I haven't posted in the thread yet, but I've read through the 60+ pages and lurked constantly so I thought I'd throw in my two cents.
- Is Baton Pass (with specific reference to full Baton Pass teams) a problem for the development of the metagame?
I'd like to say so. It's a team that's shockingly similar to make, and use, AND it also allows it to easily beat teams that don't have a good counter. As a personal anecdote, I'd like to share a few /ranks that I have.
1630 GXE:78 67-33-2
1463 GXE:84 46-11-0
1410 GXE:79 18-0-0
The first is one of my main laddering accounts (not as high of a ranking as I'd like because I often use it to test ideas), the second is the account I used to get suspect reqs for the last OU suspect, and the last is a fresh account I used to play around with baton pass. It's ridiculous how much of a cruise control the game becomes once you use baton pass. Heck, I had a friend tell me today "lol I got to 1300 on OU with deniss's baton pass team!" It's not that impressive when you think about it, but this friend I'm talking about has no pokemon knowledge. Like, he doesn't even know the types, or the new pokemon and moves. And he's at 1300?
I know there's a lot of arguments on both sides and I know the precedents, but I'm leaning on the opinion that something needs to be done for baton pass chains.
- If so, what elements, in particular, do you think are pushing Baton Pass over the edge?
That's pretty easy. Two answers: Scolipede and Sylveon. Scolipede is Ninjask with 44 more base def, 16 more base spD, a base 100 attack that has some semblance of threat. Scolipede also has iron defense, which Ninjask does not. Being able to pass defense and speed together is an extremely helpful tool. Sylveon is also extremely tanky, has great typing, and a very powerful STAB that also bypasses substitutes. These two together allow a baton pass team to gather defense quickly to not get overrun by most offense.
- Do you believe that banning individual Pokémon (such as Espeon/Scolipede) would make Baton Pass manageable?
While it's undeniable banning one or the other or both would make Baton pass more manageable (if not outright crippled), I'm not too in favor of that. These pokemon aren't broken by themselves and I'd like to see them used, just not in something like baton pass.
- Would you support a blanket ban on the move Baton Pass?
No. Baton pass has a lot of other uses like passing a sub, escaping pursuit, and smashpass. I do not support a blanket ban on baton pass just to nerf baton pass chains.
- Would you support the introduction of complex bans (like Pokémon X+Pokémon Y on the same team)? Feel free to suggest more forms of complex bans, of course.
Probably a limit on number of passers in a team. This way, there will be less collateral damage. I'd say 3-4 baton passers max, but I know a baton pass only really needs 3 to function (Scolipede, Espeon, Sylveon, the 3 most important members of a baton pass chain)