Will be my last post on Serv.
1) Servine Checks
I made a post back in April discussing a lot of Servine checks and explaining why they aren't Serv checks or are unreliable, it also covers the main aspects of serv itself which makes it so restrictive. Would recommend reading it
here tbh. Just wanted to re-clarify this because some people were not here in April, and because people are still calling certain Pokemon such as Pawniard, Metang, Zubat, Gloom etc 'checks'
2) Serv/Grimes, Serv/Pawn, Serv/Metang (or other good Pursuit trappers which force Rose out)
Ktut has already brought this point up. It's a great point; there are many Pokemon capable of either trapping or heavily pressuring common defensive Serv checks like Roselia, Vullaby etc. I do have both usage stats and replays showcasing this to back my point. It's very easy to trap Rose by forcing it to Spike/Synth then Pursuiting it. Roselia has garbage physdef and, on top of that, Serv is the best Rose Knocker in the tier. This mon is not hard to trap and wear down.
| 1 | Servine / Grimer-Alola | 68 | 16.67% | 60.29% |
|45 | Metang / Servine | 26 | 6.37% | 61.54% |
|48 | Pawniard / Servine | 25 | 6.13% | 44.00% |
To prove that nearly all these are separate usages, that no one is using all three on the same team, here's the usage stat for all three on the same team. 75% of Serv teams have a viable and solid Pursuit trapper as support for Roselia, Haunter etc, and as a means of chipping down other offensive Fire and Bird type checks.
| 764 | Metang / Pawniard / Servine | 2 | 0.49% | 50.00% |
30% of all teams in tour play have Serv plus one Rose trapper which forces it out. Admittedly, not every Metang carries Pursuit, but it highlights how difficult it is to rely on Rose as a defensive Serv check. 75% of teams with Serv have a guaranteed or potential Pursuit trapper for Rose, and this makes it very easy for Serv teams to trap rose for Serv to break through. The ServGrimes core is the most common two mon core in the tier, for good reason. It's insane how much support these two provide for each other, especially Grimes for Serv.
3) The offensive Bird and Fire Types Argument
All offensive bird and fire type teams still primarily rely on Serv and Roselia as defensive Serv checks, the fact that offensive birds and fire are checks is valid, but nearly all these teams still rely on Serv and Rose as the defensive backbone for their team, and that's primarily for other Serv. Yes, Serv and Rose check other Pokemon. However, every team needs a defensive Glare/Knock/Storm switchin on top of offensive checks and that's why Rose and Serv have 80% total usage in the tier and why every other Grass-type is dogshit. These birds and fires are also really easy to chip down during a game. They all take either 25% from rocks and/or have recoil-based STAB attacks. The odds of them surviving long enough to check serv late game is low and some of my replays showcase this. You also need good hazard removal for these teams and who pairs well with offensive bird and fire types as a good Stealth Rock fogger? Servine.
Total Rufflet Tour Usage in Serv/Rose meta: | 27 | Rufflet | 22 | 5.39% | 45.45% |
How many times was Rufflet paired with Rose/Serv
| 102 | Rufflet / Servine | 13 | 3.19% | 53.85% |
| 218 | Rufflet / Roselia | 6 | 1.47% | 33.33% |
19/22 Uses featured Serv or Rose as a partner.
Rufflet's the easiest one to quantify because its a fairly niche breaker. Pokemon such as Staravia, Monferno, Magmar and Combusken have different roles for teams and the first two are pretty splashable. I'll give you the usage stats though, to prove that even teams with heavy offensive counterplay for Serv still rely on the same defensive Serv or Rose as their defensive checks because you can't get away with just offensive checks.
Total Monferno Tour Usage in Serv/Rose meta: | 2 | Monferno | 149 | 36.52% | 50.34% |
| 3 | Monferno / Servine | 58 | 14.22% | 53.45% |
| 5 | Roselia / Monferno | 55 | 13.48% | 52.73% |
Not as high as Rufflet but about 65% of Monfs are paired with a serv or a rose.
Total Combusken Tour Usage in Serv/Rose meta: | 20 | Combusken | 33 | 8.09% | 45.45% |
| 102 | Servine / Combusken | 13 | 3.19% | 61.54% |
| 146 | Roselia / Combusken | 9 | 2.21% | 22.22% |
21/33, again about 64%
Total Staravia Tour Usage in Serv/Rose meta: | 10 | Staravia | 82 | 20.10% | 48.78% |
| 16 | Staravia / Roselia | 42 | 10.29% | 52.38% |
| 48 | Staravia / Servine | 25 | 6.13% | 48.00% |
67/82, its paired with Serv or Rose.
The point is, offensive checks alone cannot get you by against Serv. They cannot switch into Glare because they lose their entire purpose of being fast breakers if they do, they usually are frail and get chipped easily, and rarely do they survive til the lategame. A lot of the more common breakers such as Monf and Busk also typically sacrifice themselves to chip Pokemon like Marshtomp too. These Pokemon arent used just for serv so they cant survive long enough to consistently act as a check, and thats why nearly all teams with these kinds of offensive counterplay still pack a Serv or Rose.
4) Arguing against some of these antiban posts
I'm too lazy to argue against every specific point raised by people, but if you do have an antiban argument you want to lob my way, tag me on Discord.
A general point I want to make towards all antiban people is that they seem to heavily want to overestimate servs capabilities, then claim that because it doesn't do everything it wants to do, its flawed and healthy. If servines biggest flaw is that it cannot often act as an early game defensive check and wall softener then sweep late game, that supports proban, not antiban. If serv was genuinely capable of shrugging off hits like that early game, switching into a third of the tier, then still pick up three kills late game, there would be no debate. No other Pokemon, except maybe clef, even offers you the ability to play any role from defensive support, wall softener, or wallbreaker/wincon at team preview. Serv lets you pick which role you want it to play at preview and is so good, it can still do multiple roles in a game. No other Pokemon can invest fully into its defenses, while still being one of the most potent breakers in the tier, and it also has the option to luck through checks if all else fails. A lot of my replays showcase this, servine switches into attacks and clicks Knock and Glare early game, then survives long enough to break late game. If you expect it to do all this every game, again, you expect far too much. The fact that serv is capable of so much in a meta which heavily preps for it is proof that its incredibly centralising.
Another general point I want to make is to fully explain how Serv has warped the meta. Many of you cite the argument of 'I can slap a lot of the most viable mons on a team and naturally have multiple checks, both offensive and defensive to serv so it doesnt affect me in builder'. To those people, I'd ask you to look at our top used Pokemon and our VR. Number 1, 2 and 5 of the most used Pokemon in this meta is Serv, Rose and Grimer, 1, 2 and 3 for best defensive Serv checks. Number 3 is Monferno, one of Serv's better offensive checks, 10 is staravia, offensive sets are typically seen as reliable offensive checks, 11 is haunter, then you have two 'checks' in steel types Pawn and Metang at 13 and 14, and then vull, toge and combusken take 18, 19, and 20 respectively. 11 of our top 20 mons in terms of usage are either its best defensive counterplay, decent offensive checks or mons that are seen as checks but aren't. How is Serv still the best Pokemon in the tier despite this heavy level of warping and the fact that half of our top 20 mons in terms of usage check it defensively or offensively? People pack so much counterplay for it, either naturally or consciously, but it's still the best mon in the tier and still is capable of sweeping while performing defensive and wall softening roles.
More importantly, I see people complain a lot about Machoke recently. Why aren't you using Gloom or Quilladin or other defensive Machoke counters? Because you can't. Using any Grass-type that isn't serv or rose heavily weakens your serv matchup to the point where you would have to stack checks upon checks to not outright lose to it and 5 teammates. Servine has warped this meta to heavily favour spdef walls which defensively check it. Roselia and Vullaby are the big two. You need incredibly sturdy defensive serv counterplay because of how easy it is for serv to boost up. No other high ranking offensive Pokemon in the tier can boost and attack with ease like serv does, while weakening its own checks and counters with knock/glare to potentially break past them, or allow a teammate to beat them, later in the game. Plus it then can tank even SE STAB from our strongest special attackers; none of our fast frail special attackers come close to boasting that.
5) Replays
The first batch of replays are Serv teams vs teams with various degrees of offensive and defensive counterplay for it. They all highlight some facet of serv that I've brought up at some point, and each replay has a little paragraph to explain exactly what serv does. These are all here to prove how different a 6v6 game is from the 1v1 check scenarios that a lot of antiban people are suggesting. Keep in mind I also excluded borderline replays, and thst these were all filed away after watching these PL games. I didn't check every replay, so there's probs more too.
Serv Replays
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-945664510
TTK vs Leo, TTK had 3 Pokemon he would list as offensive Servine checks in Klang, Monf and Haunter. None of the offensive checks he listed beat Serv in the game. He needed his own defensive check in Serv to stall Leo Serv of all Leaf Storm PP, the other checks forced Servine out once or twice but none of them bar opp Serv beat Serv in the game because they could not switch into it. Good example of why you cant get by with just offensive checks, because some of your defensive mons will let Serv in and you have to pick one each time or let your speed control get Glared. You can't rely on offensive checks in a 6v6 TTK, its not that simple, as you yourself have proved here. Serv's role for most teams is to provide defensive utility and knock early game, then survive and try to break late game. A lot of its offensive checks don't have the longevity to survive til late game. If TTK did not have a Serv, he would have had to pick one or let his offensive counterplay get glared everytime.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-947959118
Perfect PL example of how threatening the ServGrimes core is. Quag slowly chipped at the Roselia, forced it to synth since you need health to check Serv, then trapped it with Grimer. Even if Ampha doubled, the net positive is still in the Servine users favour because they prevent either Spikes or recovery from happening. But yh Rose got trapped, the combusken got revenge killed eventually, then serv beat a CM clef and killed 4 mons. Great example of how dangerous the ServGrimes core is vs teams relying on Rose and how it can fuck you.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-948359043
My favourite PL replay tbh, and a great example of how prepping for one Serv set can completely fuck you over if its not the one you expect. At team preview, Lock looks adequately prepared for Servine. He has his own defensive Defog serv as a defensive check/switch in, offensive Staravia, Lampent and Pawniard (not a Serv check but ppl still claim it is). Defog Serv cant fit Glare. It then turns out the Star is banded. Both Band Star and Lamp are fantastic 220 speed serv checks, but theyre dogshit vs boosted 291 serv. Ktut brought 291 serv, serv got 3 kills then Lock forfeited. Shows howcdifficult prepping for all Serv sets is, some checks to slower sets are not checks to faster sets.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-948971871
Another good example of how Serv vs Serv just turns into a cripple war, regardless of how much offensive counterplay you're packing. A metagame where Serv's are 1v1ing and crippling each other because all other defensive counterplay has their own issues is not healthy. Also shows again how Serv can outlast offensive and defensive checks like Monf, Grimes, Comb etc.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-948980660
Another classic tbh, great example of how bullshit Glare is. Ktut preserves his Grimes til the end game specifically for Dado's Serv. However, Glare does what it does best. Two paras later, Ktut goes from a guaranteed win to needs to win a 50/50 because of back to back paras. He loses said coinflip. Perfect example of how late game Glare and Serv reduce skillful play, shows how uncompetitive Glare is.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-950485314
Another classic, arctic has rose, vull and grimes. I cant see a core more prepped and ready for serv than that. Serv even missed two early game leaf storms, but what happens? The rose gets chipped and eventually trapped by Cheryls grimer, then serv chips and muscles through arctics grimer, beats a twave clef, then breaks kad sash. Marsh also burns the vull to make it not a serv check. Proof that, in a 6v6, defensive checks can easily be worn down or removed by teammates for serv, and a similar argument applies for offensive checks. Servs defensive bulk and longevity lets it survive til the end game to break.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nfe-956888882
Again, another example of how dangerous the ServGrimes core is. Quag traps the Rose early game with grimes. Staravia gets glared, serv comes in late game, breaks, gets one para on star, gg. Hys only had rose and defensive star for serv and it was super easy for serv to clean late game. Proof that u need a lot of offensive counterplay on top of defensive counterplay for serv, cause said defensive counterplay is too susceptible to chip, trapping and being weakened or being glared through.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nfe-956982844
ServGrimes again. Grime traps Rose, serv then gets two kills and breaks through the defensive backbone of the team for other teammates. Prankin had no offensive serv counterplay, just rose, and it got trapped for serv to break.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nfe-957368402
Both teams at preview have sufficient offensive or defensive counterplay. Excluding serv itself, Dado has vull, grimes, and haka I suppose. Offler has good offensive and defensive counterplay in mag, monf, and metang. None of these offensive and defensive checks survive til the end game but both servs do make it that far. Game comes down to a glared serv on serv war. Shows that offensive counterplay is unreliable, its rare for a lot of these offensive fires to survive long enough to beat serv in the end game.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nfe-964374469
Both have good offensive counterplay. Lamp chips Cam's grimes. PDs serv then breaks through grimes and even beats a Haunter that came in on a free switch. It ate a super effective STAB sludge wave from one of the strongest special attackers in the tier. Cam's serv does a lot less but turn 27/28 is significant. After PDs serv muscles through a chipped grimes, beats Haunter (a supposed check) off the bat, 12% serv gets one opportunity to heal up, beats Kad, then almost beats clef if not for a leaf storm dodge. Even in games where serv gets heavily chipped, it needs one opportunity to heal up on a slower defensive mon and it becomes a massive threat again, but you dont get your check back. Again, shows how teammates weaken serv checks and highlights how insane its special bulk is relative to how good it is offensively.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nfe-965263841
I think this is the perfect serv busted replay. Elgino's Serv knocks off the Magmar Specs on the switch, takes 60 from non-Specs FB and glares it, makes it useless as a serv check. It attempts to fish for paras and synths, blink switches. It then comes back in to kill the Machoke, beats a slightly boosted CM clef, then comes back in later to clean with buzz and krok.
This second batch is for replays of Serv against a team without a Serv or a Rose. There's 6 replays here. Keep in mind that only 23ish% of teams do not have either on it, then keep in mind that only 40ish% of teams have serv on it. The amount of tour replays where this type of mu at team preview happens is pretty low, so the fact that I've got 6 good ones is a significant number.
Serv vs no Serv/Rose
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-953987545
Another great replay. PDs team is p wack, it doesnt really support serv that well in terms of breaking checks. Lock has a haunter, monf and slig. Slig gets chipped, serv is used to revenge kill a weakened Haunter cause its blown the Z move. Lategame serv wins one 50/50 vs the monf, proceeds to kill tang too. Again, highlights how insane servs bulk is, when its used to revenge kill a Pokemon like Haunter who hits it with strong SE STAB attack.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nfe-961902952
WMAR just has monf and offensive star as serv checks. No defensive checks. Neither mon survives to lategame. Servine beats double dance kad, kills mareanie then kills clef. Easy serv clean vs a team with no defensive serv counterplay and two offensive checks.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-894661936
Serv glared and knocked a toge, proceeded to Storm up and got 3 kiils. More importantly, it ate a Z Outrage from Fraxure. Fraxure has 117 base Attack, one of the highest in the tier. Highlights how dangerous Serv can be when its not against Rose and how difficult it is to revenge kill for teams that don't have specific defensive counters to it.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-887036423
This is a quality game which highlights how stupid Glare can be. You can make judgements about how the early game was played, fair enough, but turn 24 onwards is what I want to highlight. Marj has a full hp evio metang as a serv check. Most tangs have massive 4mss and can't even beat serv unless they get lucky with mash boosts, but marj is able to fit toxic on hers, which should beat Serv. Turn 33 serv knocks tang. Turn 38 serv starts. Two paras and a miss later Serv wins. On top of Glare hax, Serv also consistently provided incredible defensive utility by constantly switching into Buzz Vswitch thoughout the game. Friso himself proves here that Toxic on Serv isnt a be all end all where, once its crippled, its useless. Despite being Toxiced, Serv pulled through and beat some of its checks with some luck.
6) Final Thoughts
I think I've written 4 posts about Servine now.
First one explaining why it's good,
second one focussed on Serv/Rose as a whole and how they unhealthily warp the meta in a restricitive and centralising way, and
third one was a response to some arguments. This will be my last post on Serv. If you do wanna argue with me though, you can tag on Discord or, even better, I'm challenging anyone on the antiban side to Servine Smackdown v2, this time me (and any proban people who want to join) vs any antiban people who want to join, on the weekend. Pick a time and, if I can do it, I'll be there. Depending on how many people turn up (if any), it'll probably be a clusterfuck, but it should be fun and entertaining for both sides.