I have been meaning to comment on the wonderful Voodoom model by
noobiess for some time. But I definitely do not want to come off as being nitpicky or overprotective of the design, because it was originally "my design". I quote that, because the winning CAP art design becomes "our design" the moment it wins. And I personally get immense joy and pride seeing other artists do their own interpretations of Voodoom.
But this 3D modeling effort strikes me more as *representing* the designs, not *interpreting* the designs -- so I can perhaps give some more information to help make an accurate representation. Also I originally intended to do a model sheet for Voodoom, and never got around to it. Which is another reason I have been hesitant to offer up any corrections to the model, if anything because I felt a bit guilty about not making a model sheet in the first place.
Beautiful work
noobiess, and thank you so much for the work you have put in to help bring Voodoom to life in 3D! Based off the sprite, I think your representation is very good. But the sprite does differ from the design, mostly from body proportions standpoint. Aragornbird made a beautiful sprite, but it is thinner and more "human shaped" than the main design. Obviously, I prefer the main design ;-)
The 3D modeling effort in this thread seems to be working mostly from the original designs, and I think that is a good thing. Oftentimes spriters had to cut corners and make compromises with the design to make a sprite that looked good with so few pixels to work with. However, the 3D models have much fewer constraints, so I really feel we should be seeking to go back to the original designs as much as possible when making models.
With all that said, here are my summary notes on the current Voodoom model, with more details below that:
- The arms should be shorter and fatter, and they should widen more as they connect to the main body.
- The body should be a bit rounder too. The support poses below show this better than the main design.
- The legs should be fatter too, although I think I overdid it a bit in the support pics below. I think the main design captures the leg proportions most accurately.
- I don't think it is necessary to include the finger on the left hand in the model. Much more on the notorious "extra finger" below.
- The broken right eye button should be noticeably bigger than the unbroken left eye button.
Here are two support pics I posted with my Voodoom main design, showing how Voodoom fit a couple of things that were controversial at the time:
The first is a sketch that made it absolutely clear that Lightningrod could work. It gives a good alternate perspective on the head and eye buttons. The second pic was to help curb criticism that the design didn't "look like a Special Attacker". Several people commented to me that the second pic was a big turning point for them in voting for the design, so I guess it did the job!
Now more than you ever wanted to know about...
The Needle
With both pics I wanted to spark people's imagination in uses for the big needle, which is the centerpeice of the design. I envisioned Voodoom using his own heart as kindof "a scabbard" for the needle, and it would pull the needle out to use it as a magic wand (shown above) or as a sword. I noticed a comment that
noobiess should not model the full needle all the way through the interior of the body. However, I could imagine special move animations where it pulls the needle out, so perhaps the full needle model is a good thing? I don't know, so I'll leave it to those of you more familiar with how such things are done.
The Extra Finger
The extra finger has been something mentioned off and on in the past, as to whether it is a permanent required appendage or not. I originally put it on the main design, because I was thinking of the Voodoo doll as a big mushy "bean bag" of sorts, with a somewhat malleable body. I didn't want it to be a completely amorphous blob like Ditto or whatever, but I originally thought it could alter its shape, if necessary.
So I drew it with that extra finger sticking out, mostly because I thought it made the pose look a little more "agile". With fingerless hands, it always looks like the character is wearing fat mittens or gloves. And that is great for fists, which look like big boxing gloves, which is awesome visually for a Fighting type. But when we decided to give Voodoom 110 speed, I had a bit of a problem on my hands. Because a stubby-legged, mitten-wearing bean bag does not exactly evoke images of it outrunning Manectric or keeping up with a jet airplane pokemon like Latios. So I posed the main design with one arm with a fist (to keep with the Fighting look, which was necessary) and I extended the other arm out, to convey motion or dodging. The little finger was just a little touch to make it not look like a "mitten hand". I didn't think much of it.
The whole idea of Voodoom having an amorphous shape -- well, that idea died probably before I even submitted the main design. It ws just one of those many things that came and went in my head as I was working on the design. And as you can see in the support pics above, I certainly never considered the extra finger an integral part of the design.
But later, particularly when the sprite and other Voodoom fan art was made, people mentioned the finger, and questioned whether it was a part of the design or not. Some people thought it really added something to the design and made Voodoom look less "perfect", having mismatched hands etc. I never really came down on one side or the other, and have preferred to leave it to the artist's interpretation whether they want to include it or not.