So, I posted this here almost three years ago, and I don't think I ever got a response to it. But due to some discussion I was having earlier today, it came up again, and I checked and I don't believe anything has changed since I last posted it:
jas61292 said:Ok, so I think this qualifies as a bug, though I'm not actually sure. Either way, I brought it up on #showdown the other day and got no response, so I thought I'd post it here.
Basically, I believe there is an issue with egg move illegalities. Now, for the most part, such illegalities are a thing of the past, but that is not entirely true. The change this generation was that females can pass down egg moves as well as males, and as such, any illegalities caused by needing two different species as the male parent are now eliminated. But there are two other cases where egg moves can be illegal together, and nothing has changed regarding those this generation. As such they should be still illegal. However, as of now, such combinations are legal on PS. Now, of these two, one is purely theoretical, as no illegalities involving it exist. But the other is actually real and relevant.
The first (and actually important) one of these is the case of baby Pokemon. For many of these, it is possible to hatch both the baby, and its evolved form from eggs, depending on held items. Additionally, these evolved forms may have different egg move lists from the babies. In certain cases, there may be moves on each list that are not on the other. These moves should be illegal with one another. To give an example, Azurill has the moves Fake Tears and Sing as egg moves, but Marill does not. At the same time, Marill has Amnesia and Aqua Jet as egg moves, but Azurill does not. Thus, if you were to breed Aqua Jet onto a female Marill and then breed it with a male Clefairy that knows sing, you would have one of two results. If Marill is holding Sea Incense, then an Azurill would be born. It would know Sing, but not Aqua Jet, since that is not an egg move of Azurill. Alternatively, if it was not holding the incense, a Marill would be born, and it would know Aqua Jet, but not Sing, since that is not an egg move for Marill. In any case, the two moves will always be illegal with each other.
To put it more simply, the change in egg move passing has indeed made all egg moves of a given Pokemon legal together (baring the odd case below), but not all egg moves of a given family. Moves exclusive to one member of a family's egg list are illegal with moves exclusive to another members egg list. However, that is not currently the case on PS.
Now, while I know this is unimportant (at least at the present moment), as long as I am talking about it, I might as well mention the other, theoretical case: Volbeat. Volbeat is all male, but can be hatched via eggs from an Illumise. However, Volbeat and Illumise have different egg move lists. As such, if there existed two moves on Volbeat's egg list, but not on Illumise's that could not be passed down from a single male parent, then it would be impossible for them to be legal together, as the female Illumise could not hold onto the move for passing. Now, as it currently stands, the only egg moves Volbeat has that Illumise does not can all be passed down at once from Spinda. However, should there ever be a future case where Volbeat gains an egg move that Illumise does not have and Spinda cannot pass, illegalities would come into existence (technically, this is also the case with Nidoran-M, but since that is in the field egg group, it has Smeargle to eliminate all illegalities).
Anyways, this came up since we were talking in #cap about the potential for move illegalities now that egg move stuff changed, since they can have important competitive implications. While I'm not sure there is anything important being allowed now that should be illegal, since the idea came up, I just figured I'd drop it here.
Am I crazy or is this the kind of thing that should be marked illegal on validation, but is not?
Also, on a related note, while looking at other illegalities stuff, I think I found another kind of case where the validation check is failing: past gen exclusive moves with illegal egg combinations. Obviously nowadays a Pokemon can have any two of its egg moves together legally (except as noted above). However, this requires it to have been hatched in gen 6 or 7, meaning that if it possesses any move that could not have been acquired in gen 6 or 7, it must still apply old egg move illegalities. As an example, Charmander has both Belly Drum and Metal Claw as Egg moves, and so, of course they are legal together. However, it can also learn the move Headbutt, which was only available for it as a Tutor back in 4th gen. As such, any Charmander with Headbutt must have been hatched in a 3rd or 4th gen game. Now, back in 4th gen, it still had Belly Drum and Metal Claw as egg moves. However, Belly Drum is only available via Snorlax, while Metal Claw only via Aggron's family. As only male parents could pass moves at the time, the combination of Belly Drum and Metal Claw would be illegal. Therefore, it should be impossible to have Belly Drum, Metal Claw and Headbutt all on one set, since any set with Headbutt must follow the gen 4 egg move illegality rules.
However, a set with all three of these moves on Charmander is validated as legal on PS.
To put it in more general terms, Pokemon with moves that are only obtainable prior to 6th gen should be checked for egg move illegalities from the generation they must have been hatched in, and it does not seem like they are.
EDIT @ below: darn it, I thought that was one where this situation would come up. Had to go through a few other potential options before I found one I thought worked, but I guess not. And now that I think I found one that would be the case (Beat Up over Metal Claw) the validation is working correctly and calling it illegal.
That said, the part from my quote is still relevant, and more competitively pressing.