Volt-Ikazuchi said:Grass is usually seen as a liability with the silver lining of good status utility tho.
Grass has pretty good defensive niches when paired with certain other types (all of its resistances save itself are very nice to have). See especially: Ferrothorn. Offensively it's mainly good because it hits Water and Ground super effectively (particularly when they're on the same Pokémon

). Kinda the opposite of Dragon: a mediocre/bad STAB but very critical coverage for some Pokémon.
I don't really want to make a tier list of games RN but I'll post my thoughts on each of them:
RBY
These games just don't hold up well from a QoL standpoint at all. You can play them for/with the glitches, sure, but when status menus are bare and irritating to navigate, HMs require you to go into your party to use, an on-person bag of 20 and only 50 additional slots available in the PC, and, AI aside, in-game trainers only have their level up movesets 99% of the time, they just don't do a lot to spice up battles. If they had the QoL improvements Gen 2 had they'd be better--still probably the worst to play through casually of all the games, but much more playable. I do love Cerulean Cave as a postgame dungeon, though; its wild Pokémon tables are extremely varied and fun to experience. I also respect being able to buy most evolution stones freely; it's frustrating that they've either been hair-pullingly scarce or an annoying grind to obtain in almost every game since.
GSC
Not going to lie, I'm on the nostalgia train for these games, but I also admit that they have some pretty big flaws. The level curve (though I consider this a slightly bigger issue in the remakes, more on that later), limited access to the Johto Pokémon (especially the ones locked to Kanto, most notably every Dark type except Umbreon and Sneasel in Crystal), the choice to have most of the Johto Gym Leaders use Gen 1 Pokémon as aces, an unrewarding (and not really challenging) evil team encounter... they have problems. But, as I mentioned earlier, the QoL additions they got over RBY make a world of difference, and theyve been things that have stuck with the series since. The games also have some of the best dungeon designs in the series, IMO. Kanto is fairly barren, but that's the natural result of having to cram two regions into an already stretched GB cart. Oh, and they introduced shinies. That's pretty cool! Some of the additions like gender have clear implementation problems that more or less get fixed in Gen 3.
I'm including Crystal in with Gold and Silver because I don't think its differences cause it to stand out. It introduced the Battle Tower, which is probably one of the most important postgame additions in the series, and its implementation is even unique! They also added move tutors, something that I think is good mostly because it allowed for certain moves to be taught infinitely before TMs were made unbreakable. It was also the first game with mobile connectivity (back in 2000-2001). I appreciate the added lore for Johto; not having to chase Suicune down is an improvement, but you still have to catch Raikou and Entei if you want to catch Ho-oh, which is... bad (IMO). The Pokégear calls for items, especially evolutionary stones, is nice, but it also adds more strain on the already limited memory space in the Pokégear.
RS
These games had the original Dexit, and I wasn't really on the internet to know what the level of outrage was with it. Of course, it was only from accessibility, as all Pokémon were still in the code, and it was gradually undone across the course of Gen 3. With that out of the way Ruby and Sapphire are kinda bare by themselves. Nothing of a postgame to speak of except the basic Battle Tower, and they went a little ham with the version exclusives. For all the crap Hoenn gets, it's a big region with a fairly diverse group of Pokémon to find. Pretty good biome diversity too! Unfortunately the Pokémon diversity doesn't extend to the water routes (at least by just Surfing). Oh, I almost forgot. Running Shoes. Thank you.
FRLG
The first remakes of the series, FireRed and LeafGreen are, for the most part, faithful to Red and GreenBlue, for better or worse. They carry with them Kanto's lack of distinct biomes and occasionally corrected encounter tables (you don't find wild fire horses in Pokémon Mansion anymore, and Cerulean Cave's encounters feel more like a relatively generic cave level). Being restricted to Kanto Pokémon, and the game reminding you of that by showing your Pokémon trying to evolve (but can't) is kinda stupid. However, they DID add a good number of new areas in the Sevii Islands (which also fixes the biome problem a little bit, and gives Moltres an actually good location), and these games notably introduced the VS Seeker and stronger Elite Four rematches to the series, so I give them points for that. They do what they set out to do, with a little bit of an expanded world for the veteran player to explore. The move tutors that use some of the old TMs from RBY are a nice touch.
Oh, one more thing: I very much enjoy Kanto's map layout (this is true for both RBY and FRLG).
Emerald
Emerald was a little bit ambitious with trying to cram the plots of Ruby and Sapphire into one game, and for the most part it succeeds. It causes both teams to be presented as an actual threat (as opposed to the originals where the team you were NOT actively fighting against was little more than a setpiece), and gave Groudon a reasonable location to be woken up from (instead of, you know, the bottom of the ocean. Maybe if it was its corpse). Hoenn itself is largely identical to Ruby and Sapphire, but where Emerald really shines is in its postgame. The Battle Frontier is, perhaps, an acknowledgement of players who know more about the series' inner workings than Game Freak is willing to openly expose, and a place for them to really test what they can do. Emerald also added Gym Leader rematches, something I feel is worth noting.
DP
These games are just lacking in the oddest areas. Introduce ~25 new evolutions for older Pokémon but only have a handful of them obtainable in the main game? Surf speed matching walking speed? A painfully limited regional dex as a crappy call-back to RBY, and one that forces alleged type "specialists" to have teams that aren't even half of their designated type? Diamond and Pearl manage all of these. Yet, for all of their flaws, Diamond and Pearl are (for the most part) challenging, with said challenge being fairly well-distributed along the game, and have a pretty good-sized postgame to explore (aided by the numerous daily events and swarms to have you check back to see what new Pokémon you can catch). I also want to go on record and say that I LOVE that the mythicals that aren't Manaphy have actual locations in Sinnoh for you to catch them (though I don't think these were legally used or distributed). The DS integration was decent with the Poketch (it was the first time I felt like I could actually use the Itemfinder), and while it has problems for players who pick the games up beyond their release date, I liked how inserting the GBA games into your DS caused Pokémon from those games to appear. A neat way to expand the available Pokémon to catch.
Platinum
It's hard to say whether Game Freak deliberately held content back from Diamond and Pearl to make Platinum stand out more (mostly thinking of the Pokédex here), but there's no denying that by fixing some of the QoL issues that DP had, drastically improving the Sinnoh Dex (it's almost certainly the most robust regional dex in the series that is still relatively limited), and tightening the story that Game Freak created something close to a masterpiece. And that's before you add in the Battle Frontier! Platinum is loaded with content, both during the main story and after, and it's unarguably a good game. The new move tutors seem geared to expand both strong options for STAB, as well as strong options for coverage, in addition to more tactical move choices. I guess it does lose a little charm when all of its specialists' teams are actually structured as they should be, but hey, that's a very minor (and arbitrary) flaw.
HGSS
HeartGold and SoulSilver are, inarguably, meant to be nostalgia bait. But with that nostalgia bait, Game Freak also added content to the games to improve the general experience. The touch screen usage is excellent, and, unlike FRLG, they allowed for the evolutions added in Gen 4 to be used pre-national Dex, as long as they were something that just happened organically (mostly the "learn-move-evolution" types). With the expanded memory, Kanto is actually more than just a framework again (most apparent in its dungeons, especially the ones cut from GSC). Gym Leader and Elite Four rematches are implemented (with the Gym Leader ones being a real guide dang it experience, sadly). Unfortunately HGSS do little to fix the originals' level curve (Kanto is stronger, but then so is Red), and only a handful of Pokémon that were Kanto-exclusive are available before the postgame. Adding Platinum's Battle Frontier is a nice bonus to give the games more life, but it's not what the games are designed for and it should only really be what you're playing for if you don't have Platinum. If you liked GSC, you'll like HGSS, but if you didn't like the originals they won't do much for you since they don't have the balance issues that were generally fixed from RBY to FRLG.
I'll do the rest tomorrow, this took too long.