I'd hoped to get this up before the ladder tour started, but votes are in for this round of nominations. There's been a couple posts since we started voting so some of the recent nominations aren't included here, those will be in the next round of votes. You might notice a different group of voters this time around, the important part being that
greilmercenary9 has joined the VR council as of this vote! As a player with plenty of ladder experience his thoughts and opinions will be very helpful in votes moving forward. You'll also notice that not everyone voted, that's because with 8 members there's more leeway on getting a good sample size with which to make changes, without having to wait on anyone who is unexpectedly busy, so VR updates will hopefully be delayed less. Ideally we still want everyone on VR council to vote but this hasn't always been happened before now so this technically isn't anything new.
As for the vote itself, there were a lot of proposed changes that were not all voted on formally. You'll notice there are two lists of changes at the bottom, the first following the list of votes are the usual changes. The second consists of changes that were not
formally nominated and thus not formally voted on, but were nonetheless changes I felt were worth looking at. Mega Gyarados was also left out of this vote because we didn't think the meta changed enough to vote it down right after voting it up last vote. Not opposed to revisiting it next vote if someone wants to make a case for it.
Mega Blaziken: S -> A+
Hide
cant say: disagree. mence/gyara/torrent gren rising sucks but this thing still destroys
chemcoop: S. Mega Blaze is falling off a bit thanks to increased Mence and Gren usage, but it's still a top-tier threat that can easily sweep with a well timed HP Ice or SD, or even if your team is just a bit too weakened.
DragonWhale: not as strong as before but it has a super versatile movepool that can either overcome natural switchins with tpunch and EQ, or turn the tables around with SD and BP. Requiring a mega is kind of a minus but it's still S for now (though close to falling off)
greilmercenary9: S. Mega Blaziken is probably the most inconsistent member of the S-tier, but its coverage, speed, and power, and flexibility mean it's still very hard to deal with. Baton Pass, SD, or tech coverage (HP Ice, EQ, T-Punch, Stone Edge), along with the viability of non-mega Blaze, also all help its versatility and thus its overall performance.
Psynergy: Nah, I don't think the meta has really shifted at all to really make Mega Blaziken any less effective than before, its usage may have dropped a bit since SM but I don't see this situation as any different than Mega Salamence. Its simplicity and power is really hard to match and despite how many good checks it has, they all need to be played carefully or else they risk getting overpowered anyway.
Solerme: Stay S
Greninja: A -> A+
Hide
cant say: A+ - agree
chemcoop: A+. HUGE threat right now. SubTorrent hits crazy hard with Waterium Z, and its increasing popularity only adds to the headache of dealing with Gren. It checks a lot of common meta threats right now, and the ability to run Sash Torrent, z-Torrent, z-Protean, Sash Protean, Scarf, Life Orb, and even SubToxic(???) makes this thing a nightmare to predict in team preview.
DragonWhale: Currently the only pokemon in the entire metagame that requires more than one pokemon to perfectly counter, thanks to its incredible versatility, speed, and effectiveness of each set. Only downside is it's not as strong once the set is identified. A+ for sure. Maybe even S.
greilmercenary9: A+. The rise of Torrent Greninja gives it the extra bit of unpredictability and potential power to make it even a more top tier threat. Bulky walls like P2 that generally didn't care about Protean Greninja much now have to be wary of eating a Torrent boosted Z-Hydro Cannon, and the Torrent set being utilized primarily a wallbreaker contrasts nicely with the more anti-offense oriented Protean sets.
Psynergy: I do think Greninja's usage is slightly overrated but that SubTorrent set is really as good as people say it is. Water is a great offensive type and dealing with that kind of nuke behind a Sub can be really hard for both offensive and defensive threats alike. I like it more than Protean, definitely worth moving up.
Cloyster: A- -> B+/B
Hide
cant say: tentatively agree, it's super strong but maybe B+ is more fitting
chemcoop: B+. Too much Stealth Rocks, Sandstorm, and fat resists like Aegi and Fini in the metagame right now for the traditional Sash Cloyster to work like it used to.
DragonWhale: A- is fine. It's a lot scarier than the B+s.
greilmercenary9: B+. This requires a Sash or some other support to set up with any reliability and can't beat several prominent bulky resists/walls without King's Rock. Further, some of the subtle changes of the USUM meta were unkind to it. While stuff like P2 and Fini were already beating this almost all of the time, the slight rise in Heatran usage as a premier Naga counter and the rise in popularity of bulky, low speed Mimikyu builds (which can OKHO with unboosted LSF if they underspeed a Shell Smash, meaning that something that was previously a nice target for setup if unboosted will now just wipe it out a fair amount of the time) mean that it's fighting uphill as much as ever before.
Psynergy: Honestly yeah Cloyster isn't as scary as it used to be, or even as common. I'm not too attached to where this drops but I'm pretty comfortable with it dropping to B+. Stealth Rock is way too common for something that relies so much on Focus Sash for safe setup but it's still a decisive win condition if it gets any chance.
Solerme: Yes, derank to B+
Dragonite: B+ -> B-
Hide
cant say: disagree. I think it's still B+, maybe B is fine though
chemcoop: B. I don't really want to drop this all the way to B- right now. Although the increasingly common Stealth Rocks and fairies like Mimikyu exist, don't underestimate the sheer power + bulk of Dragonite. If you didn't bring a scarf revenge killer, be prepared to take a beating from +1 z-Dragonite. Z-Fly and Z-Outrage both hit absurdly hard at +1, but Intimidate cycling can definitely help deal with Dragonite.
DragonWhale: B-. No reason to stack quad ice weaks nor use dnite over the other quad ice weaks. Dragons that are slower than mimikyu in general have no business being in B+, regardless of how good multiscale is.
greilmercenary9: B. It's powerful if it can set up, but like with Cloyster there are a lot of problems in the process. The increased usage of hazards in late SM bleeding into early USUM (not to mention Hippo being more popular than ever) means that Multiscale--the biggest selling point--is often not active even on its first turn out. Dragonite also has some 4MSS, especially on DD sets, and while both DD and CB have the ability to hit very hard with decent coverage, they struggle somewhat to keep up in an increasingly hostile meta, especially since many Mega Mence checks cover Dragonite fairly reliably. B- is probably too low, but a drop is fair.
Psynergy: Dragonite really dropped off hard, it's lucky to have Multiscale and Extreme Speed but that's about all it has to really stand out anymore with a mediocre Speed tier like that. Its Band set is still strong and Z-Fly is good but I feel like it's only barely holding on as a strong pick compared to Salamence or even Garchomp, can't remember the last time I've even considered this on a team.
Solerme: Yes, B-
Gengar: B+ -> C/UR
Hide
cant say: definitely not unranked but it is kinda shit. I would easily use sash shark before this but I think it's still useful. B-/C is fine.
chemcoop: C. Random Sash or Scarf Trick is always going to have the potential to ruin your day when you expect MegaGar. Overall, not that great of a Pokemon, but it can be a neat speed control lead with Icy Wind, threat stopper with Sash + Destiny Bond, and wallbreaker with Scarf + Trick.
DragonWhale: dont see it so cant give an opinion besides it probably not deserving a rank. It looks like a surprise kill thing at best but then mega gengar looks more useful in every other scenario
greilmercenary9: C. Sash Gengar is mostly a relic of XY and ORAS, but it can still be annoying with decent coverage and Destiny Bond. It's not consistent by any means, but it's not unviable either.
Psynergy: While nobody really uses regular Gengar, I think unranking it is a bit much since Sash Gengar will never not be an obnoxious set. I'm fine with C because it's definitely higher than it needs to be and it's certainly not a common set by any means, though B- might be appropriate as well.
Solerme: Yes, derank to B-. The Sash set is actually legit
Glalie: B+ -> B/B-
Hide
cant say: I feel like no, stay in B+
chemcoop: B. There are a number of neat and effective team support options for Glalie, but I think it's hard to justify putting a luck-dependent strategy above B, especially when there are counters to Glalie setup like Roar/Whirlwind, Perish Song, and even a fast Toxic.
DragonWhale: Its an infinite wincon that requires minimal support and is easy to get going with little luck in a lot of situations (requires more luck in others though). Stay in B+
greilmercenary9: B. Strategies that are primarily luck based are something of a double edged sword, and Glalie's very presence on a team tends to signal that it's coming 90% of the time. Once Glalie gets going it's a monster, but without significant team support it has trouble setting up against almost anything that isn't a wall, which means having to tailor a lot of the team to help it. Even then, Glalie's own ability can potentially doom it with bad buffs/debuffs, so I think B is about right.
Psynergy: I would agree that Glalie is a bit overrated in terms of actual viability, but not so much that I'm against it remaining in B+ either. I think it's more suited to B though, since B+ feels a little high for something that relies on luck and team support to actually be worth the team slot, but there's no denying how stupid Glalie can be if it gets only a little luck.
Solerme: Yes, derank to B
Kingdra: B -> B-
Hide
cant say: sure, B-
chemcoop: B- is fine. Hits like a truck with water STAB under rain, but it really doesn't do well against things that resist it or special walls like Chansey, SpD P2,or SpD Ferro.
DragonWhale: i sort of prefer this over pert in rain but seeing how pert is the go-to swimmer by a long shot i suppose im just missing something and kingdra isnt as good as i think. I guess drop it.
greilmercenary9: B-. Fast and strong in rain, but has trouble breaking both special walls (Chansey, SpDef P2, SpDef Ferro, etc.) and Fairy or Steel types that can take a water attack and generally fairly predictable.
Psynergy: I'm pretty torn on this one, Kingdra's lack of usage kinda speaks for itself but I think it's at least as good as Mega Swampert, if not better. Not being susceptible to Intimidate cycling and freeing a Mega slot is very good on a rain team, but I'll concede that its pitiful usage is a strong point against it. I'll defend it as a better rain sweeper but I don't think I can justify keeping it in B unfortunately.
Solerme: Yes, B-
Lapras: B -> C/UR
Hide
cant say: no, stay in B
chemcoop: This should be UR. Yeah, AV is fat and access to Sheer Cold/Perish Song and Water Absorb is neat, but idk why you would use Lapras over Gren or Fini. After using Dewgong and seeing how lackluster it is as a water type, I think it's safe to say Lapras isn't much better given its similar bulk/offense.
DragonWhale: superior to dewgong in almost every way and dewgong is a god to some people. Unfortunately both mons suck as the water type slot on a team is highly competitive with a bunch of better water types. It could be unranked tbh.
greilmercenary9: UR. Lapras just doesn't do any one thing very well, and is overshadowed by many superior water types that basically do everything it wants to do except better.
Psynergy: Another drop I think might be a little far but I'm not against dropping Lapras to C at least. I don't remember the last time I've actually seen this used and don't have much opinion on it, but I think it's still viable enough to remain ranked for now maybe.
Solerme: Yes, derank to C
Mega Lopunny: B -> B+
Hide
cant say: yes, B+
chemcoop: Lop should stay B. It has a great speed tier and ability, but it misses out on the sheer power of a lot of other megas. Can mind game opponents with Sub/Encore/Quick Attack, but it suffers from serious 4 MSS and gets walled by a decent number of mons.
DragonWhale: Good against many pokemon, bad against many pokemon, requires a mega slot, intimidate bait. Not really sure why it should go up.
greilmercenary9: B+. This is another mon that improved somewhat with the move to USUM. The increased usage of fast sweepers in the 120-130 base speed range helps it, since many of them are frail enough to fall to, or at least take a ton from, Fake Out + Return/HJK. It also has some options with moveslots to help against stuff like unboosted Mence, Lando-T (Ice Punch), Aegislash or Fake Out mind games (Sub), and so on. I can see it going to B+ thanks to its superb performance against hyper offense and even some bulkier offensive/balanced teams, but no higher since it is still fairly weak compared to most viable megas and can't really do much to several common walls like Hippowdon and Cresselia.
Psynergy: I think this is fine in B, I've said for awhile that this is a solid Mega but it's lack of power really makes me hesitant to want to move it above B. It does an excellent job against more offensive builds and has some nice tech options but if it isn't dealing with frail offensive stuff or hitting super-effective its power is kinda lacking.
Solerme: Yes, B+
Quagsire: B -> C
Hide
cant say: yes, C
chemcoop: B-. Has a niche as an electric sponge and Unaware user, but its mediocre defensive stats still lead to it getting 2HKO'd by strong physical attackers like Zard X and Mence. It can 1v1 standard Mimi pretty easily which is neat.
DragonWhale: its only niche is being an unaware mon with recovery and volt switch immunity for stall, when many people rather use toxapex to stop setup. Definitely drop from B.
greilmercenary9: C. It definitely has a niche with Unaware, but it struggles to have enough bulk to effectively tank stronger neutral hits. It also doesn't have the team support options or sheer walling power of other viable mons that basically no offensive presence whatsoever.
Psynergy: Same deal as Lapras, haven't seen this in a long while and it's a very niche pick for stall teams. It's undoubtedly viable but even there I wouldn't be using it often. Sounds like the definition of a C rank mon to me.
Solerme: Yes, derank to B-
Rhyperior: B -> C/UR
Hide
cant say: B-/C imo
chemcoop: C. This thing can be really tanky with AV and Solid Rock and it still hits pretty hard even without much investment. That being said, it gets dunked on in the current Fini/Gren/Gyara metagame so I don't think being able to wall a couple of meta threats in exchange for getting smashed by several super common threats is worth it.
DragonWhale: relies on bulk, hits hard, but has no recovery, and weak to water. so like heatran and tyranitar, only it always dies to water... in a water heavy format. the only advantage it has over the two is that it beats blaziken, but then everything else is worse. C is fine though imo.
greilmercenary9: C. The USUM meta is increasingly unkind to Rhyperior. Water attacks from Fini and Gren are everywhere, and plenty of sweepers that don't look good against it due to typing smash through with grass coverage. It's just hard to bring something like Rhyperior against most teams since it gets deleted by a lot of common stuff without doing much.
Psynergy: Again, can't remember the last time I've seen this so I'm not opposed to dropping this to C. It mostly shined during early meta and particularly during ORAS when Talonflame was relevant, but it still has a useful niche against Charizard X and Mega Salamence so I'm fine with it staying in C rank.
Solerme: Yes, B-/C
Thundurus-I: B -> B-/C
Hide
cant say: B- I guess
chemcoop: Don't really want to drop this all the way to C just yet, so I'm voting B-. SubToxic Prankster can still be really annoying for unprepared teams, and the occasional offensive variant can catch teams by surprise because of its good speed tier.
DragonWhale: should drop for sure. it's a good subtoxic user but otherwise its just ungood. I guess the thing it has over thund-t is that it outspeeds kartana and mega metagross, but it doesn't ohko them anyway. B-/C either works imo
greilmercenary9: B-. Back in ORAS this was one of the most unpredictable and versatile threats around. Now, by USUM, it has basically one effective set (SubToxic), which limits its effectiveness significantly. It's not out of the realm of possibility for it to go offensive for unpredictability, but other than surprise and a couple of speed benchmarks that it hits it really isn't worth running over Therian even without considering other NP sweepers like Naga.
Psynergy: I think I'd prefer this drop to B- rather than C, SubToxic is really obnoxious and it's got a useful Speed tier over Thundurus-T even if that's all it has over it. Wouldn't exactly consider it super dependent on teammates so much as it's just an inferior forme most of the time, but it's still a competent pick.
Solerme: Stay B
Mega Altaria: B- -> C
Hide
cant say: stay B- imo
chemcoop: C. Works well in theory, does very little in actual gameplay. While it can check both Zards with its typing + Cotton Guard, in practice this can be hard to pull off and there are honestly just better ways to deal with those threats that don't require a mega slot. Also...fairies are everywhere. Yay.
DragonWhale: never seen, cant comment much. It has the "slower than mimikyu dragon" thing and it's a mega so i guess put it in C if not unranked.
greilmercenary9: C. Chemcoop summed this up very effectively: better in theory than in practice. Cotton Guard can cause physical attackers problems, but with the abundance of Fairy and Steel-types in the Top 15 in usage and Altaria's general lack of power, it struggles to perform effectively.
Psynergy: Yeah sure. I've never seen a Mega Altaria, wouldn't even be against unranking it but it does offer a unique role as a Dragon/Fairy with Cotton Guard Roost stuff so C is fine for now. At least on par with the other things we're moving there.
Solerme: Stay B-
Mega Sableye: UR -> B-/C
Hide
cant say: eh it's kinda shit. maybe C
chemcoop: C. Works well with Shedinja stall, but that's really its only niche. Definitely gets taken advantage of in the current fairy dominated metagame.
DragonWhale: C. Not much to praise about this mon in this meta where so many things can 2hko it, but i suppose it's very good against most stall teams. same as above: UR/C
greilmercenary9: C. It is decent enough for certain types of stall teams, but like Quagsire it isn't effective enough as a wall to make up for its total lack of offensive presence. While it does at least boast Magic Bounce for team support, it costs a mega slot and doesn't even have Unaware like Quagsire does, so I think the same rank is appropriate.
Psynergy: Unsure where I'd rank this, I'm okay with Mega Sableye in B- but I think its role is better described as a C rank pick. It's great on stall but the Mega slot is already pretty competitive on stall teams as is and it's only really used on specific builds that wouldn't rather just run Mega Gengar.
Solerme: Yes, it needs a rank. Id say C, but we do need to divide the C rank
Mega Aerodactyl: UR -> C
Hide
cant say: actually think it should be higher, thinking B
chemcoop: C for Mega Aero as well. Being able to run Adamant and still outrun 130s, and Jolly to outrun +1 base 80s is also neat. That being said, its ability doesn't really work with its STAB moves and it doesn't hit THAT hard in our current power creeping metagame.
DragonWhale: this mon's ONLY niche is its speed, and it takes a mega slot. UR/C
greilmercenary9: Works on some stall as a specialized eliminator of threats like Mega Gengar, Mega Charizard X, and so on, but its offensive firepower falls short compared to most other megas.
Psynergy: Same deal as Mega Sableye except I'm more convinced this is C rank, its relatively weak despite Tough Claws but its insane Speed is actually relevant this gen. Suffers even more than Mega Sableye from the competition in the Mega slot though.
Solerme: Yes, as written above, should be C+
Ditto: UR -> C
Hide
cant say: sure, C
chemcoop: This should be C. Interesting way to revenge sweep with a scarf set, and sash is viable although I think it's definitely inferior to scarf. Niche mon, but does have some usage/merit.
DragonWhale: Not sure if its any good when mimikyu discouraged a vast majority of setup sweepers besides itself already and transforming to mimikyu doesnt give you disguise. Other setup sweepers simply wont set up when there's a ditto around, making ditto even harder to use. Same as above, UR/C.
greilmercenary9: Ditto seems like the definition of niche. It's great against boosters and generally mediocre or worse against most everything else. Seeing it in team preview discourages boosters from actually boosting through. Scarf sets can frustrate hyper offense, and Sash is possible but sketchy in a meta where residual damage has been becoming more prevalent for the last several months. But as a wildcard mon it's inconsistent by nature.
Psynergy: Honestly not sure how we went this long without ranking it, Ditto is always niche tier worthy. Don't think this needs much explanation, Sash and Scarf Ditto are both solid.
Voted Changes:
Greninja moves from A to A+
Cloyster moves from A- to B+
Dragonite moves from B+ to B
Gengar moves from B+ to C
Glalie moves from B+ to B
Kingdra moves from B to B-
Lapras moves from B to UR
Quagsire moves from B to C
Rhyperior moves from B to C
Thundurus-I moves from B to B-
Mega Altaria moves from B- to C
Mega Sableye moves from UR to C
Mega Aerodactyl moves from UR to C
Ditto moves from UR to C
As a reminder, the changes below were not formally voted on because they weren't given formal nomination, but nobody on the VR council expressed disagreement with these proposed changes. Anything else that's missing from the above nominations or the following list was not moved because one or more council members disagreed with it. If you want to bring them up again for a proper nomination please feel free to, we'll still give them a proper vote in the next round.
Other Changes:
Blaziken moves from A+ to A
Latios moves from B+ to B
Mega Gardevoir moves from B- to C
Latias moves from B- to B
Pyukumuku moves from B- to C
Mandibuzz moves from C to UR
Raikou moves from C to UR
Sylveon moves from C to UR