aw man I have to delurk now
I don't think Substitute is such an outlier on the risk/reward curve. There are ways to pressure Sub teams and increase the risk of bringing in (or leaving in) a Sub mon, even when it's part of a SubWish core:
- Hazard-stacking teams force a Sub user to choose between eating chip damage and/or poison on their Sub/Wish mon and Defogging
- Trick mons like Noivern can disable something that's left in without a Sub
- VoltTurn chip damage can break a Sub and force physical Sub users out, especially when paired with WoW users like Cofagrigus or strong attackers
- Sub-bypassing moves like Noivern's Boomburst, Primarina's Sparkling Aria, Kommo-o's Clanging Scales, Specs TG Xurk's Round, and Gardevoir-Mega's Hyper Voice can force Sub users out
- Chansey switchins can be predicted and answered with Knock Off or a Pursuit trapper like Weavile or Bisharp
- Z-moves can bypass a weakened Chansey's Protect
Importantly, most of these tools would still be useful after a Sub ban. Hazard stacking, Trick, VoltTurn, Knock Off utility, Pursuit trappers, and Z-moves have valid utility other than dealing with Sub. Even most of the bypassing moves would still be useful - the only exceptions are Sparkling Aria (probably outclassed by Scald) and Round.
And is Sub itself the problem, or is it the SubWish core? Since a mon that's going to take 25% on switchin needs recovery to viably come in >4 times, which isn't an unreasonable demand in a bulky meta like TM, the number of viable Sub users drops off dramatically outside a SubWish core - of the mons
Imperator Romanum listed, the only ones with reliable recovery (i.e. 50%) are Buzzwole and Scizor, and I hardly ever see Scizor. (There's also Gliscor on stall, and I think I've seen Sub Hydreigon and Vikavolt once or twice.) So Sub sets on mons like Alolawak, Tyranitar, and (to a lesser extent because immune to Toxic Spikes) Heatran will be
heavily pressured outside SubWish.
Of the components of the core, Sub has a wider range of viability than Wish. I'll usually want Sub no matter what I'm building - to give a physical attacker protection from WoW TMs, give a utility mon a free turn (e.g. U-Turn/Defog/Roost Scizor), or just have an answer to TMs like Leech Seed - but running Wish strongly encourages stall or at least semi-stall, so if the core turns out to be overcentralizing and/or broken, I'd rather see Wish go than Sub.
Sure, most teams are going to have a Sub user (whereas offensive teams don't need Wish) but just because something is central to a meta doesn't mean it's
overcentralizing - cf. Pdon in Ubers, Lando-T in OU, Imposter Chansey and Sturdinja in BH, Tomohawk in Gen 6 CAP, or even WoW here in TM, which strongly discourages the use of physical attackers that aren't either Fire-type or running TM Sub. These are all things that you'll usually want to run - Pdon is at >70% usage in Ubers 1760 - and that you'll want to prepare for, but (unlike e.g. Hoopa-U) you have a decent range of options in preparing for them.
tl;dr: voting
DO NOT BAN
team
Mega Roomba (Magearna) @ Assault Vest
Ability: trickroom
EVs: 252 HP / 4 SpA / 252 SpD
Sassy Nature
IVs: 0 Atk / 0 Spe
- Aura Sphere
- Fleur Cannon
- Ice Beam
- Volt Switch
Primarinyaa (Primarina) @ Choice Specs
Ability: reflect
EVs: 252 HP / 4 Def / 252 SpA
Quiet Nature
IVs: 0 Atk / 0 Spe
- Sparkling Aria
- Moonblast
- Ice Beam
- Hidden Power [Fire]
Lt. Xurge (Xurkitree) @ Choice Specs
Ability: Tail Glow
EVs: 252 HP / 252 SpA / 4 SpD
Quiet Nature
IVs: 0 Atk / 0 Spe
- Volt Switch
- Thunderbolt
- Energy Ball
- Round
Richard Nixon (Marowak-Alola) @ Thick Club
Ability: swordsdance
EVs: 248 HP / 252 Atk / 8 SpD
Brave Nature
IVs: 0 Spe
- Flare Blitz
- Shadow Bone
- Knock Off
- Bonemerang
Spikesbane (Zapdos) @ Leftovers
Ability: defog
EVs: 252 HP / 252 Def / 4 SpA
Bold Nature
IVs: 0 Atk / 0 Spe
- Volt Switch
- Hidden Power [Ice]
- Toxic
- Roost
Punch Buggy (Buzzwole) @ Fightinium Z
Ability: substitute
EVs: 252 HP / 252 Atk / 4 SpD
Brave Nature
IVs: 0 Spe
- Drain Punch
- Earthquake
- Ice Punch
- Roost
description
AV Mag sets TR and pivots out. Aside from late-game or clicking Ice Beam on a predicted Ground switch-in, that's all it does. If Mag gets KOed, you probably lose - there's no backup TR setter. But I haven't needed one.
Reflect Primarina might look like it's entirely an anti-Sub teamslot, but it's also there to check SD Goli, surprise Ferro switchins with HP Fire, and set a screen for the rest of the team, which aside from Buzzwole doesn't have much physical bulk. Primarina hardly ever clicks Ice Beam, so could run Scald (for burns) or Hydro Pump (for OHKOing 252/252+ Heatran, although with the damage calculator's specially defensive set Hydro Pump only provides an ~11% higher chance of netting the OHKO than Sparkling Aria) instead - I'm not really losing a moveslot to Sub here. Could maybe be replaced with WoW Jellicent or Trick Noivern.
Specs TG Xurk breaks things. It 2HKOs Eviolite Chansey. I am losing a moveslot to Sub here, but Xurk's movepool makes the Kardashians look deep so who cares.
SD Alolawak also breaks things. Not much to say here. Bonemerang loses 10% accuracy vs. Earthquake to break subs and sashes, although does anything run a sash?
Zapdos is a defogger. It isn't very good and could stand to be replaced, but I'm not sure what with. Usually gets sacced after the opponent's hazard setter is down. I had Heat Wave on it instead of HP Ice for a while.
Buzzwole is a slow, hard-hitting Sub user. I haven't tried Focus Punch on it, but that could work too, especially for more damage on the Z-move against the Protect of a low-HP Chansey. This slot was Conkeldurr for a long time, but it didn't have enough bulk and Drain Punch as sole recovery wasn't reliable enough.
replays