DaSpoofy said:In the no scald tier, bulky waters are not as common making stuff like maero darmanitan and feraligator really good atm. This is really fun... for now but I dont believe this will be healthy in the uu tier and for smogon as a whole.
Hikari this would be fun as a random tour in uu but this can not become a pernament thing.
Removing Scald doesn't lower the viability of bulky waters in this aspect. The meta still needs time to adapt and will likely have water mons resurface in order to keep dealing with Darm, Entei, etc.
DaSpoofy said:Banning scald is banning the prevelancy of bulky waters. Have you ever seen the disney movie Heracles? Remember all those demons in the lightning jail? Pretent Zeus is the bulky water types. If we ban zues, all the monsters get out and ruin the earth. So many things become op with no scald. We become a whole new meta which means more bans and more suspect tests.
As is reinforced in every suspect test thread. Broken things keeping broken things in check does not constitute a balanced metagame.
DaSpoofy said:Well, that doesnt sound too bad but the point is not what this does to uu meta but what it does to smogon. We ban scald then pu bans knock off then lc bans eviolite then ru bans choice scarf then hackmons bans wonder guard. Wow all this sounds really fun but for how long? We can start something way bigger than we thought and its not healthy. We have counters to bulky waters. Sure they are annoying but they are not unfair.
Slippery slope logical fallacy, try again.
DaSpoofy said:Earlier in the thread there was some discussion whether we should ban other stuff like sacred fire, steam eruption, and even wil o wisp. Banning wil o wisp is just plain stupid because we have plenty of stuff that can deal with it. As Hikari stated earlier, sacred fire and steam eruption are not common and if they were, then this scald thing would be the least of our problems. If sacred fire was really op then entei would be banned... but its not.
Sacred Fire is a really fucking good move. If it was widespread it would be getting a similar treatment as Scald most likely. As it stands, three pokemon learn Sacred Fire. One is BL, albeit for different reasons, one is uber and really fucking good because Sacred Fire is physical now, and one is our beloved Entei who is one of the best mons in UU because of Sacred Fire.
DaSpoofy said:Scald is really unique in the sense that what ever cant get burned takes super effective damage from it. Its a rotom wash in a move. Rrotom wash is really really good at doing what it does but it will never be banned because its not op. Its just really annoying.
The issue arises when important matches are determined from dodging 10 Scald burns in a row or from landing 10 Scald burns in a row. The debilitating effect of the move has been a critical factor in deciding many tournament and high level matches. The threat of switching anything aside from your own water-type into a Scald prevents a lot of different options in game and often leads to cases where whoever burns whom first is in a ridiculously favorable position.
DaSpoofy said:We have banned stuff that is really annoying in the past; swagger, multiple baton passes, evasion. Do these things out rank scald? Absolutely! We dont have a lot of anti confusion tactics, not every team should have roar, and we dont have a good pokemon move that always hits that exceeds 60 base power... except vital throw i think. These annoying things were banned because we didnt have enough resources to keep them at bay. With scald we do. We have water absorb, natural cure, and dry skin. Plus most grass and electric pokemon are special attackers. To be honest, I dont care if scald gets banned. Im scared of what may go with it. Ou is already following in our footsteps. Whats stopping smogon from an overconstricting rebirth?
Again, slippery slope is not a good way to phrase your argument. Smogon as an entity isn't deciding what is and isn't banned, they provide the means for the general populace to decide.
Also, it's not a fucking suspect test. Stop treating it like it is.