UncleSam said:The Democratic Party of the 1980s was most certainly not to the left of where it is today. You’re telling me that you believe Jimmy Carter or Walter Mondale were to the left of any of the current candidates or Obama? They got primaried by the left of the party back then for being insufficiently pure.
You are making an apples to oranges comparison. I would argue that the party had started its rightward move at least since the death of JFK, but really accelerated in the 80's and 90's culminating into the election of Bill Clinton. Carter may have been to the right of his opponents but he would still be considered farther to the left of any other Democrat that has been president after him. If anything, Carter is among the best pieces of evidence of the party's rightward shift since this is the man who not only endorsed Sanders in 2016 but also refused to vote for Clinton in the general. It should be very telling that Carter spent his post presidential years advocating for human rights and teaching sunday school classes while "mainstream" democrats of today like Obama and Clinton have collected boatloads of cash from closed Wall Street speeches.
No, the only way to say the Democrats have moved right is to compare the left wing of the party then to the right wing of the party now. The branch of the party that has actually won elections has always been either the right wing of the party or the main stream of it. There’s never been a progressive wing candidate nominated who didn’t get slaughtered by the Republicans (I’m talking modern political era here btw, the parties didn’t line up in a meaningful way to current political paradigms before 1960 or so) because the fact is that independents don’t want someone who is going to upend the existing political structure.
Yet again you are being extremely disingenuous. The point I am making is that the "mainstream" of the party is what has shifted right, ie the policy positions of your average Democrat. Also, it's clear that you didn't read my previous post where I mentioned that Obama won with a record number of votes in 2008 when he ran as a progressive. It was not until after he was elected where he was exposed as being more in line with the "mainstream" of the party rather than progressives.
Your point about independents is also hilariously wrong. Speaking as an independent, I can tell you that Sanders does better with independents which
the data overwhelmingly supports. That is precisely because independents (and a large chunk of people who historically don't vote) do want to upend the existing political structure as they understand that our two parties have allied themselves with the elites and professionals rather than the working class.
Democrats can win with right wingers like Clinton but tend to do best when they nominate candidates from the center of the party, like Obama. Someone like Klobuchar, Buttigieg, or Yang would probably do well in a general election, but none of them have a serious shot at the nomination.
Again, how can you make this argument when the only democratic presidential candidate of our lifetime who ran as a progressive won with both a record total number of votes and overall voter turnout? Back then, the pundits were saying that Americans were too racist and backwards to ever elect someone whose middle name is Hussein and the right-wing media relentlessly called him a socialist, yet they were all proven wrong. Obama's posturing to the center was not until after winning in 2008, and both his voter turnout and margin of victory was significantly lower in 2012. And in spite of the fact her opponent was heavily despised, Hillary Clinton got even less votes in 2016. She over-performed in the liberal elite coastal cities which are full of professionals but failed to win key states in the Midwest whose working class residents have been the most negatively impacted by the neoliberal economic policies of the modern Democratic party. I agree that Yang could do well in a general election since at least he offers something that energizes voters (ie UBI) but the other two you mentioned? I don't see why it wouldn't be a repeat of 2016.
If you look at the results of the midterm elections, my point should be even more obvious. In 2014 many Democrats
ran further to the right of Obama but got absolutely destroyed as voter turnout was laughably low. This is the part where a naive person might argue that this result just confirms the neoliberal Democrat talking point that our voters have moved farther to the right, but the reality is that their voting race isn't going to be motivated to turn out and vote if their candidates aren't going to offer them anything to be excited about. Although turnout somewhat improved in 2018, Democrats still somehow failed to take back the Senate despite Trump's unpopularity even though Republicans were able to easily reclaim both chambers of Congress during Obama's presidency.
The only candidates with a real shot at the nomination are Biden and Sanders. Biden would beat Trump but would likely underperform his current polling, lead to poor Dem performances in 2022 and 2024, and probably be an ineffectual president whose primary contribution would be enabling RBG to die in peace and not get replaced by Trump.
This is probably the only portion of your post I somewhat agree with, but I am honestly not convinced that Biden is as electable as the pundits would like us to believe. I could see why some people might if they believe that Clinton lost in 2016 primarily because of her gender, James Comey, and the Russians, but if you ask me a Biden general election campaign (and Klobuchar or Buttigieg campaign) would just be a repeat of 2016 and fail to offer anything other than being the lesser of two evils, which is not a great position to be in knowing that Trump's approval ratings are actually higher now than they were in 2016.
Bernie would get crucified in a general election because the reality is that the wealthy Democratic Party machine would abandon him.
It seems you have forgotten that the entire point of the Sanders campaign is to win without the backing of the wealthy party machine. And he has managed to take a frontrunner position in early primary states while being the only candidate among the frontrunners to fully reject corporate PAC money.
All the favorable news coverage on center left networks that Democrats tend to be able to take for granted would be gone.
What news coverage are you watching? Because Sanders has mostly been ignored by the media throughout the campaign so far, and he has been
covered far more negatively than the other leading candidates. And this article was written prior to the recent barrage of negative coverage the Sanders campaign has received over laughably false sexism allegations, whereas Warren's numbers have been trending downward in spite of very favorable media coverage. Maybe you ought to consider that voters, now more than ever, have less trust in the corporate media outlets (CNN, MSNBC, and Fox) than you seem to be giving them credit for?
The data shows that this is in a longterm downward trend.
All the fundraising prowess of the Clinton and Obama machines would abandon him.
Again... Bernie's goal is to win without relying on their money anyway, because if he doesn't, how could he be held accountable to the promises that he makes? This seems to be a point that has been lost on so many and is something I wish the Sanders campaign said more often, but the fact that most of the other candidates are relying on corporate money to win is precisely why they are against policy positions that are mainstream in the rest of the developed world like single payer healthcare systems (eg. medicare for all).
But even if you disagreed, at least acknowledge that
Trump beat Clinton anyway in spite of being outspent 2 to 1. And that the two billionaires in the race aren't polling that well in spite the amount of money they have spent.
Wealthy government employees in the Northern Virginia suburbs, Philadelphia suburbs, and Southeastern Michigan, among many other electorally influential areas, would abandon him.
You are trying to make this argument even though working class voters who greatly outnumber professionals in key battleground states who previously voted for Obama abandoned Clinton in 2016? If you are going to argue that these affluent voters are willing to either sit out or vote for Trump just because someone who is actually principled wins the nomination, then that is probably as big of an indictment of the modern democratic party as you can get, considering that these people (among many others) spent 4 years calling Trump the most immoral president in the history of our country.
You don’t have to believe me that the center of the party would rather let Bernie get massacred by Trump to keep control over the party and away from the left if you don’t want to
Oh I believe you alright, which is precisely why the media has already been overwhelmingly against him, and yet he is still making a comeback somehow.
odds are Biden will win out, perform extremely mediocrely
Indeed, I also think he is still the favorite in part because Sanders as well as the media have been far too easy on him (and all his opponents for that matter). Perhaps things might change though if Sanders is able to do well in New Hampshire and Iowa.
and the left can go back to talking about how Bernie would’ve won a thousand electoral votes against Trump and a host of other nonsense. But the only reason Bernie polls well for now is because he’s not seen as a serious threat by either political establishment or by independent voters, many of whom are extremely privileged white suburban voters who think its trendy to change political tunes with the times and who don’t actually have any strongly held beliefs at all.
And
the data proves you wrong again on just about every single one of these points! (see page 114)! And plenty of other polls have shown that Sanders draws his support primarily from the working class. What irks me is that you somehow are unable to see that just maybe, some people who are not doing that well want more than superficial changes and platitudes?
If Bernie wins the nomination save this post because the race will be over by October and Trump will probably win the PV on top of a sizable EC win.
Based on what concrete evidence exactly?
He is too far left
Even though left-wing policies like medicare for all have
majority support. That's why the biggest obstacle Sanders faces is well-to-do professionals who are stuck inside their urban bubbles where they think the rest of the country is too batshit insane and stupid to support commonsense policies that are commonplace in the rest of the developed world.
too old
Even though Trump is just a few years younger...
too white
Trump, Sanders, Biden, Warren, and Buttigieg are all white. What makes Sanders "too" white?
too male to pull enough people together to beat the Cheeto monster.
You know, maybe most voters actually care more about what the candidates actually stand for than the color of their skin or their gender?