Bruce(hitmon)Lee said:I just created this account because in order to reply to this thread. I've been playing ps for a little over 2 years now and here're my two cents:
Since the release of XY OU, I had only seen 1 baton pass team. This of course changed with the news report on Pokemon Showdown discussing baton pass and its effects on the metagame. I was a little confused because it is a difficult task to define something as over centralizing or unhealthy for the meta when it is only seen once.
After this news release, I decided I'd try out baton pass. It faired pretty well and netted me a decent amount of wins. The problem is, the same thing would occur if someone used a powerful pokemon such as say talonflame against only teams that had no checks/counters to it. It is widely accepted that in order to have a successful team you need a check to certain pokemon. This causes people to do things such as, run earthquake over contact moves for aegislash, run heatran/rotom-w/etc. for talonflame, run taunt over a coverage move to shut down deo-d, etc etc etc. Changing one move or pokemon to counter a whole new team archetype is not a new thing, so why is it so unwelcome? One cannot expect to run a team that counters every single team type or pokemon, this is why you must pick and choose your pokemon, and why pokemon reamains so unpredictabole and fun. How fun would the metagame be if everyone always ran the same things and was able to counter every pokemon. (sounds almost like current ou anyway, heatran, rotom-w, talonflame, mega pinsir, tyranitar, aegislash, etc.... change would be fun). Maybe baton pass will become a problem if it is used as much as the current top ou pokemon are, but at the moment, I just do not view it as one.
P.S. I beat the one baton pass team I saw, even though I was unprepared for it haha
TheZokeShipper said:Now that I think about it, I haven't seen a single BP team in my entire time on PS, and even though I only started at the beginning of Gen 6, that's a fairly long time, about 6 months, without facing such a "threat". Honestly, while it is cheap to use an entire BP team to win, it's not nearly that common, at least from my experiences. Is it really necessary to impose such a ban on an obsolete strategy that is entirely predictable and counter-able? Swagger was considered too powerful, but it's a legitimate playstyle based on luck, which one might argue are similar to a lot of playstyles of the current metagame, like ParaFlinch and Super Luck. I think that if a player could actually pull off a 5-Pokémon chain without a hitch, and being able to outsmart the opponent enough to get that final Pokemon out and ready to sweep, deserves the win, because it is fairly manageable to deal with. Good strategies should be embraced, and that includes BP, so I'm in favor of keeping it. Again, just my opinion, but feel free to bash, because I feel strongly about this topic, and would enjoy a friendly, or not-so-friendly discussion.
EDIT: I have no negative feelings towards those who believe differently, and in no way mean to insult either. I just wish to convey my point of view.
I'm going to stop you guys right there, because we went down this road before, and it led nowhere.
Something only has to be common enough to get noticed, see
Haunter's Post, but Baton Pass is a lot more common, especially on suspect ladders, than you give it credit for, and even if it weren't a common problem, it could still be worthy of a ban.
tehy said:Can i just point out that you need a really, really good reason to make complex bans? Honestly, what we're trying to do seems like "let's nerf it so it's not broken" (is it even broken? who knows) but is still good. That's a dangerous line. You're risking either just nerfing it too hard, thus basically banning it, or still leaving it too good.
Either ban it entirely or don't ban it at all. If you really want to do a complex ban to preserve other forms of baton pass, not an entirely illegitimate endeavor, ban more than one baton pass user on a team.
Or give me a really good reason why there should be a complex ban, because I just don't see it.
The main reasonings are that banning BP would unnecessarily eliminate quick passing, and since the pokemon on BP teams are only broken on that specific team, nobody wants to ban them either. The # limit has plenty of precedence, so we don't need to justify that, and I'm in the same boat as you when it comes to things like Stored Power + Baton Pass.