, at the cost of some support. I also don't understand why people act as though rain is so hard to keep up, as most teams do not carry a weather setter, and all common weather setters are very easily taken out by Kabutops, especially if rocks are up for Char-Y, and changing the weather is by no means a total stop to Kabutops, as bringing in a Tyranitar or Hippowdon invites Kabutops to either eliminate it, or smack a switch in with a +2 life orb boosted STAB attack, which is still going to hurt, with or without rain, as shown in the calcs of stone edge, which of course is not boosted by rain, destroying mega Venusaur. And of course, even if you can't get to +2, Rain and life orb is often more than enough to clean up weakened offensive teams. Kabutops is by no means helpless before a boost. All of this together, should definitely be enough to get Kabutops moved up to at least a minimum of a B- tier, in the company of mons such as Roserade, Zygarde, and Sharpedo.
Yes you did state that, but I was just restating it as points for my points. I will say a few things on what you said though as they themselves are good points and I would like to discuss them as well.
Everything you said is true, but I believe the perception of rain is just how it seems so...out of place now. We have new ways to combat it (via Mega evolving to start wather, thus combating a switch in) and that people seeing it as easier to fight make it seem less reliable. It doesn't help that Poli is still lack luster, and that he now is required to take more damage than before (true, a secondary dancer is lovely with him) via multiple switch ins, more than weather wars of old and such.
His power, as I stated earlier, is undeniably great with him being one of the best SSers, but he is weak to Ground, Fighting, Electric, Grass (x4), and while he has useful resistances and nice base Defense, he is un able to switch in as easily and set up like he would wish. Resisting three of the most used on Priorities are nice, but he is also weak to the other two (which is debatably an issue as Jet is neutral to most users of those two moves while being faster) but he is also weak to some of the most common coverage moves in the game. Earthquake, Thunderbolt, and Close Combat are always an issue, and his Special Defense almost certainly leads to death while his Defense can save him from most, to just making them 2HKOs. His switch in opportunities are not very fun sadly as that hurts him.
To the Pokemon you mentioned, I see it as an interesting quandary. Sharpedo almost certainly needs to drop in my mind, the other two have earned the spots well. Sure Zygarde isn't Gar, but its not suppose to be. It has its own traits to abuse in the fun SubCoil set and, if you really want, the DDance set. Roserade is one of the best offensive Grass type special attackers as it is able to break through common grass walls with Technician boosted HP and give great support in a variety of ways.
The comments on it being moved up is nice, but I just don't know if B- needs yet another guy in there... I believe that is what's making me argue harder than normal, but I do not yet think Kabu is able to get any higher in my mind.
Although the fact that Sharpedo of all things is above it sickens me...