The Diabolic Gift said:I think Sawk is pretty broken right now in Neverused.
Can you give me a legitimate scenario where a non-choiced sawk does not get a free kill as a lead?
Sawk’s Combination of Sturdy and having absolutely no counter even without running a band make it the scariest Pokemon in NU.
The problem with Vileplume is that it can’t provide the damage to actually beat sawk and even if it could then it would still not break it’s sturdy. Sleep Powder could work but if Sawk uses taunt Vileplume can’t survive 2 zen headbutts. Scyther seems like a good idea but it’s unable to break sturdy and if it were to pivot out to try and break sturdy it would risk not only coming in on rocks but it would risk the switch in fainting as well. Even if Scyther does manage to get Sawk to the point that it is able to KO sawk, sawk simply can switch out. Pyroar, Archeops, Swellow and Jynx could have OHKO’d but due to sturdy still will get defeated by sawk. Even more proving sawk has “a free kill”, poison types like Gardobor and Weezing sure can switch into a CC but in both cases cannot even OHKO the sawk at -1 and you lose a mon anyways. Rotom-S and Pelipper cannot handle stone edge and fail at beating Sawk 1v1 as long as it doesn’t run taunt. All psychic types cannot OHKO because of sturdy and either are OHKO’d or are slower than sawk and cannot take 2 hits.
- Vileplume can simply Giga Drain out of Zen Headbutt 2HKO range. Baiting Sawk into using Close Combat and/or crippling it with Effect Spore makes the matchup even better for Plume.
- Taunt Sawk doesn't have room for Stone Edge so it is pretty screwed if Scyther chooses to stay in, but even assuming the Scyther player expects the CB Stone Edge, he/she can just make the conservative play and U-turn to break Sturdy without risking itself, or gain momentum should Sawk switch out
and be informed that Sawk most likely isn't carrying Stone Edge. Don't know why Scyther would worry about SR at that point when, you know, Sawk is the lead and not the SRer in question.
- If Sawk so much as touches Garbodor it loses Sturdy and, again, baiting the Close Combat for the Defense drops puts Garbo in a much better position.
- Weezing is in a more awkward position, but considering it is one of the best Sawk switch-ins in the tier and the fact that it is not the end of the world if it gets hit by an Expert Belt Zen Headbutt, it isn't
too much to lose really. In fact Weezing is one of the main reasons Taunt Sawk managed to integrate itself well despite the overwhelming prowess of CB Sawk (Gourgeist-Super is another big reason).
- The Psychic-types already equip Colbur Berry to handle CB Sawk such that
none of them are OHKOed, so they shouldn't struggle much more with Taunt Sawk; the faster Psychics (Xatu and +Spe Mesprit, assuming Adamant Sawk) can easily survive Knock Off + Close Combat, while Musharna practically doesn't care, putting a lot of pressure on Sawk to nail them with Knock Off on the switch or miss its chance to beat them.
Simply put, you're over-exaggerating most of these matchups, and Taunt Sawk simply doesn't get the 'free kill' you expect it to unless the opposing team doesn't have solid Sawk checks in the first place (or if the Sawk user consistently makes flawless predictions). Choice Band is usually preferred anyway for 3 big reasons: it lets Sawk perform the
hitbrutalize-and-run tactic much more effectively, the greatly improved OHKOing potential of its Close Combat subjects it to less direct harm, and it usually only needs to make one solid prediction to utterly ruin most of its checks.