motherlove said:<snip for space>
Well, that first bit assumes A) You already know about Anchor Shot being present and B) You have something that is ensured to win the 1v1. Stuff like Stakeout Draco Meteor Primaldon exist to OHKO your Giratina switch-in, so you can't be 100% certain. There's also times where it can be advantageous to stay in on a bad match-up for a turn or two if your confident your opponent expects you to switch. So like, that Primaldon uses Shift Gear, expecting a free turn, and your Solgaleo bops it with Glare. Next turn, he V-Creates, but he hits your Fur Coat Zygarde instead, so now you've crippled their sweeper and also have momentum. Whereas, if you always switch to Giratina the moment Groudon shows up, your opponent, if he's any decent, will find a way to punish such timid play.
As for Edit 1, it's really the lack of counterplay that does make it, well, I'm leaning on unhealthy rather than overpowered. Again, if you're not a Fairy or slower, it suppresses your ability, no ifs, ands, or butts. Doesn't matter how you team build or play, you lose the ability. Defog, meanwhile, is a great example of something that appears to have no counterplay or drawbacks, but it has quite a few. Specifically...
-Defog does no damage and has negligible secondary effects, so using it gives up momentum
-Shut down by Taunt
-Blocked by Substitute
-Easy punished with moves like Encore
-Clears your hazards/screens/etc as well
-Pairs poorly with Choice items
-Unusable with Assault Vest
-Lower PP than hazard setting moves, so hazards win the PP stall war
-Minor, but the evasion drop can be bounced back
-Minor, but Defogged opponents get an Evasion boost if it with Topsy-Turvy. This can be problematic if they've set-up and Topsy is your set-up checking move
Core Enforcer, and the other moves I brought up, lack pretty much all of those drawback/counter options. (Thank Arceus Sub at least blocks Anchor Shot) There's very little you can do to stop their secondary effects from landing and it costs little for them to be ran.
As for Edit 2, it's mostly on "removing planning/preparation" bit. Depending on interpretation of the last bit, being trapped may apply there as well.
Edit 3, I mentioned Shed Shell in my first post. Knock Off is common though, so its a bit unreliable.
AbuseroftheBroken said:Phasing/Pivot moves are EVERYWHERE, and there is not a cost of running it just to counter Trapping moves. They have various other applications, unlike Water Absorb, which only has 1 use, and is 100% useless outside of countering 1 specific attack type. Therefore, the cost of running Phasing/Pivot moves are minimal compared to wasting a WHOLE ability slot just to counter 1 single attack type. And, as motherhate has said, you would never switch in a mon into your opponent if it can't reliably 1v1 a mon, or can't take a move and then pivot out. Also, always carrying U-turn isn't a symptom of Trapping moves, but the Meta, like most OU teams running Landous-T in BW/ORAS, or most Ubers teams running P-Don in ORAS. Those moves, like the pokemon I used as examples, are just so good that they became ubiquitous, not because they are absolutely needed to counter Trapping moves. Same with running Giratina, one of the best walls in BH.
<snip>
That would be a cool team to see, when you are done can I challenge you to a match? I want to see firsthand what you consider as broken. :)
Well, look at it this way. If you don't run pivot/shuffle/Ghost-type on a good chunk of your team, what's the cost then if your opponent is using trapping? Running pivots everywhere might be "inexpensive", but not using them has the potential to be hideously costly with permanent trapping being so accessible and potentially spammable. Which, is the point I probably wasn't clear enough about on, sorry about that. But yeah, the way I see it, it's not currently "it's a good idea to run these low cost moves often", but rather "you'd better run these low cost moves on at least good chunk of your team or you could easily lose at team preview to certain teams."
As for that team, if I do it, it might take me a while. Building for realsies teams is usually a kinda slow process for me.
But it might turn out something like this. Or a number of meta-abuse teams I built for suspects and such, but I didn't RMT those and don't want to go farther off-topic posting them here.