Truth be told, before playing the game myself I had watched someone stream roughly the first half of it in a pacifist playthrough, up to the Mad Dummy fight. This is what convinced me to buy the game in the first place, so I entered knowing how to spare Toriel, but I feel like even if I had gone into the game completely blind, I would've been able to figure out how to do it. I spent a lot of time exploring the environment and talking with the frogs in the Ruins, more so than what I had already seen of the game, and I think I could've picked up on the various hints that were dropped.
Undyne stumped me pretty hard, though. I didn't look up a guide or anything, but I died about six or seven times because I kept challenging / pleading with her. Her dialogue continues to change regardless of what action you take, so it sort of leads you on into thinking the fight is just an absurdly long endurance test. The actual solution came to me on a whim, when I realized that fleeing was the only option I hadn't tried.
In retrospect, the game does quite a bit to hint at the solution, just like with Toriel. She opens the fight with a comment along the lines of "No more running away!", she specifically mentions that you can't escape as long as you're green (the "can't escape" text is even highlighted in red), and her check description mentions that she NEVER gives up. It did make me feel awfully clever upon figuring it out, and really hammered in the unconventional nature of the pacifist boss fights.
newtonja said:Hide
so I just completed the pacifist route for the second time. The way I planned to play the game was do pacifist genocide pacifist but I kinda got thrown off course when I reached sans. Now I kept fighting him and fighting him and it was at this point that I truly started to question my motives for doing the genocide route in the first place and what sans said really rang true with me, I was doing it simply because it was there (also to brag to my friends). When I discovered this is lost all motivation to continue, I just felt so wrong and empty so I decided to abort the genocide route entirely and right my wrongs by doing the pacifist route. For the most part I felt atoned for my sins but there was this little part of me that just nagged at me saying that I killed all of these people. when flowey reprimanded me, it brought all this guilt to light and I have decided never to attempt the genocide route again.
Your response to the genocide route is really interesting. It's amazing that Undertale can really invest you in your relationship with the characters, and force you to realistically weigh the consequences of your actions. It seems like the Sans fight had the exact effect on you that I think it was designed to; to force you to reevaluate whether sheer curiosity and completion is worth betraying the friendships you've already fostered.
I had planned to take the same approach to my multiple playthroughs (pacifist, then genocide, then pacifist again to make myself feel good about my actions again), and Sans' words resonated just as much with you as with me; however, it didn't stop me from seeing my murderous rampage through to its end.
After completing the genocide route and the game unceremoniously dumps you back into a completely new reset of the game, I was desperately paranoid of some lasting consequence showing up. The way the game just seems to completely forget everything that just happened, especially given its penchant for remembering your past decisions, was far too suspicious. But of course, nothing happens immediately, and at about the point I had reached Undyne again I got bored of playing the same game again and just stopped. I eventually just looked up what happens at the end of the pacifist route again, and was chilled by its implications. Undertale suspends the weight of your sins until the very moment you think you've atoned for them, then drops it right on your head.
In that sense, I think there's something poetic about the fact that I decided shelve the game indefinitely. If I were to complete the game again, I ensure the death of all the characters this game has made me care about so much. I've effectively destroyed any chance for a happy ending. The only way to keep them safe is to deny them their wish for freedom, and keep them imprisoned in the Underground forever. And myself with them, I suppose.