LordHelix said:I feel too many people are voting based on what they enjoy to use and are voting biasely.
Also i dont get why people are calling multiscale broken when its obviously only as good as it is because of the existence of brokenbounce but still insist on not having mbounce banned. I dont get why people are complaining abt mscale and dont want mbounce banned it doesnt make sense
How i see it (my opinion)
Mbounce banned: multiscale and sturdy becomes fine and exca isnt as necessary on every team best option imo
Fluffy unbanned: stall teams now invalidate phys teams even more with multiscale/regen/unaware/ph/fluffy core no pls keep it banned
Multiscale banned but mbounce isnt: sturdy becomes a better substitute and offense teams are still broke doesnt solve the prob
Sturdy banned but mbounce isnt: multiscale becomes a substitute, or sash spam again i see mbounce as the problem here
Regenerator: i dont care abt this ability, both offense and stall still function well without it, a bit overwhelming but wont be so much if multiscale/mbounce is banned no opinion
Mguard unbanned: literally no reason to bring it back only reason why anyone would want it back is because they enjoyed using it for biased reasons of making some dumb playstyles viable (solar power, gale wings spam, sturdy offense...etc) at the cost of breaking much more, invalidating so much and making shit styles like sash/sturdy spam an actual viable playstyle keep it out and banned for the rest of this oms existence
I hate people like yourself the most. Claiming other's decision being based on personal bias just because you yourself cannot grasp their arguments.
Even if we get rid of Magic Bounce, the problem is not solved. The ACTUAL issue here is Poison Heal. Here me out:
Teams with Poison heal basically have a doubled Leftovers + Marvel Scale giving them a huge defense on top of that. Even if rocks are up, they come in, Protect 1 turn and get their Multiscale back up. Wearing them down indirectly is not possible, because they are already poisoned and usually get more HP back, than they would actually lose due to Poison Heal (Sand, Hail and not even Leach Seed work on them). You HAVE to directly attack them, but their physical defense is too high (Marvel Scale) and they have Prankster Recover to get back to their Mulstiscale, while at the same time PP stall you with Pressure. Their pressure Mon is usually Aerodactyl which can easily deal with Kyurem, Excadrill and Pinsir, aka the most common Mold Breakers. Now you could set up on them, but they either have Unaware oder Prankster Haze for that, so set-up is not possible either. And when you want to hit them on the special side, have fun dealing with Chansey. The worst part is, that they come in almost with full HP thanks to Regenerator and protect 1 turn to get to full HP. Hazards don't do anything to them and as soon as they burn you, your physical attackers won't even do more than 12% to them (no joke, I run Adaptability + Tough Claws and while burned, my Mons cannot do more than 24% to their Marvel Scale + Multiscale, so they take one hit, and then protect to get to full HP). Banning Magic Bounce won't do anything to this strategy and beating them requires 3-4 dedicated Slots which means that you lose to almost anything else.
I honestly think that Poison Heal is the issue here and not Magic Bounce. But even then, Multiscale is more than an issue, than Magic Bounce will ever be. Right now, those Stall Teams don't even need Magic bounce, since none of the stuff it would bounce can actually touch them. Honestly, think about it: if you could use Magic Bounce, all of the above STILL matter. The only difference is, that you could now Taunt them but for that, they just swap their Magic Bounce Monster with one that has Oblivious. Literally the only thing they need to do and their strategy still works.
Again, Magic Boucne is not the issue. It probably is Poison Heal. And even then, Multiscale has proven to be an issue every time we discuss it. Sure, it is not the original root of these problems, but every time something strong shows up, Multiscale is involved. It is not broken by itself, but it becomes broken with a lot of other abilities, that in and off themselves aren't broken either. I mean, overtime we think, we solved it by banning something else, a new way is found to make Multiscale work again). I really think, that we should just ban it, since it WILL be a problem in the future, too.
Tl,dr;
- BAN Poison Heal (actual problem here)
- BAN Multiscale (secondary problem here, but also a secondary problem almost everywhere else, making it an actual issue)
- DO NOT BAN Magic Bounce (no issue at the moment, because the above exist)