• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

General News Discussion Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
americans live in a country with a far-right governance which incites violence and animus toward black and brown people on the daily. we live in a country whose gun rights are central to male identity. historically, guns were one of the few class-based indicators which set apart poor white men from the enslaved. this fetishization of the gun has since developed into a iron-clad connection which makes guns a symbol of power and freedom. we live in a country which fails to reckon with its history of racism and has whole hosts of the population espousing we are in a colorblind society, and that slavery isn't an issue for today. even in leftist spaces, there are equivocations of needing to be post-racial, further shirking responsibility. we live in a country founded on dual genocides, yet cages those who we uprooted from other countries attempting to escape poverty. we live in a country with the most atomizing form of capitalism ever, disconnecting the population from community, and siphoning entitled white men into toxic spaces which allow them to demonize the very brown and black people central to the white supremacist logics this country was founded upon and supports today. no, i don't believe these shooters are insane. it is shameful to any mentally ill person to insist they are. white supremacy is not, and never will be, a mental illness.
 
I don't think it's a very good idea to categorize shooters as mentally ill regardless of whether it's true or not because of how people at large view propositions. For example, if x -> y is true then people will also think that the inverse y -> x is true, for whatever reason. While that is literally illogical, that does not change that that is how views get developed and propagated.

This makes labeling things a mental health issue very dangerous. Whereas the proposition is "bad behavior -> mental health issue", which is hard to take offense with, it leads to people believing the inverse of "mental health issue -> bad behavior". Which, despite being a literally illogical conclusion as previously mentioned, happens. Labels matter more than what the label actually means, for better or for worse, so they require a great degree of care in their usage. So I'm really not onboard with saying that anyone who commits a mass shooting absolutely has a mental health issue, for more reasons than just I'm not a psychiatrist.
 
business insider said it, not me

https://www.businessinsider.com/deadliest-mass-shootings-almost-all-have-domestic-violence-connection-2017-11

"Many of the shooters behind the deadliest mass shootings in modern America (listed below) committed violence against women, threatened violence against women, or disparaged women.

According to the nonprofit Everytown for Gun Safety, the majority of mass shootings in the US are in some way related to domestic or family violence. A 2018 Everytown report indicates that in at least 54% of mass shootings, the perpetrator also shot a current or former intimate partner or family member.

The US government long barred scientists at the CDC from researching gun violence (in 2018, Congress said the US government could fund research into gun violence, as long as it did not promote gun control). But a now decades-long trend is clear: Violent, armed perpetrators of domestic violence are a deadly force in America.
"
 
RODAN said:
so are you saying that the people doing the shootings are completely sane of mind?

it's really easy to say in hindsight "oh murdering people means your brain is messed up" because we don't like to grapple with the idea that the ability or willingness to murder people isn't as rare as we'd like to pretend.

Also I think the shooters are radicalized less because of loneliness and depression and more because of the insane toxic culture surrounding the proper way to be masculine. Loneliness and depression arguably are side effects of embodying what it means to be masculine in our world.
 
dice said:
words


RODAN said:
so are you saying that the people doing the shootings are completely sane of mind? mental health is an extremely broad spectrum and that combined with the inherent culture of violence and the glorifying and attention shooters get by MSM would explain why it happens in america most prominently

I don't think all shooters are of sound mind and body, but when you have people like the Christchurch guy, the El Paso guy and others who deliver a manifesto, set up live streams and distribute these to a wider audience (8chan or whatever), it is very clear they are aware what they are doing and have followed an ideology to an extreme extent. Perfectly sane people can do this, when they have been alienated or pushed to one side, just had it reinforced via echo chambers, or deep down just hate. Hate is not a mental illness. Once they have been radicalised to think certain groups of people are sub-human, it's not really a far leap to have no remorse about killing. People wouldn't say Ted Bundy was insane or the Unabomber. They know what they are doing. Ted Kazynski (spelling probably wrong) was fully aware of his actions. Mental illness seems like a copout because it's *ONLY* used to describe white shooters. When it's gang violence among minorities, it's a social issue. When it's a terror attack inspired by Islamic extremism, it's terrorism and an 'AttAcK oN oUr fReeDoMs'. If you're going to call it mental illness, call it a mental illness for everyone, but then where do the goalposts stop? You can just kick it down the line to medicate whole swathes of the population into sedation (bit extreme endpoint, I'll admit). These people couldn't kill all these people without guns (the recent shootings, not the historical references cited).

All that being said, and I kind of went off on a tangent, I do agree with your points about the culture of violence and MSM coverage on shooters being largely responsible. I'd also like to indict Fox News in particular Tucker Carlson and Sean Hannity who are the president's lapdogs for all intents and purposes and echo his hateful rhetoric, which validates the views of these scumbag white nationalists.
 
Last edited:
No, white supremacy does not cause people to become violent. The beliefs about inflicting harm on people caused violence. Vast majority of white supremacists are peaceful, and this is a fact whether you like them or not.

Likewise, it is hypocritical to attribute mass shooting phenomenon to white nationalist incels or whatever hilariously reductive generalizations you guys itt are parroting, when mass shootings are disproportionately done by people of color. I'm just saying that mass shooting is a consequence of violent people, not a specific ideology. It will always happen regardless the access to guns. Outlawing guns as a respond to rare occurrences of violent people misusing them only hurts all of our civil rights and empowers government's control over us.
 
orch said:
No, white supremacy does not cause people to become violent. The beliefs about inflicting harm on people caused violence. Vast majority of white supremacists are peaceful, and this is a fact whether you like them or not.
white supremacy as an ideology is inherently violent. is there a way for a white supremacist to achieve their goals without violence? just because a white supremacist doesnt pose any threat to your (im just guessing ur white tbh) existence doesnt mean theyre by any means peaceful. laughable idea.

Likewise, it is hypocritical to attribute mass shooting phenomenon to white nationalist incels or whatever hilariously reductive generalizations you guys itt are parroting, when mass shootings are disproportionately done by people of color.
[CITATION NEEDED]

seriously? the only mass shooter i remember in the last few years who could reasonably be called a poc was omar mateen.
I'm just saying that mass shooting is a consequence of violent people, not a specific ideology. It will always happen regardless the access to guns. Outlawing guns as a respond to rare occurrences of violent people misusing them only hurts all of our civil rights and empowers government's control over us.
well i mean i have my own issues with gun control but this seems uniquely american to have frequent mass shootings. other developed countries arent seeing this type of mass violence but i dont think anyone would clam violent people dont exist in these places. u can keep up this weird 'well its just a reoccuring pattern of black swans' act but nobodies buying it and u might have to look at societal problems beyond the scope of individual action
 
orch said:
No, white supremacy does not cause people to become violent. The beliefs about inflicting harm on people caused violence. Vast majority of white supremacists are peaceful, and this is a fact whether you like them or not.
nothing quite so peaceful as an ideology that has at its core the belief that there is a "white race" which is superior to other "races" and therefore gets to discriminate, oppress, deport, and ultimately kill non-white people at will. there is no such thing as nonviolent white supremacy. dehumanization of people of color and other minorities deemed "inferior" by whichever strand of white supremacist thought we're talking about will inevitably lead some believers to take up arms against those minorities. of course white supremacy isn't the sole cause of such shootings, most people are unwilling to risk their own lives just to kill a bunch of people they don't like or make some political statement. i would assume the majority of these shooters are already deeply dissatisfied with their own lives, but dissatisfaction with your life or mental illness or what have you does not have to manifest itself in this way. whenever it does, it more often than not turns out the shooter in question just so happens to hold racist beliefs. if you think there couldn't possibly be a connection between white supremacist thought and people shooting up mosques, synagogues, black churches, or random public places after publishing their racist political manifesto, then you are naive at best and deliberately trying to whitewash (lol) white supremacist thought at worst. this is all of course without going into the fact that even if most white supremacists aren't mass shooters, their beliefs have always, always, always resulted in extreme systemic violence wherever they obtained significant levels of political power (i would hope you paid enough attention in history class to know the kind of violence i'm talking about here)

Likewise, it is hypocritical to attribute mass shooting phenomenon to white nationalist incels or whatever hilariously reductive generalizations you guys itt are parroting, when mass shootings are disproportionately done by people of color. I'm just saying that mass shooting is a consequence of violent people, not a specific ideology. It will always happen regardless the access to guns. Outlawing guns as a respond to rare occurrences of violent people misusing them only hurts all of our civil rights and empowers government's control over us.
"mass shooting" is an extremely broad category, most mass shootings only have a few casualties and can be the result of anything ranging from gang violence to armed robberies gone wrong to escalated familial disputes and anything inbetween. if you wonder why many people are calling for white supremacist mass shootings to be labeled terrorism, it's because they are both more lethal than and serve entirely different purposes from more typical, "everyday" mass shootings. again, when somebody explicitly targets a particular racial or religious minority in their attack, or when they start a shooting spree in a random public place after publishing a white supremacist political manifesto, surely they have some goal beyond simply "wanting to kill people" or whatever? what exactly is your explanation for such grotesque violence, and how do you think it should be combated? because all i get from your post is that some people are just inclined to commit acts of violence, and that some groups of people (poc) juuust so happen to be more inclined to commit acts of violence than others, which almost sounds like the root of a racist argument. now i wouldn't dare to suggest you are actually racist, of course, but i wouldn't blame anyone for coming to that conclusion.
 
Robert Alfons said:
"mass shooting" is an extremely broad category, most mass shootings only have a few casualties and can be the result of anything ranging from gang violence to armed robberies gone wrong to escalated familial disputes and anything inbetween.

Asek said:
[CITATION NEEDED]

seriously? the only mass shooter i remember in the last few years who could reasonably be called a poc was omar mateen.
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/mass-shootings-in-2018/ this page breaks it down a little.

"Of the 59 named individuals suspected of involvement in mass shootings, two-thirds (40) were black men. Furthermore, many of the cases in which a suspect hadn’t yet been identified or charged involved gang-related shootings taking place in predominantly black communities, with exclusively black victims."

"Mass shootings" has become a poisoned term imo. Media needs to stop saying "we have had more mass shootings than days in 2019" because mass shootings are heavily different from each other. The reasons behind gang violence and public terrorism-suicide are extremely different. Likewise anybody who says "gotcha, actually a majority of mass shooters were people of color, it's not the fault of white supremacy" have an agenda on their hands.
 
Steel With It said:
... Said the white supremacist with a real photograph of a knife jammed through somebody's hand for an avatar.

Like, you can't even choose an avatar for your fucking Smogon account without laughing at a guy who I'm sure you imagine to be a liberal (given the whole "Those damn liberal Millennials and their avocado toast!!!" meme) being stabbed. If that's "Peaceful," then what the hell do you consider "Violent"? ... Oh, right. Mockery, milkshakes and being banned from Twitter. Of course.
i'm not a white supremacist. i'm a person with identity which most people would consider as minority/oppressed/marginalized. you're right, i find my avatar to be funny. no, it's not because i think that person is a liberal. i have no idea what the hell that person's political affiliation is, nor it's even part of the humor. i love my avocado toasts too.

i did not say that this white supremacist wasn't being violent. el paso shooter was a violent white supremacist. 100% agreed. if white supremacy is indeed inherently violent, then we should be seeing hell a lot more terrorism considering that myzozoa made a bold claim that white supremacy is literally everywhere in american society. why aren't there more mass killings by the white supremacists who are apparently omnipresent and trying to sell you the white supremacy stuff on white supremacist channels on white supremacist made television?

GatoDelFuego said:
The reasons behind gang violence and public terrorism-suicide are extremely different. Likewise anybody who says "gotcha, actually a majority of mass shooters were people of color, it's not the fault of white supremacy" have an agenda on their hands.
my agenda is to clear the ridiculous misconception that white supremacy is inherently violent. if white supremacy is inherently violent, then all supremacist beliefs are inherently violent if you follow robert alfons' logic in his post. are you prepared to denounce black panthers as inherently violent? i am not, and i consider supremacists as a weird and interesting individuals with unique beliefs. anyone can be violent.

violent people have their own reasons for being violent. i don't claim to know these reasons, as i am not a violent person. it was interesting to read through an ex-girlfriend's experiences with dayton shooter. https://medium.com/@_adeliajohnson_/my-ex-boyfriend-was-the-dayton-shooter-2b7f2d792b68
 
how can you genuinely, unironically support the claim that "the vast majority of white supremacists are peaceful" like come the fuck on dude, really? You don't think there is any overlap between the circles of "my skin is white therefore im superior to you" and violent rhetoric and actions?

It's shit like that that has this forum foaming at the mouth at any moderately right wing views, because the only exposure people get to them happen to be "black people are actually more violent, white supremacists are peaceful" or are ashaebis maskoff "immigrants are ruining the country"
 
I mean, I could definitely see it being true that most white supremacists just sit around on the computer all day and take no direct action, as is the case with many online "activists". In that sense, they're technically nonviolent, but they're still promoting and enabling the violent acts of their peers (i.e. advocating for genocide, enviously tracking "kill counts" on 8ch, and the likes).
 
tcr said:
how can you genuinely, unironically support the claim that "the vast majority of white supremacists are peaceful" like come the fuck on dude, really? You don't think there is any overlap between the circles of "my skin is white therefore im superior to you" and violent rhetoric and actions?

It's shit like that that has this forum foaming at the mouth at any moderately right wing views, because the only exposure people get to them happen to be "black people are actually more violent, white supremacists are peaceful" or are ashaebis maskoff "immigrants are ruining the country"
i am not saying that black people are more or less violent than white supremacists. i don't believe in race, so attaching racial value to shooters is absurd in the first place. in fact, it's you who is being racist by attaching value to the race of shooters. all i'm saying that violent people are violent, and white supremacy is not inherently violent.
 
Orch since you believe that white supremacy is peaceful, do you also believe that white supremacy is an acceptable ideology to hold? Would you go so far as to defend the views of white supremacy that someone had?
 
tcr said:
Orch since you believe that white supremacy is peaceful, do you also believe that white supremacy is an acceptable ideology to hold? Would you go so far as to defend the views of white supremacy that someone had?
I do think that it is okay for someone to have white supremacist ideology. I will only defend as far for the ability for them to defend themselves.
 
orch said:
all i'm saying that violent people are violent, and white supremacy is not inherently violent.
With that kind of statement, do you consider ANYTHING "inherently violent"...? Fine if you do but it's not really relevant to keep saying it. Terrorists around America are killing people in the name of white supremacy, repeatedly. It's not a one-off. We've got a problem on our hands
 
GatoDelFuego said:
With that kind of statement, do you consider ANYTHING "inherently violent"...? Fine if you do but it's not really relevant to keep saying it. Terrorists around America are killing people in the name of white supremacy, repeatedly. It's not a one-off. We've got a problem on our hands
No, I don't think that any ideologies are inherently violent unless they directly incorporate violent beliefs. If you believe that ideologies can be inherently violent, then it is clear that Radical Islamism is the number one dangerous ideology going by worldwide terrorism. Yes, it is true that White supremacist terrorism is the most common terrorism in America, however if you want to compare ideologies, you have to compare them all. I think that that Radical Islamism isn't inherently violent, just as White supremacism isn't inherently violent.

I don't think that it's possible to solve this "problem" without genetically modifying people to be more domesticated.
 
haha check it out guys im an epic centrist, i think it's ok to be a white supremacist BUT i also think it's ok to be a black nationalist (not remotely comparable to white supremacy btw but ok) so u cant say im racist lol :p

orch listen bro idk if ur somewhat challenged when it comes to your ability to understand politics or just a racist concern troll but the simple fact of the matter is that white supremacist ideology is not some weird fringe idea that u can look at from a distance as though ur observing a foreign animal species. it's a very real very dangerous mindset that has already proven itself to be inherently violent in, say, nazi germany, apartheid south africa, oh and all throughout the history of the USA as well, who woulda thunk. like, can u really look at people at a trump rally chanting that a political opponent ought to be deported because she wasn't born in america, can u really see a guy spelling the word "trump" out in guns before publishing a white supremacist manifesto and shooting a walmart up, can u really see the amount of racist hate crimes go up in recent years without considering that perhaps white supremacy is a very real threat that is actively making ethnic minorities less safe? i don't give a shit how "not racist" you personally think you are, the fact of the matter is that abiding by white supremacy is not much different from aiding it. i should like to point out that the majority of the german people in the third reich never voted for hitler and even less people were actively committing violence against jews, gypsies, gay people, the disabled et cetera. however, not enough people stood up against that regime, so it had to be ended forcefully in a world war that cost many millions of people their lives. there is only one response to racist ideologies, and that is "fuck you." any words that attempt to even remotely redeem this shit just show a blatant disregard for the lives of those people that are put in jeopardy because of these very ideologies.

do not bother responding to this post unless you want to apologize for being wrong beyond the point of ridicule. i would also like to encourage everyone else to not engage with orch beyond this point since you'll most likely just be wasting your energy on a troll.
 
Why is dude playing semantics with the word “inherent”? This is such a waste of time. By any ethical consideration, there is nothing morally virtuous or appropriate about holding views that a white supremacist holds, and going around sharing that view makes you a person that causes harm. Violence is a type of harm, and ultimately the goal in most philosophical undertakings is to try and avoid causing harm. Why you defending people’s right to cause harm? Don’t be a white supremacist and don’t go around defending their right to hold such views if you care to appeal to any common morality.
 
orch said:
If you believe that ideologies can be inherently violent, then it is clear that Radical Islamism is the number one dangerous ideology going by worldwide terrorism. Yes, it is true that White supremacist terrorism is the most common terrorism in America
And we are in america, discussing American events.
 
https://edition.cnn.com/2019/08/07/us/racial-slurs-swastika-ohio-house-explosion/index.html

Racial slurs and a swastika were found spray-painted on a garage at the scene of a house explosion in Ohio, officials said Wednesday.
Wayne County Sheriff's deputies and fire officials responded to a 911 call around 12:40 a.m. to find the home in Sterling, south of Cleveland, engulfed in flames, Sheriff Travis Hutchinson told reporters. The side of the home was blown out, the sheriff said.
Authorities believe the fire was intentionally set, he said. The incident is being investigated as a possible hate crime, the sheriff said.
"There were some racial slurs and a swastika that was spray painted on (the garage)," Hutchinson said. "We're not going to tolerate that type of activity and behavior here."
An interracial couple lives in the home, according to CNN affiliate WOIO. But the house was unoccupied at the time of the explosion, the sheriff said.

In other news Nazis bomb the house of an interracial couple and scribble a swastika and slurs on the garage door.

Obviously these fucks are gonna be emboldened if every relevant authority figure brushes their violence under the rug with both-sidisms at the very best, or just tacitly endorses them.
 
orch said:
No, I don't think that any ideologies are inherently violent unless they directly incorporate violent beliefs. If you believe that ideologies can be inherently violent, then it is clear that Radical Islamism is the number one dangerous ideology going by worldwide terrorism. Yes, it is true that White supremacist terrorism is the most common terrorism in America, however if you want to compare ideologies, you have to compare them all. I think that that Radical Islamism isn't inherently violent, just as White supremacism isn't inherently violent.

I don't think that it's possible to solve this "problem" without genetically modifying people to be more domesticated.
Well, a key part of white supremacist ideology is the creation of a white ethnostate, right? How do you create a white ethnostate? You ask people to leave politely? I don’t think most black and brown people, especially those who were born here or their family has been here for generations but a lot of immigrants too, are going to want to leave. So you do ethnic cleansing / a genocide. Now, if genocide is a key part of an ideology, I think that makes it inherently violent.

Like, if my ideology is “kill all white people”, is that not inherently violent? Because the aim of the ideology is to perform violence against groups I don’t like. That sounds inherently violent to me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top