Ztest said:Hello,
I believe I'm the first good vocal player to really catch on to the potential this thing has. I was really struggling to peak this meta and Thievul did it for me practically on its own.
Regardless if it's broken or not, Thievul is the best mon in this meta by far, here are my reasons.
1. Free set up/1 turn titan
Rillaboom in this tier is amazing on it's own and proves to be an even better partner for Thievul, who only benefits from terrain. You can add these two to any team and make it viable against all archetypes.
Thievul's access to Nasty Plot and grassy recovery is what puts it levels above any other unburden mon. Thievul becomes incredibly bulky with seed, and it's natural special defense means it will survive most strong neutral moves, evading 2hkos with grassy restore. The additional HP that Thievul can restore (which the other unburden mons can't) means that it has essentially a +1 def leftovers item, unmatched by any other terrain seed combination, limited as it may be.
What I would like to emphasize is that this 132 spdef mon can go from zero to +2 speed +1def +2 spa in 1 turn. Nothing else can do close to this. The only thing that I can think to compare is Xerneas. Yes, you're sacrificing an item slot, but it doesn't really matter when you are getting insane bulk and power in just 1 turn. Thievul is a 1 turn will decide if I win the whole game type mon.
2. Coverage/Niche counter play
Thievul's limited movepool is a complete non-problem, it has exactly the tools it needs. Psychic is perfect for Toxapex and Thro, which would naturally be answers to a set up dark type. Grass Knot ohkos Quagsire, which would naturally be an answer to a set up dark type. Dark pulse offers a strong stab move that can flinch just to top it off.
Really think about how good it is to be able to beat not only the top Regenerator mon but also the top Unaware mon, plus beat a whole type that you're weak to, PLUS get a free +2 speed +1 def boost. No other set up sweeper has this flexibility. Of course I know fairies can easily counter, but offensively this is the perfect moveset for an unburden sweeper. This leads to extremely niche counter play, there is only 2 ways to beat Thievul after it set up. You can either have a mon that avoids the 2hko and pressures it, or have a mon that 1hkos it and lives in return. This may seem like a big pool of pokemon but it truly isn't, if you don't have a specific mon dedicated to counter play Thievul, you will lose. Thievul centralizes teams.
3. Impossible to revenge/too fast
Thievul's massive 130 speed being doubled by unburden is perhaps it's best attribute. This allows for you to naturally outspeed all scarfers, all other unburden mons, and even weather boosted mons. This limits revenge speed counter play to either priority or opposing Thievul. Common speed creepers like fake out espeed Pikachu fail to do nearly enough. Additionally, Thievul can easily eat a mach punch/vacuum wave and ohko fighters/Pikachu in return. What this leaves us with is the simple inability to outspeed Thievul. Nothing on your team right now (that isn't another Thievul) can outspeed mine after it's been unburdened. I think that's a problem for a mon that can boost +2 easily, though I will admit there is a lot of counterplay HO can incorporate. First impression and sash for example can alleviate the match up for offense, though they are inherently circumstantial.
I predict that we will see in upspike in usage for this mon as more and more people realize it's potential. I am hoping this post will also shed some light. I really like Thievul and honestly I would hate to see it go, but I also have beat on this meta ladder enough to realize what's best for it.
This is actually an excellent post, but I still disagree.
Thievul was definitely a surprise with how good it was, despite its terrible movepool.
Firstly, yes, Grassy Seed+Unburden is a pretty good way to get your Unburden boost, and Thievul can get away with being bulkier thank to Unburden and Thievul having 130 Spe. This is very similar to what people used in Gen 7 OU with Tapu Koko and Hawlucha.
However, 1 problem with Unburden is that it’s strictly a late game clean up.
If you’re forced to switch out too early, you better hope you removed the opponent’s fast Pokemon, since you’re not getting it back. Compared to an ability like Swift Swim, Unburden is less flexible despite having the same boost since the conditions for Swift Swim can be utilized throughout a game and doesn’t require a consumable item.
This isn’t to say Unburden is bad or outclassed by weather speed abilities since it isn’t blocked by opposing weather and last as long as you don’t switch.
There is also the problem of Thievul not always getting a free Nasty Plot. Sure, you have Psychic for Fighting types, but do you really trust that it can KO at full health? And do you trust that Fighting STAB won’t kill because of Unburden?
Thievul sure is Bulky. bulky enough to tank an Icicle Crash from Beartic, but not bulky enough to tank STAB Close Combats multiple times or STAB Playrough.
Secondly, there is a few things you didn’t consider.
With DP, Psychic, and GK, you aren’t getting past most Dark types.
Skuntank and Scrafty really shit all over Thievul as defensive counterplay.
Pyukumuku is also a good answer as it heals from Grassy Terrain and doesn’t care about Thievul’s stat boosts, while not being OHKO’d from a x4 grass knot.
Bulky fairy types also work really well against Thievul, as even a +2 Psychic or Grass Knot won’t do much.
It doesn’t even have to be that bulky of a fairy type. Rapidash-Galar is bulky enough to stomach a Dark Pulse and KO it back pretty easily.
Ludicolo is also a pretty good option. In Rain, Ludicolo hits Thievul really hard. Even when using enough EVs to outspeed +2 Modest Ludicolo (96 Speed EVs), Thievul still struggled to beat it since a Rain Boosted LO Hydro Pump hits hard and Ludicolo itself is pretty specially bulky. On top of Ludicolo benefiting from Grassy Terrain more than Thievul does.
Trust me when I say that Thievul definitely needs support from its teammates with chip damage and threat removal.
For comparison, while we got to play with +40 Rapidash-Galar for the few days, it was an absolute beast. Life Orb Swords Dance, Play Rough, Zen Headbutt, and High Horsepower could trade half of the opponent’s team since it would be as fast as the fast electric types like Manetric, it had coverage only resisted by Bonzong, and it has excellent bulk for the power and speed you got from Rapidash-Galar. It was very easy to switch on the field because of its bulk, immunity to Toxic, and how it can easily kill you before you could move.
If Rapidash-G wasn’t recently banned from PU, I would say it would the Pokemon most suspect worthy. It can be used pretty liberally with huge amounts of pay off.
Thievul has a good pay off but requires more patience and teammates to soften up the opposing team.
Third, like I said earlier, Ludicolo is an excellent revenge killer for Thievul. Even when running a set to specifically to outspeed Modest Ludicolo by as much as possible with the rest invested into HP, Ludicolo that’s healthy enough can severally punish you for over extending.
Revenge killing isn’t always about speed and going first. It does help, but it’s mostly about forcing a Switch/Sack on a weakened Pokemon too.
I did find myself over extending with Thievul where a +2 Dark Pulse just barely misses an OHKO.