I would say give every new status move "Resets lowered stats" as their Z-effect since that's what most status moves have as their Z-effect and it's a safe bet. Not sure what you guys will think about my suggestion.
HeatEdgeSword said:I would say this still enters into Pet Mod territory as it's a custom change to mechanics.I would say give every new status move "Resets lowered stats" as their Z-effect since that's what most status moves have as their Z-effect and it's a safe bet. Not sure what you guys will think about my suggestion.
Sereg said:PS are going to make a National OU format so I doubt they would want to make it into a pet mod.Still a good idea if you find being a pet mod acceptable
wrink said:The issue is that it's incredibly awkward and very obviously not how these mechanics are supposed to work.is there an issue with just making cut and new moves unusable as max and z moves respectively?
DrPumpkinz said:you're right, it's not, but even if nobody cares about z moves, return frustration hidden power and pursuit still are still in demand. if we make an ND meta, the choices are cutting them, which is against the spirit of ND, adapting them, which is pet mod territory unless we can find a rule that covers all cases, or making them unusable under conditions in which we dont have a defined effect for them.The issue is that it's incredibly awkward and very obviously not how these mechanics are supposed to work.
Heavyweapons Mann said:All moves of a certain BP will have the same BP as each other when they are Max Moves but no actual formula.Is there a formula for Max BP Moves or is it a move-by-Move basis?
wrink said:Except leaving them cut isn't against the spirit on ND at all. The only stipulation of a ND meta is that the game doesn't block you from transfering regular Pokemon just because they're a certain species of Pokemon. Moves getting cut is no different than not being able to transfer a Pokemon up because it knows an HM move.if we make an ND meta, the choices are cutting them, which is against the spirit of ND
Arai said:what about variable power moves like return and frustration?All moves of a certain BP will have the same BP as each other when they are Max Moves but no actual formula.
DrPumpkinz said:Except leaving them cut isn't against the spirit on ND at all. The only stipulation of a ND meta is that the game doesn't block you from transfering regular Pokemon just because they're a certain species of Pokemon. Moves getting cut is no different than not being able to transfer a Pokemon up because it knows an HM move.
Oh, and if anyone is wondering what would happen with Unown if cut moves aren't brought back, the answer is simple: it would remain untransferable. This isn't an arbitrary decision to avoid complications, but rather the logical conclusion of the game's transfer rules if they were tweaked to not discriminate against species. From what I've read from the move rejection messages, it sounds like you have to delete all cut moves from a Pokemon's moveset before it's able to be transferred. Because you can't remove a Pokemon's only move, it would be impossible to remove Hidden Power from Unown, so any legitimate Unown would remain impossible to transfer. In theory, if you hacked an Unown to know something other than Hidden Power, it could be transferred without a hitch, assuming there isn't also an illegal moveset check.
The Immortal said:There's no need to have this argument. There will be NatDex and NatDxe+. One is a OM, one is a Pet Mod. One does not prevent the other from existing. One has a general rule, one has several specific and subjective rules. Those who like the minimal one can play the minimal one. Those that want all their favorite deleted mechanics will have all their favorite deleted mechanics. Please stop flooding this thread unnecessarily. Thank you.
wrink said:can I ask one last question? when you say + will be a pet mod, do you mean its going to be individual user-to-user challenges only? if so, im not sure shutting down this conversation is fair. the entire goal of the discussion is to remove subjectivity from the rules so that it can be a metagame
Petuuuhhh said:This is gonna be a regular OM my manSwSh Anti-MetaThis meta would be all the cut mons from SwSh. All the cut moves would be illegal and no Mega Evolution or Z-Moves.
Yung Dramps said:I think he means ONLY the cut monsThis is gonna be a regular OM my man
Gravity Monkey said:yeI think he means ONLY the cut mons
Gravity Monkey said:I think he means ONLY the cut mons
Petuuuhhh said:ye
Yung Dramps said:It isn't a Pet Mod, it's an OM ideaI see. Still a pretty crappy idea IMO. Pet Mod approvers don't take too kindly to formats that just shuffle around the usable Pokemon list with no other changes (I know from experience trying to sub a format where all legendaries, megas and z-crystals were banned)
Petuuuhhh said:same thing appliesIt isn't a Pet Mod, it's an OM idea
Petuuuhhh said:At its base I do not think this idea would be approved. It seems like a pointlessly restrictive version of All-Dex OU. I don't see what appeal this has over that meta or even gen 7 OU.It isn't a Pet Mod, it's an OM idea
Petuuuhhh said:Why would this be approved? All you are doing is changing the Pokemon you are able to use (aka the Pokemon cut from the game).SwSh Anti-MetaThis meta would be only the cut mons from SwSh. All the cut moves would be illegal and no Mega Evolution or Z-Moves.
Arai said:Why is nat dex approved? All they're doing is adding Pokemon you are able to use (aka the Pokemon cut from the game).Why would this be approved? All you are doing is changing the Pokemon you are able to use (aka the Pokemon cut from the game).