Cresselia~~ said:Not sure if this count as unpopular opinions.
But I just don't buy into the theory "Game Freak wants people to forget about Jynx"
(etc.)
I don't think GF or the Pokemon Company has any bias against any Pokemon (maybe against Raichu, but only in the sense that no other Pikaclone has had an evolution). However with over 700 Pokemon sadly they need to be selective with what Pokemon they choose to advertise.
As for Jynx specifically, well there's really no specific situation where it fits in aside for winter stuff and background filler. In the eyes of Pokemon fans Jynx does have the advantage of being a Gen I Pokemon but, and probably more importantly, still needing a Mega Evolution.
Cresselia~~ said:It would only be controversial to Americans though.
Hm, maybe a little though only by those who are easily offended. Remember an important aspect about the Jynx controversy had nothing to do with it but rather the popularity of Pokemon. Now Carole Boston Weatherford has a point that the Japanese do use the blackface stereotype in stuff while not understanding its an offensive portrayal of African Americans. And I do believe Jynx takes a bit of design from blackface, at least when they were designing it. However at the same time if Pokemon wasn't popular I doubt she would have mentioned it. There's a ton of anime, manga, and Japanese stuff with blackface visual and (though some did change when brought to the US but by the dubbers) yet she specifically targeted Pokemon and Dragon Ball Z, two popular anime at the time. Until then no one really cared what color Jynx's face was since, while a "humanoid", didn't look human enough for people to go "hey, isn't this a bit offensive to black people". Carole Boston Weatherford was known to attack Eastern culture for blackface stuff so of course she saw Jynx as such (though she did have a point with Mr. Popo, though he's sort of a clash of African and Indian (as in people from the country India) stereotypes). So in a way you could argue she was projecting some of her bias on Jynx when no one else was. However if they kept its design despite that I think the mast majority wouldn't care, but if silencing some criticism is as easy as a repaint than there's no harm in doing that plus it'll look good to parents who may have been worried about exposing their kids to negative stereotypes.
It's important to remember GF and the Pokemon Company are a kid's company, they target audience is kids (or rather their parent's wallets). Controversy is a bad thing, no matter the situation. If the controversy can be "solved" with little trouble like repainting Jynx's face, not airing a filler episode, or for Porygon case not have it be in any more anime episodes then a company would prefer to do that then try to change people's mind. That all said if they added Porygon back into the anime I don't think anyone would care, even though affected by the seizures. Now the episodes involving earthquakes and attack on Castelia City are examples of bad timing, Japan had earthquakes which did a lot of damage and took lives so having episodes which could remind people of that would be incredibly in poor taste. The Whiscash episode was filler so that didn't matter, though that did mess up the planned Team Plasma arc (though I still argued they messed it up by not having them appear earlier like they do in the games but that's beside the point). Doesn't matter who the market is or how many number of people it affects, if the change is easy to make without affecting much of anything for the most part a company will do the change.
Cresselia~~ said:Americans also do not spend much on official merchandise.
Well maybe if they brought over more merchandise we would. Or at least sell them on the online store, Pokemon is a big enough company I think they can do international delivery (they'd probably have the products delivered at the same time they get a restock delivery so it probably wouldn't cost them any more).