bludz said:So I don't know if this has been gone over but what's the consensus on multiple sets?
So for example Stallbreaker Talonflame is a good switch-in to Charizard Y but other sets are not. Similarly, AV Slowking is a good switch-in to Charizard Y, but without the AV it fails to check. Yet Talonflame is listed as a GSI and Slowking is only SSI.
Edit; nvm about the other part but I'm still curious about this.
I basically assume the best possible matchup, so if at least one Talonflame set can switch into Charizard Y every time, then Talonflame will be a GSI. That said, Slowking vs Charizard Y is sort of a tricky case. It can be 2HKOed by Solar Beam depending on SpD investment (greater chance or even guaranteed after Stealth Rock), and it can't guarantee a 2HKO back without Power Gem. Do people still run Power Gem Slowking? Because I'm fine with taking it into consideration if it's a reasonably viable move, but even if it is, the large or guaranteed chance for Solar Beam to 2HKO after Stealth Rock makes Slowking more SSI worthy.
As for KidMagic's stuff, I'll address a few of the things disputed above.
Weavile =SSI (Non Low Kick) - I think this should be NSI because suppose that Weavile carries Low Kick, Cobalion loses 100% of the time. And low Kick is one of the common 4th moves for Weavile (the only other choices are Swords Dance and Poison Jab)
Low Kick appears on less than half of all Weavile according to last month's 1825 stats, so non-Low Kick variants are more than common enough for Cobalion to be an SSI. Also, don't forget Pursuit, which is significantly more common than Poison Jab.
Mbeedrill= (Scarf) - NSI because getting hit by U-Turn / Knock Off sucks. Also, you cannot OHKO unless you run Fire Punch / Zen Headbutt
I try to give things a little leeway when it comes to U-turn since, if you think about it, there are no safe switch-ins to U-turn (unless your opponent has no checks to your switch-in). I'll go with NSI for now, though, because it's such a borderline case.
Breloom = SSI (SubPunch threat/otherwise relatively safe) - Is Focus Punch Breloom still used nowadays?
Yep.
MLopunny=NSI (HJK hurts/Scarf) - Need Zen Headbutt to win
This goes for more suggestions than just this one, but Zen Headbutt is a reasonably common and viable move on Scarf Jirachi, so it's okay if Jirachi requires Zen Headbutt to win.
I'm good with all of the other suggestions KidMagic made and the other corrections that Random Passerby made. I'll add them shortly. Thanks!