Rafael J. Feliciano said:I agree with this analysis, however, banning Scolipede would only make BP teams consider Focus Sash Ninjask since he has Speed Boost + Baton Pass + Protect + Insert boosting move(s) here...
Like you said... this is the ONE time where... if a ban were to take place... that a Complex Ban might be needed....
Also, on a speculative note... I believe that the Complex Ban would have to be something involving "Speed Boost + Magic Bounce."
Yes I understand that would mean that Sharpedo and Xatu, as AlphaSpade mentioned, would be unintentional collateral in this but, this would be the "simplest" complex ban due to the fact that the distribution of these moves (4 mons with Speed Boost & 3 with Magic Bounce) is very limited and thus, would have the biggest impact on BP teams without affecting the rest of the Meta.
When I tried Ninjask, there was only one thing that came to mind, "this guy sucks." Seriously, he can't take a hit, ever. he can protect and substitute for 6 turns, but he'll literally never get to use that stat move (which would be limited to either Swords Dance, hone claws, or agility). He'd lose to literally any pokemon with priority (other than sucker punch), is incredible set up bait, and can pretty much be used once, maybe twice, so the niche counters will be significantly more reliable. He still beats most stall teams, but he's so bad against just about everything else that no serious player can expect to use him and win against a half-way decent player. If you want to ladder with BP teams, you'll be forced to use Gliscor, Zapdos, or Smeargle. BP teams will still be an auto win vs bad players, but if I can add something to that list you quoted, it'd be
We don't care about low rank players.
Now, on a totally different note, I don't think an action against Espeon or Magic Bounce will solve anything. Besides taunt and phazing, substitute takes care of things just fine, so banning Espeon will just result in more ingrain and Mr. Mime usage. Stall teams will be forced to carry either taunt, or whirlwind and a way to deal with Smeargle on literally every team, which is miles ahead of where we are now (especially since whirlwind is actually decent on Skarmory), but that wouldn't be my first choice.
scorpdestroyer said:Drizzle wasn't banned because it isn't broken alone, Swift Swim wasn't banned because it isn't broken alone, Politoed wasn't banned because it isn't broken alone. Drizzle + Swift Swim as a combination was the very thing that was broken, so it got banned, while other obviously non-broken strategies could still be used, such as Rain stall and Thunder/Hurricane/Hydro Pump, the difference being not every relevant user of those strategies were broken while almost everything that got Swift Swim could abuse perma rain to the point of broken.
Same thing I see here with Baton Pass. I'm pretty sure this argument has already been said but: Baton Pass is not broken on its own, Speed Boost + Baton Pass is not broken on its own, Magic Bounce + Baton Pass is not broken on its own, Magic Bounce + Speed Boost + Baton Pass is not broken, etc. It's a combination of 6 Pokemon that make it broken. Banning any individual move or Pokemon would make no sense in this case when they are obviously not at fault.
If you were a newcomer to Smogon and saw the banlist, what would you think of a ban on, say, the combination of Magic Bounce + Speed Boost? I get that this is hardly a good argument but the point is that banning a combo of Magic Bounce + Speed Boost or something similar is unnecessarily complicated. How would you explain this complex ban? "oh this combo is banned because Espeon and Scolipede with Baton Pass are commonly seen on Baton Pass chains and BP chains are broken"? I do see the reasoning behind these proposals but I believe they are unnecessarily complex and difficult to understand at surface value; they don't get to the core of what is broken. Every single proposal so far, be it for a Speed Boost + Magic Bounce ban, boils down to how they are broken because of Baton Pass.
If that was difficult to understand, see it this way: if you take away Baton Pass, would Scolipede or Espeon be broken? Nah. If you take away Scolipede and Espeon, would BP chains be broken? They'll surely be less powerful but it's still very easy to play around a team without phazers or Taunt users. Why are we probing so far when Baton Pass is obviously the issue?
Now, I've stated that BP alone is not broken, and I'm sure many of us would agree. It's the combination of BP users in a team that make it so. Hence, I'm all for the argument of ban multiple BP users per team. Simple, to the point. No need for roundabout bans of Espeon/Scolipede/whatever because themselves alone aren't the issue. Of course, there comes the issue of what number is the limit. But going by the number of important Pokemon in BP teams, we should be able to derive a number. For instance, every full BP chain needs a speed booster, a magic bounce/soundproof user, and a defense booster at the bare minimum. I propose that limiting 3 baton pass users is a good number that would significantly nerf BP chains while retaining the benefit of every section of BP chains on their own.
My problem with this post is the line "Baton Pass is so obviously the issue."
It is obviously
an issue, but any argument about how those pokemon aren't broken without baton pass can go the other way, and say that baton pass isn't broken without those pokemon.
I posted
here my thought process, but basically, Espeon and Scolipede are definitely issues too, just less obvious because support pokemon rarely get the reaction offensive ones do.